Interview
The Business Case for Investing in Diversity
Strategic Rationale for Diversity
- Goldman Sachs Asset Management (GSAM) views diverse investment teams as a primary driver of profitability and competitive advantage, rather than solely an issue of fairness.
- Teams with plurality of perspectives generate different viewpoints relative to the marketplace, positioning the firm to outperform competitors.
- The approach mirrors economic arguments used in the 10,000 Women Program: enfranchising underutilized groups (e.g., women) yields long-term GDP increases and high returns on investment.
Data and Performance Correlations
- Evidence indicates that companies scoring high on ESG diversity, inclusion, and workplace quality outperform across most sectors over the last decade.
- This performance correlation is a core driver for GSAM's investment process integration, stewardship, and engagement strategies.
Stewardship Actions and Voting Policies
- In 2019, GSAM became one of the first major asset managers to implement a voting policy against nominating chairs of U.S. companies with no women on the board.
- The firm voted against approximately 200 companies under the initial U.S. policy; 40% of those companies subsequently added a woman to their boards.
- In 2020, GSAM expanded this policy globally to vote against the boards of any listed company without at least one woman, voting against roughly 700 companies and 1,400 directors.
- Results from the global policy are expected to be available early next year.
Recruitment and Talent Development
- A critical factor for achieving diversity is placing senior women in seats of influence, authority, and risk-taking to counter "representative bias" (the belief that "if you can see it, you can be it").
- Successful representation in leadership roles creates an organic recruitment pipeline where diverse talent begins to seek out the organization.
Market Demographics and Consumer Trends
- GSAM prioritizes companies with cultures valuing diversity to ensure alignment with the "millennial consumer" demographic.
- Millennial consumption is projected to increase between 10% and 15% over the next five years, while baby boomer consumption is expected to decrease by 5% to 10%.
- Research cited (Edelman survey) indicates 60% of millennial consumers would buy or boycott a brand based on their reaction to racism, making diversity a direct factor in addressable market and brand trust.
Racial Diversity and Data Challenges
- Current data on racial equity in corporate leadership is sparse; historically, only 18 Black CEOs have led Fortune 500 companies, with only two being female Black CEOs.
- A key correlation found is that every instance of a Black CEO in the Fortune 500 had Black representation on the board, suggesting board diversity as a precursor to executive diversity.
- A significant barrier to progress is a lack of mandatory disclosure; only 20% of Russell 1000 companies report both gender and racial demographics.
- GSAM plans to engage companies throughout the remainder of the year and into 2021 to demand better demographic disclosure, operating on the premise that measurement is required for accountability.