Conference Presentation, Keynote
François Chollet: How We Get To AGI
Core Definitions and Shifts in AI Intelligence
- Fluid Intelligence vs. Static Skills: Intelligence is defined as the ability to handle novel situations and synthesize new programs on the fly, distinct from static, memorized skills or task-specific automation.
- The Failure of Pre-training Scaling: Despite a 50,000x increase in pre-training data and compute, models failed to improve on the Abstraction Reasoning Corpus (ARC-1), scoring only 10% compared to human scores above 95%.
- Paradigm Shift (2024): The field has moved from pre-training scaling to Test-Time Adaptation (TTA), where models dynamically modify their internal state during inference to solve unseen problems.
- The Role of Benchmarks: Traditional benchmarks (like exams) measure memorized skills and lead to "Goodhart's Law" (optimizing the metric while missing the point); they are inadequate for measuring genuine AGI.
- Efficiency as the Metric: Intelligence is defined as the operational efficiency ratio of converting past information (experience) into actions for future, novel situations.
Evolution of the ARC Benchmark Series
- ARC-1 (Released 2019):
- Designed to distinguish fluid intelligence from pattern memorization using 1,000 unique tasks based on core priors (physics, geometry, counting).
- Demonstrated that scaling pre-trained models yields near-zero accuracy on fluid reasoning tasks.
- OpenAI's o3 model (fine-tuned for ARC) achieved human-level performance, validating the TTA paradigm.
- ARC-2 (Released March 2025):
- Focuses on compositional generalization and deliberate reasoning rather than instant pattern matching.
- Human Performance: Solved by 100% of a random sample of 400 non-expert humans; requires no specialized training.
- AI Performance: Static models score 0%; single-chain-of-thought models score 1–2%; only TTA systems achieve meaningful scores, yet they remain far below human levels.
- Status: ARC-2 saturates below human-level intelligence, proving current systems lack true general fluid capability.
- ARC-3 (Planned for Early 2026):
- Will assess agency, requiring models to explore unknown environments, set goals, and interact autonomously without prior knowledge of controls or objectives.
- Introduces strict action efficiency limits to measure how quickly a model solves tasks compared to human speed.
- Will feature a developer preview in July 2025.
Theoretical Framework: The Kaleidoscope Hypothesis and Abstractions
- Kaleidoscope Hypothesis: The universe contains limited "atoms of meaning" (isomorphisms) that are recombined to create the appearance of infinite novelty. Intelligence is the ability to identify and reuse these building blocks.
- Two Types of Abstraction:
- Type 1 (Value-Centric/Continuous): Based on perception, intuition, and gradient descent; excellent for pattern recognition but fails at discrete logic (e.g., sorting).
- Type 2 (Program-Centric/Discrete): Based on exact structure matching, graph isomorphism, and logical reasoning; essential for human-like problem solving and invention.
- The Missing Link: Current deep learning models excel at Type 1 but lack Type 2 capabilities; they cannot perform discrete program search or compositional generalization efficiently.
Future Architecture and Endia's Roadmap
- System 1 + System 2 Integration: The next generation of AI must combine Type 1 (fast, approximate intuition) with Type 2 (rigorous, discrete search).
- Deep Learning-Guided Search: Using neural networks to map discrete program spaces into continuous latent spaces to mitigate combinatorial explosion during program synthesis.
- Programmer-Like Meta-Learners: Future systems will synthesize custom software (blending DL submodules and algorithmic modules) for each new task rather than relying on fixed parameters.
- Dynamic Abstraction Library: Models will maintain a growing, evolving library of reusable code blocks/abstractions, uploading new solutions back to the library for future reuse (analogous to GitHub).
- Goal of Endia: To build systems capable of independent scientific invention and discovery, moving beyond automation to accelerate the timeline of science by solving ARC-1 and beyond.