"Climbing the Wall of Worry”
Market Performance vs. Uncertainty: U.S. equities have climbed 45% from the March trough and gained over 1% year-to-date despite significant market volatility, high infection rates, and policy ambiguity.
- The "Wall of Worry" narrative reflects client concerns regarding infections, government policy, and the upcoming election, yet market resilience persists.
- Investors are cautioned that the path to future gains will not be smooth and requires a long-term horizon to look beyond short-term volatility.
Return Expectations and Asset Class Projections: Financial advisors recommend a probabilistic approach to long-term returns, prioritizing equities over cash and bonds due to low interest rate environments.
- Cash: Expected to yield negligible returns (0–25 basis points) for several years due to Fed policy.
- Bonds: The 10-year Treasury yielding approximately 0.6% offers similarly anemic expected returns.
- Equities: Mid-single-digit returns are projected for the next several years, with a specific base case of 6% annual returns over the next decade (citing David Koston's analysis).
Healthcare and Economic Outlook: Investment recommendations remain positive based on a projected "mid-single-digit downdraft" for 2020 and a similar magnitude recovery in 2021.
- Vaccine Timeline: Experts do not anticipate a broadly available vaccine until 2021; therefore, investment strategies are not predicated on a fall 2020 vaccine.
- Epidemiology: Continued adherence to social distancing and mask-wearing could prevent a full economic lockdown without requiring new therapies.
- Labor Market: Unemployment is expected to recover from a peak of 14% to approximately 9% by the end of 2020, though a return to mid-single-digit unemployment (around 5%) may not occur until 2023.
- Structural challenges include the difficulty of retraining long-term unemployed workers and the potential for certain jobs to disappear permanently.
- Recovery Data: High-frequency indicators (mobility, restaurant traffic) show signs of stalling, while broader economic data (non-farm payrolls, ISM indexes) indicates a recent recovery.
Fiscal Stimulus and Debt Trajectory: The strategy assumes the passage of approximately $1.5 trillion in additional fiscal stimulus to prevent an economic "cliff" as existing benefits expire.
- Expert Consensus: There is bipartisan agreement on the need for stimulus, with most estimates ranging around $1.5 trillion.
- Debt Concerns: Experts from the Brookings Institution and the Committee for Responsible Federal Budget assert that rising debt levels are not currently inflationary and will not trigger a fiscal crisis.
- Debt-to-GDP projections have increased, but market participants are advised not to view this as an immediate risk.
- Calls for fiscal discipline are reserved for the post-stimulus period (a few years hence).
Political and Election Risks: The presidential election introduces uncertainty regarding governance structure and tax policy, which are key variables in equity valuation.
- Governance Structure: Historical data suggests divided government often outperforms single-party control; the increasing probability of a Democratic sweep may influence long-term market performance.
- Tax Policy: Concerns exist regarding a potential "Biden tax plan," estimated by Jason Furman to be reduced from $4 trillion to roughly $2 trillion over time.
- Any potential corporate tax increases are not expected to present an immediate barrier to equity market fundamentals.
Investment Recommendation: Clients are advised to maintain strategic asset allocation and avoid attempting to trade based on headlines during periods of high volatility.
- Actionable Advice: Investors should remain fully invested at their risk-appropriate equity allocation rather than attempting to time the market.
- Risk Warning: Market volatility is significant enough that trying to trade around every headline could result in losses equivalent to a year of gains in a single day.
- Valuation Context: While the market is currently somewhat overvalued, it is not considered excessively so given favorable economic and policy fundamentals.