newsfilter.io
Fireside Chat, Interview, Conference Presentation

Hugh Herr: Co-Director of MIT Center for Extreme Bionics

Core Philosophy on Disability and Technology

  • Hugh Herr defines disability as a failure of technology and environment, stating, "There is no such thing as a broken person, there's only broken technologies."
  • Herr rejects the term "disability," referring to his condition as having an "unusual body" rather than a broken one.
  • Historical medical advice dismissed his recovery potential, stating, "This is as good as it gets," and provided non-technical limbs made of foam and wood.
  • Herr advocates for a future where basic physiological functions are a human right and humanity ends disability within this century through augmentation.
  • Current technology fails to match advancements in other fields like cars, space shuttles, and the internet, driving the need for advanced prosthetics.

Distinction Between Bionic and Cyborg

  • Herr distinguishes "bionic" from "cyborg" based on bi-directional communication; current prosthetics allow him to move but not feel touch.
  • A true cyborg requires synthetic parts to become part of the self, where the nervous system views mechatronics as its own.
  • Cyborg technology would allow humans to sculpt their own morphology and dynamics, fundamentally changing human design.
  • Herr predicts humans will be "unrecognizable" in 100 years, expanding narrow views of beauty, intelligence, and power.
  • Risks include the potential for external control of the human brain, such as manipulating mood or inducing delusions via direct neural interfaces.

Future Human-AI Interaction and Policy

  • Within 50 years, high-fidelity input/output to the human nervous system is expected to be realized.
  • Future sophistication in artificial intelligence may lead to machine consciousness within the next half-century.
  • Herr considers the scenario of AI agents controlling human systems "truly terrifying" and calls for robust policy to govern this pathway.
  • He anticipates general acceptance of humans informing and controlling AI, but views the reverse direction with significant apprehension.

Impact on Sports and Competition

  • As a key expert witness in the 2012 Olympics, Herr helped overturn the ban on Oscar Pistorius, proving the athlete did not have a net advantage.
  • Current data suggested science was not mature enough to prove Pistorius had a net advantage across the totality of the 400-meter race.
  • Herr predicts gold-medal-winning athletes with bionics will appear very soon, challenging the primacy of innate biological bodies.
  • He foresees the Olympic spectator count shrinking while Paralympic attendance increases as bionic feats surpass innate limits.
  • The future will likely see new sports categories emerge, such as "bionic climbing," "bionic running," and "bionic swimming," similar to how the bicycle invented cycling.

Personal Resilience and Overcoming Limitations

  • Following his accident and amputation, Herr experienced a 24-hour period of intense grief after being told he could never climb or ride a bicycle again.
  • He overcame this by rejecting his doctor's negative assessment, citing his own persistence and the rapid pace of technological innovation.
  • His parents instilled a core lesson of resilience: "Never, ever give up," "Never say that you cannot," and "Whatever you do, do well, do beautifully."
  • Herr asserts that many people fail to achieve their potential because they embrace negativity and limitations that do not actually exist.

Innovation, Emotion, and Entrepreneurship

  • Herr defines creativity, invention, and innovation as an "emotional phenomenon" rooted in emotional intelligence rather than just intellectual capability.
  • Fearlessness is identified as a common trait among great historical innovators, who were willing to try anything regardless of ridicule.
  • Thomas Edison's experiment of linking his ear to a pendulum to see if he could move it via thought exemplifies the fearless nature of true innovation.
  • Herr criticizes the education system for creating students who are "locked up" by emotional shackles and fear of experiments contradicting their ideas.
  • He argues that fearlessness in experimentation is essential to science and that these traits can be taught to children.