Panel, Conference Presentation
The World in Transition | Africa and the Middle East: The Cradle of Civilization Once Again?
Milken InstituteStaci Warden, Mohammed Alardhi, Madalitso Mandiwa, Michael Milken, Patrice Motsepe, Stephanie von Friedeburg
Demographic Shifts and Population Projections
- Africa's population is projected to reach 2.8 billion by 2040 and 2.5 billion by 2060, with Nigeria expected to surpass the U.S. population by 2040.
- Demographics are heavily skewed toward youth: two-fifths of Africa's population is aged 0–14, and one-fifth is aged 15–24.
- In the Middle East, 30% of the population is aged 15–29, with Saudi Arabia alone having 70% of its population under age 30.
- Africa adds 12 million people to its workforce annually, representing the primary driver of global population growth for this century.
- Mike Milken notes that without internal opportunities, this demographic surge could trigger mass migration that disrupts global cultures and causes instability.
Infrastructure Deficits and Capital Requirements
- Africa faces an annual infrastructure deficit of approximately $170 billion, requiring significant capital mobilization to meet Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
- The total gap to fund SDGs globally is estimated at $2.5 trillion annually, necessitating deep, vibrant local capital markets.
- Mobile phone penetration in Africa has surged from 2% to over 80%, creating a foundation for leapfrogging in education, healthcare, and financial inclusion.
- Telecommunications infrastructure represents a $365 billion annual gap in Africa, identified as a top priority for SDG closure.
- Power generation remains a bottleneck; only eight countries outside of South Africa in sub-Saharan Africa can generate more than 50% of their power on a base-load basis.
Private Sector Strategy and Investment Trends
- Patrice Motsepe's African Rainbow Minerals invested $600 million in a Zambian copper mine, highlighting the need for regional integration to manage logistics and costs.
- South African companies have invested approximately $23 billion on the African continent, ranking third globally only behind China and India.
- Mohamed al-ardi (Invescore) notes that only about 5% of total private equity deals in Africa (approx. $24 billion) originate from the Middle East.
- Invescore has not directly invested in Africa due to concerns over the rule of law, exit mechanisms, and scale, preferring markets with established capital markets infrastructure.
- McKinsey estimates over 10,000 Chinese companies operate in Africa today, with 90% being private firms; these entities employ 89% local workers and focus on middle-class markets rather than just resources.
- The International Finance Corporation (IFC) aims to mobilize private capital by using its AAA-rated balance sheet to create risk-free benchmarks, such as issuing sovereign bonds in Rwanda and Zambia.
Financial Instruments and Innovation
- The IFC facilitated the first local currency bond issuance for a West African mortgage refinance company, solving a currency swap issue by creating a synthetic swap off the IDA balance sheet.
- Extending mortgage terms from 7.5 years to 15 years in targeted regions can reduce monthly payments by 46%, making affordable housing viable.
- Islamic finance is a $4 trillion market growing at double the rate of commercial banks, though it requires broader institutional acceptance and regulatory clarity to become a mainstream tool.
- Malawi's Ministry of Finance is transitioning from short-term financing to long-term bonds, including 2-year, 5-year, and 10-year instruments, and is now developing infrastructure bonds.
- Intra-regional foreign exchange (FX) volatility is high against the USD, but FX stability between African currencies (e.g., Rwandan Franc vs. Kenyan Shilling) suggests a priority for developing regional FX markets.
Regional Integration and Policy Priorities
- Patrice Motsepe advocates for open borders and the free flow of goods and capital to achieve economies of scale, citing the Schengen model in Europe and the East African Community.
- Current barriers include excessive trucking queues at borders; for example, five to six kilometers of trucks were observed waiting to enter the DRC from Zambia.
- The IFC emphasizes regionalization as essential, noting that individual African nations cannot compete globally as standalone markets.
- Mohamed al-ardi advises Middle Eastern nations to diversify away from oil dependency, shifting focus to human capital and private sector participation via Vision 2030.
- The panel highlights that 40% of Africa's population is currently urban, projected to exceed 50%, necessitating massive investment in city infrastructure and job creation.
Human Capital and Education Initiatives
- The Milken Institute and IFC have established a scholar program training mid-career government officials in capital markets risk management to return and implement reforms.
- Ma'ala Mandiwa (Malawi) credits the program with transforming her approach to finance, moving from theoretical concepts to practical implementation of long-term bond issuances.
- Mike Milken identifies the "demographic curse" as a potential alternative to the "demographic dividend" if youth remain uneducated and unemployed.
- Investment in research universities (e.g., Stanford, Oxford) is identified as a historical prerequisite for sustained economic growth and technological innovation.
- The IFC is leveraging World Bank balance sheets to provide "first-loss" guarantees, de-risking projects to crowd in private sector capital.
Risk Perception and Market Opportunity
- Mike Milken argues that the perceived risk in Africa and the Middle East currently exceeds actual risk, creating an "investment nirvana" for risk-tolerant capital.
- Current capital flows favor Western Europe, the U.S., and Asia due to higher stability, with the Middle East seeking safety due to regional volatility.
- The panel concludes that investing in good policy, capable administrators, and confident regulators is a prerequisite for private capital entry.
- Cultural and technological leapfrogging is evident in sectors like dining (e.g., high-quality sushi in Ghana) and digital connectivity, challenging old stereotypes of the continent.
- Final consensus emphasizes that creating local opportunities is essential for global stability, preventing mass migration driven by lack of economic prospects.