Conference Presentation, Panel
Women Entrepreneurs: A Dynamic Force in Global Growth
Milken InstituteRick Smith, Jessica Alba, Susan Feldman, Sheila Lirio Marcelo, Alexandra Wilkis Wilson, Debbie Wosskow
Panel Overview & Key Statistics
- Founder Demographics & Funding Gap: Research indicates women start companies at twice the rate of men, yet only 1 out of 12 Series A deals last year involved female founders.
- Panel Credentials: The five panelists (Sheila Lirio Marcelo, Alexandra Wilcox Wilson, Jessica Alba, Susan Lyne, and Debbie Millman) have collectively raised hundreds of millions in venture capital; one founder (Care.com) has taken their company public.
- Market Opportunity: Care.com's total addressable market (TAM) for care services is estimated at $280 billion annually.
- Economic Impact Data: A McKinsey study cited suggests that achieving gender parity in the workplace could add $28 trillion to the global economy, equating to the combined GDP of the US and China.
- Perception of Parity: Survey data reveals 42% of women enter the workforce believing there is no equal parity in opportunity, compared to only 11% of men who believe gender parity issues exist.
Founders' Motivations & Business Models
- Care.com (Sheila Lirio Marcelo): Founded out of personal necessity when the founder's father suffered a heart attack while she was using Yellow Pages to find care; serves 18 million members in 16 countries and became publicly traded.
- Glam Squad (Alexandra Wilcox Wilson): Launched to provide high-quality beauty services (hair, makeup, nails) delivered to consumers; generated $200 million in funding (venture and public) and operates in NY, LA, and Miami.
- The Honest Company (Jessica Alba): Addressed the lack of safety testing for chemicals in US products compared to Europe; focuses on affordable, non-toxic home and baby products with a built-in community giving model.
- One Kings Lane (Susan Lyne): Evolved from a 2009 flash sale site during the recession into a comprehensive online home goods destination featuring new, designer, and vintage items; bootstrapped initially before raising Series A.
- Love Home Swap (Debbie Millman): A global home-sharing platform leveraging the "sharing economy" with over 100,000 homes; addresses the desire for authentic travel experiences over hotel stays, particularly for families.
Structural Barriers & Investor Bias
- The "Old Boys' Network": The venture capital community is identified as an "old boys' network" where investors often lack familiarity with female-centric products, making it harder to secure funding for women-led businesses.
- Pain vs. Pleasure Framing: Female founders face difficulty convincing investors that their businesses solve "pain" problems (e.g., childcare, safety) rather than "pleasure" problems, despite the massive market size.
- Cognitive Bias Examples:
- One VC claimed "women don't spend $500 on shoes" before admitting his wife owned that specific pair.
- Another VC could not comprehend how a woman could multitask (e.g., getting a blowout while working on a laptop).
- Term Sheet Challenges: One Kings Lane received a non-negotiable, unfavorable term sheet from a lead investor who later regretted the decision after his wife used the service.
- Early-Stage Funding Gap: In the UK and elsewhere, the primary hurdle for women is accessing seed finance due to a lack of networks and contacts, rather than a lack of later-stage capital.
- Valuation Disparity: Analysts compared Care.com's metrics to OpenTable's successful IPO, noting that male analysts understood OpenTable's model but struggled to value Care's, highlighting a gap in understanding female-centric markets.
Strategies for Success & Ecosystem Solutions
- Mentorship & "Championing": Successful founders emphasize the critical role of having mentors who have navigated board meetings and fundraising; panelists advocate for active "championing" by existing leaders to pull others up.
- Role of Male Allies: Panelists assert that true gender parity requires more men to act as mentors and champions, as men currently hold the majority of leadership positions and investment power.
- Investment Thesis Shift: Some investors suggest that backing female-led companies can be a competitive advantage if they target demographics (e.g., households where women control 70% of income) that male founders may overlook.
- Dedicated Funds: There is a forward-looking call to create more funds specifically focused on hiring female partners and investing solely in women-led startups.
- STEM Advocacy: Jessica Alba highlights efforts to integrate coding and tech skills into school curricula, specifically supporting organizations like Girls Who Code to increase female representation in technology.
- Overcoming the "Three Ps": Sheila Marcelo identifies three self-imposed barriers for women:
- Perception: Fear of being judged in male-dominated industries.
- Perfectionism: Waiting for all qualifications to be met before launching.
- Passivity: Hesitation to voice opinions in meetings, often resulting in men repeating the same ideas.
Founder Advice & Personal Strategies
- Grit Over Inspiration: Panelists cite "grit" and persistence during negative news cycles as more critical to success than initial inspiration or idea novelty.
- Early Rising Habits: Susan Lyne emphasizes the practical necessity of training oneself to be an early riser to manage the demands of founding a company while raising a family.
- Friendship Dynamics: Alexandra Wilcox Wilson advises ensuring that the business does not "business-ify" friendships, maintaining trust and support among co-founders.
- Authenticity & Intuition: Founders urge women to trust their intuition (cited as correct 10 out of 10 times) and to remain authentic to their vision rather than conforming to external expectations.
- Speed vs. Perfection: Susan Lyne advises moving quickly and iterating rather than waiting for a perfect product, as markets change rapidly.
- Redefining Leadership: Sheila Marcelo encourages women to "over-project" their voices in meetings to establish leadership, even if it risks being labeled "pushy," noting that confidence is often mistaken for incompetence in women.
- Reframing Failure: Jessica Alba advises that failures prepare founders for the next step; she was rejected three times before her co-founder joined the company 18 months later.
- The "Katniss Moment": Marcelo encourages founders to find an "inner strength" moment to overcome being underestimated, asserting that women can be nurturing at home and ferocious in business simultaneously.