Conference Presentation, Panel
Infrastructure, Investment, and Industrial Competitiveness | Global Investors' Symposium Mexico City
Milken InstituteAlex González Ormerod, Gautam Bhandari, Ricardo Fernández-Mazarambroz, Carlos Garcia Moreno, Raul Martinez-Ostos Jaye
Mexico's Strategic Positioning
- Mexico is currently described as being at a "serious crossroads" regarding its reconfiguration as a key global supply chain node and the southern neighbor of the United States.
- Panelists identified a "mismatch of opportunity and present," noting that the Western Hemisphere is undergoing a historic re-industrialization and decoupling from China, offering a unique window of opportunity.
Infrastructure and Connectivity Requirements
- Telecom Sector Needs:
- Reliance on robust, fast, and secure 5G networks (currently deployed in 120 cities) and fiber backbones to attract foreign investment.
- A need for government involvement to extend connectivity to rural areas, which remain economically difficult to cover via private capital alone.
- Current urban home phone penetration for those over 60 is 92% (INEGI data), but rural gaps persist.
- Broad Infrastructure Strategy:
- Success requires a shift from "mega projects" to "mid-market" projects (e.g., cold chain, trailer logistics) to ensure easier execution and faster returns.
- Private capital has already moved independently; I Squared Capital deployed over $1 billion organically to build data centers, creating 1,200 jobs and tripling its size.
- BBVA generated 170 billion Mexican pesos in projects across 11 states through a state-level financial diagnosis methodology (LEAPT).
- Telecom Sector Needs:
Financing Ecosystem and Capital Sources
- Local Funding (Afores):
- Mexico has developed a robust local savings pool via "Afores" (pension funds), moving away from reliance on international markets and reducing FX exposure.
- Afores have evolved from primarily funding government debt to increasingly sophisticated investments in real assets, though they remain in an early phase (25 years old) compared to Chile (70% of GDP).
- Challenge: A lack of "credit expertise" within the domestic system poses a risk to squandering these savings or incurring losses on productive investments.
- Insurance Sector:
- Insurance assets (one-third of Afores' size) are currently three steps behind in regulatory sophistication and heavily weighted toward government paper rather than long-term infrastructure.
- Insurance capital is identified as a critical, underutilized source for long-term infrastructure financing.
- Banking Sector:
- Commercial banks have achieved high returns on equity (mid-to-high 20s), reducing their incentive to push into riskier infrastructure without new incentives.
- Development banks (e.g., under Roberto Lacería and Jorge Mendoza, 2018–2024) must act as complements to commercial banks, providing guarantees and bridging gaps rather than competing on every asset.
- Global Capital:
- International investors require "skin in the game" from local partners and "political insurance" (via local DNA) to navigate political risks.
- Co-investment platforms (e.g., BBVA's partnership with Canada's CDPQ) are cited as effective mechanisms to connect local validation with international capital.
- Local Funding (Afores):
Role of Government and Policy
- Plan México:
- While ambitious, the government's industrial policy lacks direct cash reserves, necessitating private sector-led financing for roads, railways, and ports.
- The government is encouraged to stop rewriting concession agreements from scratch and instead adopt standardized contracts (e.g., IFC models) to reduce risk.
- Regulatory Needs:
- Contract law sanctity and a level playing field are cited as critical levers to lower the cost of capital.
- Speed of execution is identified as a specific weakness in the Mexican economy that hinders investment compared to global peers.
- Federal vs. Local:
- The majority of infrastructure must be developed at the state level, requiring a financial diagnosis of specific states to align infrastructure with local competitive advantages.
- Plan México:
Sector-Specific Initiatives
- Energy Transition:
- A notable example involves the sale of Iberdrola's third-generation power plants in Mexico, where a consortium involving a Sovereign Wealth Fund (GIC) and a global operator committed billions in renewable energy investment, signaling continued confidence despite market rumors.
- Digital Payments:
- The telecom sector emphasizes the need to complete the digital payment ecosystem, moving away from cash withdrawals via debit cards to fully integrated digital transaction networks.
- Energy Transition:
Consensus Action Items
- Immediate Priorities:
- Identify and execute 2–3 "quick wins" (easy, replicable deals) within the next 12 months to generate momentum and validate the investment landscape for international capital.
- Shift from "PowerPoint to action" by converting stated strategies into executed deals.
- Collaboration Models:
- Private sectors must actively co-invest with Afores and international funds to create liquidity and share grades.
- Governments must provide clear policy signals and facilitate back-and-forth dialogue with the private sector rather than imposing one-size-fits-all solutions.
- Immediate Priorities: