Panel, Conference Presentation
Credit Market Outlook
Milken InstituteMichael Milken, Ilfryn Carstairs, Sir Michael Hintze, David Miller, Joseph Naggar, Jim Zelter
Market Growth & Capacity
- The leverage finance market has grown 48% over the past six years; the leverage loan market specifically grew 51%.
- Private equity dry powder stands at over $1.1 trillion, requiring deployment over the next 5–7 years.
- Projected purchasing power from this dry powder is $3.6 trillion, with $2.5–2.6 trillion attributed to debt origination.
- This projected debt volume represents a near doubling of the current total US leveraged finance market size ($2.5 trillion).
Credit Quality & Covenant Trends
- Fixed charge coverage ratios today average 2.5x, significantly higher than the sub-2.0x levels seen during the 2006–2008 period.
- Interest coverage ratios have improved to 4.0x, compared to 2.5x in the pre-crisis era.
- Equity checks in leveraged financings now average 40%, up from 30% pre-crisis.
- Average leverage ratios sit at 5.0x EBITDA (excluding energy sector distortions).
- Default ratios for non-energy and non-retail sectors range between 1.8% and 2.8%, currently hovering at 2.0%.
- Covenant-light deals now constitute 75% of the market, up from less than 30% in 2007.
- Fully covenanted deals trade with spreads 85–90 basis points higher annually than covenant-light counterparts.
Asset Management Strategies & Origination
- Apollo manages $102 billion in permanent capital vehicles and aims to originate a broader range of products (RMBS, ABS, direct origination) rather than relying solely on bank underwriting.
- Apollo's relationship with Athene (15% equity owned, assets managed) targets a spread business generating 5.5% asset returns against 2% liability costs.
- Golden Tree identifies "triple C" securities with spreads under 700 basis points and issuance >10% of the high-yield universe as negative long-term prospects.
- Golden Tree highlighted a specific Argentina opportunity: floating-rate bonds issued by the Province of Buenos Aires offering ~10% USD yields (300 bps over sovereign) via local-to-USD swaps.
- CQS (Sir Michael Henze) utilizes complex legal analysis of corporate capital structures (e.g., Altice) to execute trades across cash bonds, CDS, options, and equity.
- Vardy emphasizes "credit with hair," building granular, country-specific platforms in distressed markets like Spain (NPLs) and India (banking sector reforms).
Interest Rate Exposure & Hedging
- Apollo structures 80%+ of its portfolio (excluding distressed/deep value) with floating rate exposure to benefit from rising LIBOR.
- Golden Tree reports limited fixed income exposure in its flagship fund, with rates acting as its biggest short position.
- CQS hedges fixed-rate credit exposures internally, relying on the floating nature of many structured credit and loan instruments.
- Credit Suisse projects four more Fed rate hikes by the end of the year, with current 3-month LIBOR at 2.40%.
- Rising rates have resulted in 1.95% year-to-date returns for loans, while high yields remained flat and investment grades fell 3.75% (unhedged).
- Panelists warn that a "step change" or uncontrolled inflation spike poses greater systemic risk than gradual normalization.
- Hertz was cited as an example of a company where a 100 bps rate increase on its fleet would consume $60 million of EBITDA due to high floating rate exposure relative to leverage.
Regulatory & Technological Disruption
- US risk retention rule changes in 2017–2018 led to a sky-rocketing in CLO issuance volume despite cheap liabilities.
- ECB regulations are driving opportunities in European non-performing loans (NPLs) and banking recapitalizations.
- Indian government reforms (insolvency code, equity injection) are creating a catalyst for the country to enter the distressed market, with NPLs estimated at 10–15% of bank assets.
- Technology obsolescence is expected to increase dispersion in performance, leading to higher defaults and lower recoveries for firms unable to invest in software/digital transformation.
- Passive investing is causing equity volatility to compress relative to implied credit volatility, creating arbitrage opportunities for active managers.
- Market dynamics are shifting where equity values are increasingly leading indicators of distress, sometimes preceding debt price corrections (e.g., McClatchy).
Investor Returns & Capacity
- Target risk-adjusted returns for permanent capital vehicles range from 6–12%, with direct origination targeting 8–9%.
- Jim Zelter (Apollo) estimates capacity to generate 8% returns is "gazillions" via their permanent capital engine.
- Joe (Golden Tree) confirmed capacity in the billions for various strategies (US, Europe, emerging markets, distressed) with long track records.
- Sir Michael Henze (CQS) stated exceptional comfort in delivering 7–8% returns over time, though capacity is linked to client risk tolerance and volatility preferences.
- Panelists anticipate a return of event-driven investing as quantitative easing and passive indexing reduce the efficiency of broad credit indices.
- There is a consensus that "credit is not a single market," and investors must avoid homogenized views to capture value in specific capital structures and geographies.