Conference Presentation, Panel
Global Capital Markets
Milken InstituteGerard Baker, Mary Callahan Erdoes, Michael Corbat, Joshua Friedman, Scott Minerd, Ning Tang
Global Economic Outlook (2018):
- Global growth is projected to be the fastest and most synchronous since the 2008 financial crisis, driven by recovery in previously stagnant regions like Europe and Japan.
- The U.S. economy is in its 106th month of expansion (since June 2009), with unemployment at a 44-year low.
- Central bank leadership remains stable globally, with the appointment of Chair Powell (Fed), Governor Kuroda (BOJ), and consistent stances from the ECB and Bank of England.
- U.S. tax reform benefits are expected to continue driving growth, though their full intermediate impact is not yet fully reflected in the economy.
Market Structure and Liquidity Risks:
- A significant structural shift has occurred in capital markets: the percentage of high-yield bonds held by commercial banks has dropped to nearly zero, with risks transferred to illiquid passive vehicles (ETFs/mutual funds).
- The number of U.S. public companies has declined from approximately 8,000 to 3,800 due to regulatory burdens (e.g., Sarbanes-Oxley) and Volcker Rule complexities, encouraging a shift to private markets.
- Market volatility is expected to increase as the $11 trillion in global quantitative easing is withdrawn (quantitative tightening), removing the liquidity that previously muted price swings.
- Passive investing creates "discontinuity" risks; securities can be rapidly removed from indices without credit analysis, leading to sharp, non-fundamental price drops (e.g., Toys "R" Us).
- Investors face a "fast speed, slow speed" trading dynamic where ETF liquidity exceeds the liquidity of underlying assets, creating potential runoff risks during crises.
Debt, Leverage, and Imbalances:
- Corporate debt-to-GDP ratios are at record highs; rising interest rates combined with the expiration of tax cut stimulus are expected to strain corporate free cash flow in 2019-2020.
- U.S. banks now hold significantly higher capital buffers (over 90% above 4% buffer zone) compared to pre-crisis levels (less than 20%).
- Scott Miner warns that the U.S. structural trade deficit is a necessary consequence of the dollar's role as the global reserve currency; attempting to eliminate it could undermine U.S. military and economic standing.
- Labor shortages in the U.S. (e.g., unemployment rates below 2% in Elkhart, Indiana) are becoming a critical constraint, colliding with immigration policies and potentially creating a "breaking point" for growth.
Geopolitics and Trade:
- Trade protectionism has shifted focus from growth to job creation and wage concerns; the U.S. trade deficit with China is $375 billion (out of a total $570 billion deficit).
- J.P. Morgan Asset Management (Mary Callaghan-Erdos) and Citigroup (Michael Corbett) note that the headline tariff rates are the highest in 50 years but from the lowest base in 100 years.
- When accounting for subsidiaries and multinational operations (e.g., General Motors), the effective U.S. trade deficit with China drops significantly (from $250B to ~$50B).
- Michael Corbett argues that the real nexus of global trade imbalance lies in services and intellectual property, as 80% of the U.S. economy is services-driven, while manufacturing faces automation risks.
China's Economic Transition:
- China is entering a "New Era" driven by 200 million middle-class consumers and 2 million ultra-high-net-worth individuals demanding higher quality services (healthcare, education).
- The Chinese financial system is shifting from bank-dominated lending to direct investment (venture capital, private equity) to support innovation and long-term tech development.
- Fintech and mobile technology are enabling lending to small businesses based on transactional data rather than hard assets, bypassing traditional banking bottlenecks.
- Chinese leadership is prioritizing sustainable development, technology, and a fairer distribution of wealth between the U.S. and China.
Technology and Cybersecurity:
- The primary risk in the financial sector has shifted from Bitcoin to blockchain and general cybersecurity; password breaches are considered a known constant, but "complete control" hijacking of life and infrastructure is the new threat.
- Fintech is expanding financial inclusion to rural populations in China and small businesses globally via mobile platforms.
- Guggenheim Investments is focusing on artificial intelligence as a key area of innovation and future growth.
Banking Regulation:
- Citigroup CEO Michael Corbett states that while the tone of U.S. banking regulation has improved (more constructive engagement with regulators), actual repeal of Dodd-Frank is limited.
- Deregulation is expected to continue as regulatory bodies complete leadership transitions, potentially improving public market liquidity and reducing the incentive for companies to stay private.
- J.P. Morgan's Mary Callaghan-Erdos emphasizes that active management will regain importance as market volatility returns and stocks diverge, allowing analysts to differentiate between company fundamentals.
Volatility and Passive Investing Dynamics:
- Volatility in 2017 was historically low (only eight 1%+ daily moves), creating a false sense of stability that is expected to revert to the historical average of 1-2 such moves per week.
- There is a fear that returning volatility will psychologically damage investors who experienced the 2008 crisis, causing a flight to cash or premature exits from passive funds.
- The "passive exit" risk is identified as a potential catalyst for a "sell-off spiral" where liquidity dry-ups prevent orderly exits.