Interview, Fireside Chat
Barry Sonnenfeld, Filmmaker and Author of "Call Your Mother"
Early Life, Family Dynamics, and Career Entry
- In January 1969, Barry Sonnenfeld's mother orchestrated a public page at a Jimi Hendrix concert at Madison Square Garden at 2:20 AM, forcing him to call home for violating his 2:00 AM curfew; Sonnenfeld initially feared it was a death notice before learning the truth.
- His mother's philosophy was "strength through weakness," believing that admitting vulnerability prompts others to offer defense.
- Sonnenfeld attended NYU for three years while living at home in Washington Heights, taking only political science courses (Monday, Wednesday, Thursday) to minimize school time and work at Lincoln Center, fearing his mother would commit suicide if he attended a sleep-away college.
- He secured a 16mm camera to self-identify as a professional cameraman rather than a dilettante, initially shooting industrials for Rabbi Gelman and Sony Trinitron.
- Joel Cohen hired Sonnenfeld to shoot a trailer for the Coen brothers' Blood Simple after Sonnenfeld volunteered his owned camera; the trailer was used to pitch the film to investors who could not read scripts or judge directors' capabilities.
- Blood Simple required raising $750,000 in $15,000 increments; Sonnenfeld notes that an initial $15,000 investment would have returned approximately $75,000–$85,000 by today, a rare success in film finance.
- Sonnenfeld's filmmaking philosophy centers on "pre-production," advocating for extreme preparation to anticipate failure, citing the necessity of storyboarding every shot for Blood Simple, Raising Arizona, and Miller's Crossing.
- He describes pessimism as a "win-win" strategy: if a feared disaster occurs, he is right; if it does not, he survives; conversely, he claims optimism offers "no upside."
Directorial Experiences and Industry Conflicts
- Sonnenfeld was hired as the cinematographer for the film Big only after Bobby Greenhut failed to secure another cameraman in time; he negotiated a second interview to be hired as a "smart" candidate rather than the "idiot" Sonnenfeld.
- Director Penny Marshall struggled to make specific decisions, leading to conflict with Sonnenfeld, who views decision-making as the core of directing; Marshall reportedly attempted to fire him during the second week, but Danny DeVito's endorsement saved his position.
- Marshall's contribution to Big included the physical comedy of Tom Hanks eating baby corn, a detail she deemed necessary for the scene's authenticity.
- During the filming of When Harry Met Sally, Rob Reiner faced extreme physical discomfort due to humidity and the stress of directing a scene where his mother witnesses Meg Ryan faking an orgasm; Reiner reportedly called it the worst day of his life.
- Sonnenfeld argues that comedy relies on reaction shots rather than close-ups, stating that "close-ups are the enemy of comedy" because they tell the audience where the punchline is located.
- He posits that successful comedies should not feature two "funny" actors simultaneously, citing Wild Wild West as an example where Will Smith and Kevin Kline (both comedians) clashed, preventing one from effectively playing the straight man.
- Sonnenfeld's directorial debut, The Addams Family, was commissioned by producer Scott Rudin after Tim Burton and Terry Gilliam passed on the project; Rudin claimed to have auditioned 20–30 other directors during production, though Sonnenfeld attributes the visual success to his background as a cinematographer and love of Charles Addams' cartoons.
- The Addams Family performed twice its predicted box office revenue, generating a significant profit despite Sonnenfeld earning only one-fifth of his potential cameraman salary due to first-time director scale rules.
- Sonnenfeld directed Addams Family Values after Orion Pictures went bankrupt; during production, the studio was sold to Paramount, where new head Stanley Jaffe deemed the uncut footage "unreleasable."
- Sonnenfeld famously described the unedited Addams Family Values to producer Gary Lucchese as "a much sadder version of Sophie's Choice," a statement he later retracted as a joke to convince Lucchese the film was actually funny.
- Paramount offered Sonnenfeld the chance to direct Forrest Gump after the studio rejected eight script drafts; Sonnenfeld convinced Tom Hanks to star, but producer Wendy Finerman overruled him to proceed immediately, fearing delays or similar projects.
- Sonnenfeld lost the Forrest Gump project after refusing to wait on Addams Family Values; he later viewed the final film as "an hour shorter" than he would have directed but acknowledged it as necessary for his emotional healing.
Men in Black, Will Smith, and Future Outlook
- Sonnenfeld initially rejected the Men in Black role because Steven Spielberg insisted on hiring Chris O'Donnell for the lead, whereas Sonnenfeld's wife (Sweetie) suggested Will Smith.
- After Chris O'Donnell passed on the film to star in Cliffhanger, Sonnenfeld arranged a meeting between Spielberg and Will Smith in East Hampton, resulting in Smith's casting.
- Sonnenfeld was rehired to direct Men in Black after quitting early due to disagreements with the producer and a desire to pursue Get Shorty; he returned after the replacement director was fired before shooting began.
- The franchise with Will Smith became a personal landmark, with Will Smith later stating he wanted Sonnenfeld to visit schools to demonstrate that success is possible for anyone.
- The memoir concludes with the forward-looking affirmation derived from Smith: "If I can be a successful director on big budget movies anyone can."
- Sonnenfeld's new memoir is titled Call Your Mother: Memoirs of an Erotic Filmmaker (note: the transcript title appears to contain a transcription error, likely Call Your Mother: A Life in Film or similar, but the text explicitly quotes the "erotic filmmaker" phrasing as part of the introduction).