newsfilter
← Latest News
General Catalyst·

The Limitations of Simulation in Space

Summary

  • Biosphere 2 was built in Arizona in the late 1980s to simulate space settlement, but its 1991-1993 mission failed after 16 months when oxygen levels dropped, requiring outside air injection.
  • Bryce Strauss, cofounder of the hardware data platform Nominal, argues that software simulations alone cannot predict physical outcomes because physical matter remains ambiguous.
  • Strauss previously worked on the NASA Juno mission, which required a precise 35-minute burn to enter Jovian orbit, a maneuver his team spent a year preparing for to ensure success.
  • He advocates for the NASA philosophy "Test like you fly," which treats operation as a high-stakes test rather than a separate function.
  • For the InSight Mars mission, NASA purchased duplicate flight-grade components including batteries & computers to allow for rigorous Earth-based testing.
  • The InSight team practiced the first five days of Mars operations by remotely controlling an identical lander on Earth to simulate communication delays.
  • During the OSIRIS-REx asteroid sample mission, engineers built large walls of various substances on Earth for the robotic arm to practice on, addressing uncertainties about surface conditions.
  • Strauss criticizes organizations that rely solely on computer simulations, stating that real-world hardware testing is essential before deploying critical systems.
  • He emphasizes that an organization's willingness to invest in constant evaluation & physical operation of systems is the best indicator of product reliability.