Panel, Conference Presentation
2014 London Summit - Africa Rising: How Fast?
Milken InstituteMark Cutis, Jay Ireland, Kola Karim, Ben Kruger, Vimal Shah, June Sarpong, Nick Williams, Paul Links, Sandra, Tarek
Market Demographics and Growth Metrics
- Africa is projected to be the second-fastest growing region globally (post-developing Asia) with >5% annual GDP growth (through 2019).
- The continent is projected to hold the world's largest population by 2050.
- Urbanization is set to rise from 33% currently to 64% by 2030, driving massive consumption clustering.
- Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has tripled over the past decade, yet a $2 trillion annual infrastructure gap remains until 2020.
Investment Philosophy and Strategy
- On-the-Ground Presence: Success requires physical presence and long-term commitment; "flying in" from London or Dubai is insufficient due to the relationship-based culture.
- Patient Capital Required: Panelists (specifically Vimal Shah) warn against 5-year exit horizons targeting 25-30% returns, advocating instead for 10-15 year investment horizons to allow for infrastructure maturation and value creation.
- Sector Focus: Key investment areas include extractive industries (oil/gas), real estate, telecommunications, infrastructure, and agribusiness (where 60% of unused arable land exists).
- Regional Aggregation: East African Community (EAC) members (Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, Rwanda, Burundi, Ethiopia) offer a 150-250 million person market with harmonized customs, VAT, and free movement of labor, surpassing individual markets like Nigeria in scale.
- Local Partnerships: Multinational enterprises are advised to partner with agile, locally rooted African firms to navigate security risks and bureaucratic complexities that global giants often fail to address.
Technological Leapfrogging and Innovation
- Mobile Financial Services: Africa is ahead of Western markets in mobile banking (e.g., M-Pesa), enabling 10-minute account openings and "pay-per-use" utility models (e.g., hourly power purchases via mobile money).
- Healthcare Innovation: Mobile technology is utilized for remote diagnostics, including transmitting X-rays and using handheld ultrasounds for rural triage, bypassing traditional infrastructure limitations.
- Operational Standards: Modern African businesses operate at ISO-certified, world-class standards with real-time ERP integration, rejecting the notion of "second-class" operations.
Challenges and Risk Realities
- Infrastructure Deficits: Power generation and logistics (roads/rail) are critical bottlenecks; for example, Nigeria has roughly the same power capacity as the US state of Montana despite having 160+ million people.
- Banking Constraints: Commercial banks in Africa often require 100-125% asset collateralization for loans and struggle to provide working capital financing without hard assets.
- SME Financing Gap: While short-term working capital is accessible, long-term capital for SMEs, mortgages, and startups is scarce; high interest rates (up to 40% in some regions) persist.
- Risk Perception vs. Reality: Investors often overestimate political risk (which is insurable via MIGA/ATI at low costs) while underestimating credit risk; the "submerging market" concept suggests Africa is maturing faster than traditional emerging markets.
- Execution Speed: Large infrastructure projects face a "five-year negotiation, two-year construction" lag, where delays in approval widen the deficit daily.
Institutional and Policy Developments
- Governance Improvements: Nations like Kenya are shifting to hybrid models (e.g., devolved counties, separate judiciary) and enforcing quotas (e.g., one-third gender rule), making political systems more stable and predictable.
- Capital Market Evolution: Local financial institutions are scaling up, with single transactions growing from $50 million (requiring multiple banks a decade ago) to $400 million involving single African institutions.
- Public-Private Gaps: Development Finance Institutions (DFIs) are often criticized for "analysis paralysis" (2-3 year timelines), whereas private sector efficiency is needed; however, DFIs play a role in de-risking early-stage projects to make them bankable for private capital.
- Capital Formation: A critical barrier is the time required to raise large sums locally (e.g., 2 years in Africa vs. 1 week in the US), necessitating increased local capital formation.
Panelist Perspectives on Specific Sectors
- GE (Jay Ireland): Focuses on innovation driven by necessity (healthcare, power) and asserts that Africa's low labor costs are negated by logistical/power expenses, making efficiency and technology adoption paramount.
- Standard Bank (Ben Kruger): Emphasizes the need for world-class compliance (AML/financial crime) matching UK standards and identifies credit extension at only 12% in sub-Saharan Africa as a massive inclusion opportunity.
- Shoreline Energy (Kola Karim): Highlights that African entrepreneurs are uniquely positioned to manage security risks in oil/gas (e.g., in Nigeria) through community engagement that multinationals cannot replicate, taking over assets major oil companies have abandoned.
- Abu Dhabi Investment Council (Mark Cutis): Notes that while African banking is redefining itself (payments), investment ticket sizes are smaller, requiring a diversified approach across 50+ distinct countries rather than a single continental view.
- Bidco Group (Vimal Shah): Argues that SMEs are the economic engine but are hindered by a mismatch between investor return expectations (short-term) and the long-term development reality of the continent.