Panel, Conference Presentation
Investing in Ukraine's Future | Global Conference 2025
Milken InstituteGillian Tett, Philip Bennett, Xavier Bettel, Wladimir Klitschko, Oleksandra Matviichuk, Yuriy Vitrenko
Current Conflict Outlook
- Most panelists and the audience reject the likelihood of a peace deal within six months, with a broader consensus placing a realistic timeline at approximately three years.
- Russia currently holds the initiative on ceasefire negotiations, having proposed only a temporary three-day pause rather than accepting a permanent ceasefire.
- President Putin's domestic political constraints make a peace deal politically suicidal in the short term, while Ukrainian leaders feel less urgency due to strengthening domestic drone production and defensive capabilities.
The U.S.-Ukraine Minerals (Hydrocarbons) Deal
- Deputy Prime Minister Xavier Bettel confirmed the U.S. signed a minerals deal with Ukraine, though he warned of unpredictability regarding potential U.S. concessions on Lugansk and Donetsk.
- Former Naftogaz CEO Yuri Vitrenko clarified the agreement is broader than minerals, encompassing oil and gas, and serves as a potential first step toward a peace or armistice agreement.
- Vitrenko estimates the probability of a peace deal or armistice (similar to the Korean scenario) at slightly above 50% within the next year, contingent on demonstrated strength from the U.S. and Europe.
- The deal is viewed as a "win-win" that provides Ukraine with necessary investment and security guarantees while offering the U.S. access to critical resources.
Human Rights and War Crimes
- Nobel Peace Prize laureate Alla Aleksandr (Alexandra) documented over 84,000 war crime episodes, emphasizing that Russia's goal is the total destruction of Ukraine and the restoration of a Soviet-style empire.
- A primary concern raised is the deportation of over 20,000 Ukrainian children to Russia, with reports of torture, forced adoption, and mass graves under Russian occupation.
- Panelists fear that a rush for a political settlement may lead to impunity for Russian leaders, undermining sustainable peace.
- Aleksandr advocates for a Special Tribunal on Aggression to hold Putin and top military command accountable immediately, arguing that justice is a prerequisite for lasting peace.
Investment Landscape and Reconstruction Needs
- The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) has deployed approximately $7.5 billion of its own balance sheet in Ukraine since the full-scale invasion, blending it with $2.5 billion in donor funds.
- EBRD Secretary-General Scott Besant noted the bank aims to scale investment to $3–4 billion annually in a post-conflict scenario, focusing on energy, defense, agribusiness, and high-tech sectors.
- Estimates for total reconstruction costs range as high as $700 billion, requiring a mix of grants, credits, and subsidies.
- The EBRD identifies nuclear power (specifically Small Modular Reactors or SMRs) as a critical investment avenue, with Holtec already signed to supply reactors starting in 2029.
- Energy sector privatization, including state-owned enterprises, is identified as the "sweetest spot" for private equity, offering immediate cash flows to fund greenfield investments.
Funding Mechanisms and Frozen Assets
- Deputy PM Bettel highlighted the legal complexity of confiscating Russian frozen assets; current international law requires a judicial decision rather than a political one to prevent investor mistrust in European jurisdictions.
- While interest from frozen assets is currently being used to fund Ukraine, the confiscation of the principal assets remains blocked by legal fears of future liability for countries like Belgium.
- Yuri Vitrenko argued that freezing assets must be a legal punishment for war crimes, advocating for the seizure of the core assets rather than just interest.
- There is a strategic push to link Ukraine's future investment climate to EU accession, which would provide long-term legal guarantees and access to EU funding.
Sector-Specific Opportunities
- Energy: With an estimated $200 billion needed for the energy grid, reconstruction involves both repairing existing infrastructure and building new distributed energy systems to counter Russian attacks.
- Technology: Ukraine has become the world's second-largest drone manufacturer, adapting rapidly through digitalization (e.g., Starlink) and homegrown innovation to maintain sovereignty.
- Agriculture: The panel noted Ukraine's status as a global agribusiness superpower, though investment requires strong government guarantees to mitigate war risks.
- Security: Private sector interest is high in the defense industry, particularly in drone technology and related high-tech manufacturing.
Strategic and Geopolitical Context
- Putin's long-term objective is described as overturning the current international order to establish a world where authoritarian regimes operate above international law.
- Ukraine's resilience is framed as a defense of shared democratic values, with panelists noting that Ukraine's survival is existential for the broader European security architecture.
- The panel emphasized that investment must be distinguished between "conflict engagement" (risk mitigation, resilience) and "post-war reconstruction," with the EBRD acting as a critical partner to lower risk profiles for U.S. investors.