Panel
In the 21st Century, Data Is King
Milken InstitutePaul Kudrowski, Kevin Slavin, DJ, Jim Messina, Frank Cooper, Michael Chewy, Michael D
Key Drivers of the Big Data Era
- The confluence of cheap storage, inexpensive processing power, and ubiquitous cloud infrastructure has made data collection and analysis globally accessible.
- The world is increasingly "instrumented," shifting from passive data generation to active, conscious collection and utilization of data streams from daily devices and interactions.
- McKinsey research indicates that effective data usage is becoming a primary basis of competition; organizations that fail to utilize data risk failure, while those that embrace it can create entirely new business models.
- A fundamental shift in decision-making is occurring, moving away from "HIPPO" (Highest Paid Person's Opinion) models toward rigorous, scientific experimentation with control groups and statistical analysis.
Sector-Specific Transformations and Challenges
- PepsiCo (Frank Cooper):
- Shifts from sampling to analyzing "all the data," requiring real-time response to messy, fluid datasets rather than clean, exact historical data.
- Emphasis has moved from seeking causality to accepting correlation, necessitating a cultural shift to "marry data with intuition and imagination."
- Creation of "Green Label Sound," an independent label, to leverage data in the music ecosystem where traditional record companies fail to utilize analytics.
- Failure of a major tech company in the music space attributed to a purely engineering/data approach lacking human creativity and emotional connection.
- Political Campaigns (Jim Messina):
- The 2012 Obama campaign utilized a team of 165 data scientists (up from 12 in 2008) to rank every voter on a scale of 1-100 based on support and voting probability.
- The campaign ran 62,000 computer simulations nightly to allocate the $1 billion budget, including precise targeting of television ads and volunteer deployment.
- Implementation of "A-B testing" on email campaigns, where 24 versions of every email were tested to maximize returns, increasing donation efficiency by 82%.
- Success in "targeted sharing" on Facebook, where 78% of users who clicked to share a video with friends voted for the candidate, reversing previous trends of undecided voters.
- Post-campaign strategy involves "Organizing for Action" to translate campaign data tools into sustained governance and issue advocacy, though political fragmentation makes broad leadership difficult.
- Venture Capital & Technology (DJ Patil & Michael Chui):
- Healthcare: Identified as a major opportunity through the combination of disparate data sources (insurance, providers, wearables like Fitbit, and pharmaceutical trials) currently not being integrated.
- National Security: Data utilization is critical for threat detection, as demonstrated by the Boston bombing investigation.
- Future Funding Trends: Current investment favors building technology "stacks" over verticalized solutions; the market is shifting toward specific applications for executives and security officers.
- Emerging Markets: Big data adoption is "spiky," with global standards met by leaders, though mobile platforms offer leapfrog opportunities for localized data sensing (e.g., Ushahidi in Africa).
- Entertainment & Media:
- Transition from naive Nielsen sampling to data-driven insights on audience consumption habits, though reliance on algorithms (e.g., "Narrative Science" scripts) risks removing human creative analysis.
- Companies like Epagogics attempt to predict movie box office success via algorithmic script analysis, signaling a shift toward data-driven creative decisions.
- PepsiCo (Frank Cooper):
Risks, "Dark Sides," and Ethical Considerations
- Signal vs. Noise: The volume of data increases the risk of finding false signals, exemplified by the Boston bombing manhunt where innocent citizens were falsely identified, or the AP Twitter hijacking which momentarily crashed 9% of the stock market via algorithmic reaction.
- Algorithmic Feedback Loops: Non-human readers (e.g., Google Panda algorithms) influence content creation, leading to stories optimized for machines rather than humans, which can then be parsed back into data, creating a cycle of degraded information quality.
- Human Displacement: A key concern is the supplanting of human perception and intuition with data-driven automation, particularly in financial markets where automated trading can react to unverified data instantly.
- Privacy Concerns: The Obama campaign established a dedicated privacy group, highlighting the tension between data-driven persuasion and individual privacy, especially regarding the "liberal paternalism" of guiding choices.
Strategic Recommendations and Future Outlook
- Startup vs. Enterprise: While large corporations possess historical data advantages, startups retain an edge in nimbleness and the ability to adapt without the burden of legacy ecosystems.
- Data as a Service: Entrepreneurs can compete by identifying "closed-loop" gaps in larger organizations (e.g., connecting consumer behavior at the point of sale for retailers) to provide value-added data solutions.
- The "Bridge" Role: Successful organizations require a "Spock on the bridge"—a data scientist who can translate technical data into intuitive human insights to guide decisions that may run contrary to raw data.
- Future Experiments: The ability to conduct A-B testing is expanding from digital environments (email, web) into the physical world (e.g., McDonald's testing store configurations in warehouses).
- Data Reuse in Politics: The Obama data team faces legal and structural challenges in repurposing campaign data for non-political uses or future campaigns, aiming to keep data cross-platform for various advocacy groups.