Stan Wong: Tax-loss selling – when does it make sense to sell at a loss?
Summary
- A stock down from $50 to $35 warrants review of earnings outlooks, price implications, and alternative investment options before deciding to sell.
- Realized capital losses in non-registered accounts can offset capital gains, while losses in TFSA or RRSP accounts cannot be used for tax purposes.
- To apply a 2026 loss against that year's gains, the trade must settle by Thursday, Dec. 31, 2026, making Wednesday, Dec. 30, 2026, the final trading day for most Canadian & U.S. stocks.
- Excess losses can be carried back three years (2023, 2024, 2025) or carried forward indefinitely to offset future taxable capital gains.
- Investors must calculate gains in Canadian dollars, as currency fluctuations can turn a U.S. stock decline into a Canadian dollar gain.
- The adjusted cost base should be verified using the weighted average method if the same stock was purchased at different prices.
- The superficial loss rule denies tax deductions if the investor or an affiliated person buys the same or identical investment within 30 days before or after the sale.
- Selling an investment to contribute to a registered account preserves the loss, whereas contributing the investment directly forfeits the capital loss claim.
- Investors retaining industry exposure after a sale can reinvest in similar peers or diversified sector ETFs, but Canadian Depositary Receipts (CDRs) of the same shares may trigger the superficial loss rule.
- Tax-loss selling should align with a total wealth plan, potentially involving a tax advisor to assess loss value & a wealth advisor to determine optimal use of proceeds.
- The final decision on selling should rely on whether the investor would buy the stock at its current price today.
When I review a stock that’s down, I look at what’s changed in the earnings outlook, what the lower price already reflects and where else I could put the money. If the case for owning it has weakened, it may be time to sell.