Panel, Conference Presentation
2014 London Summit - Capital Markets Outlook
Milken InstituteMichael Milken, Madelyn Antoncic, Richard Byrne, John Calamos Sr., Elroy Dimson, Thomas Finke, Mike, Rich Byrne
Regulatory Disintermediation of Traditional Banking
- Post-2008 Basel regulations (Basel 2.5/3) and the Volcker Rule forced major banks to exit high-risk activities, including proprietary trading ("prop desks") and middle-market direct lending.
- Middle-market lending volumes have shifted from legacy banks (e.g., JPMorgan, Deutsche Bank, Bank of America) to non-bank alternative capital providers (e.g., Ladder Financial, Benefit Street Partners, BDCs).
- Regulatory risk-weighted asset calculations made middle-market lending unattractive for banks by requiring equity capital levels comparable to those for single-B bonds, despite the business generating high returns on equity.
- Banks responded to capital constraints by reducing personnel costs, further shrinking their capacity to underwrite smaller loans (e.g., $50 million EBITDA companies) relative to larger deals.
- In the U.S., less than 20% of middle-market loans are now originated by traditional banks, compared to a heavily bank-dominated system in Europe where 80% of corporate credit still originates from banks.
- The $40 billion market cap of the Business Development Company (BDC) sector nearly matches the annual volume of middle-market loans banks previously underwrote, indicating rapid fill-in of the regulatory void.
Global Capital Allocation and Sovereign Wealth Trends
- Corporations, sovereign wealth funds, and individuals are holding record levels of cash; U.S. individuals doubled their net worth allocation to cash since 2007 (from ~5% to 10%, rising to 20% for the top 1% income bracket).
- Corporate cash reserves have surged dramatically: Apple's cash grew 11-fold ($15B to $164B), GE more than doubled, and Microsoft's cash increased from ~$23B to $88B.
- Japan's corporate cash now represents 44% of the nation's GDP, while Norway's Government Pension Fund Global (GPFG) has evolved into the world's largest sovereign wealth fund.
- Norway's GPFG operates on a "liability-asset matching" model (reverse of traditional pension funds), allowing it to be contrarian and absorb volatility, effectively acting as a natural portfolio insurer against market sentiment.
- Sovereign wealth funds and ultra-wealthy families are the only remaining truly long-term investors as pension funds and insurers have become increasingly short-term due to rising interest rate sensitivity on liabilities.
Regional Economic Risks and Capital Market Development
- China faces a potential "hard landing" risk with Q3 GDP at 7.3% (lowest in five years), threatening to drag down commodity prices and affecting developing economies like Nigeria (budget breakeven at $119/barrel) and Russia ($96/barrel).
- India remains highly susceptible to capital outflows when the U.S. Federal Reserve tightens monetary policy, due to heavy reliance on external financing.
- Capital market development is lagging in China and emerging markets, where 88% of companies are SMEs yet access to credit remains dominated by state-directed lending to large enterprises.
- Europe's economic stagnation is partly attributed to high bank leverage (assets 8-10x GDP in France vs. a fraction in the U.S.) and banks' reluctance to liquidate assets at par, creating a bottleneck for SME financing.
- The transition from investment-led to consumer-led growth in China has created overcapacity in commodities, causing significant price drops that negatively impact resource-dependent developing nations.
Investment Strategies and Market Dynamics
- Convertible Bonds: The convertible bond market is expanding, particularly in Europe, offering downside protection in volatile, low-yield environments and outperforming traditional bonds in 9 of the last 10 interest rate hikes.
- Equity vs. Fixed Income: With real short-term interest rates near zero, institutional investors are favoring equities and equity-linked securities (convertibles) over bonds, as fixed income offers negligible yield for the risk taken.
- High Dividend Yields: Historical data (1900–present) shows that countries with high dividend yields tend to outperform low-yield markets over the long term, as high yields often reflect traumatized, undervalued markets that eventually recover.
- Emerging vs. Developed Markets: Over a 100-year period, developed markets have historically outperformed emerging markets; performance parity emerged only in the post-1950 era, but emerging markets retain a beta of 1.3 relative to the global market.
- Asset Allocation: The "risk-free rate" has effectively hit zero, meaning future returns must come from explicit risk exposure (equity risk or alternative risk premiums) rather than time value of money.
- Liquidity Shifts: Dealer inventories have shrunk due to bank regulation, reducing market liquidity; institutional investors must now proactively provide liquidity rather than relying on street dealers.
Future Outlook and Social Impact
- The World Bank's Treasury is prioritizing the creation of catastrophic risk markets (e.g., weather derivatives for Uruguay, pandemic hedging for Ebola, longevity risk for pensions) to protect national budgets against climate and health shocks.
- The growth of the global middle class, expected to shift majority populations to Africa and Asia within 5–10 years, represents a massive, underexploited opportunity for consumer-driven capital markets.
- Capital markets have demonstrated efficacy in solving societal problems, such as the U.S. SO2 credit trading system which successfully eliminated acid rain without direct government mandates.
- There is a critical need to build capital market infrastructure in Latin America, the Middle East, and Africa to support SME growth and reduce global dependence on traditional banking intermediaries.