Panel, Conference Presentation
Outlook for High-Yield and Leveraged Finance
Milken InstituteTom Braithwaite, Christopher Boyle, Peter Budko, Henry Chyung, Robert Kricheff, Andrew Whittaker
Market Structure & Macroeconomic Outlook
- Global macroeconomic fundamentals point to a "slow growth, low interest rate" world characterized by weak PMIs, global trade, and retail sales.
- Central banks globally are pursuing unprecedented monetary policy, including negative interest rates and trillions in sovereign debt at negative yields.
- High-yield markets have rebounded sharply over the last 10 weeks, a move experts attribute to technical drivers and central bank sentiment rather than underlying fundamentals.
- One expert guarantees that markets will not continue to rise linearly, citing a "mini-cycle" compression into a four-month period.
- Asset classes (equities, oil, high yield) have moved in unison with central bank actions, specifically following the Fed's rate hike in December 2016 and Janet Yellen's dovish testimony in February 2017.
- There is a consensus that extreme central bank activity creates a "feedback loop" where markets ignore fundamentals, driving assets to "crash into a wall."
Credit Cycle & Default Trends
- The market is currently in the late stages of a credit cycle, with experts observing that the rebound has pushed marginal borrowers back into capital markets.
- A "bifurcation" is occurring within the high-yield market, with defensive sectors outperforming cyclical sectors like energy, metals, and mining.
- In the first quarter of 2017, "fallen angels" (downgraded investment-grade bonds) outnumbered new high-yield issues by a ratio of 2:1.
- Approximately $140 billion in downgrades entered the market in Q1 2017, with 89-90% of these occurring in the metals/mining and oil/gas sectors.
- Default rates are currently skewed by the energy sector; excluding commodities, the default rate in the high-yield market is approximately 0.4%.
- Analysts predict that while defaults will not spike immediately due to a lack of visible catalysts, the "coyote" (a black swan event) remains a risk.
- Historical cycles suggest defaults peak 12-18 months after the initial bust, implying a lag in the energy sector's full resolution.
- Banks are expected to be less lenient during redeterminations in this cycle compared to previous downturns, likely forcing further defaults in cyclical sectors.
Sector-Specific Dynamics
- Energy: The sector is considered "funky" and difficult to quantify due to geopolitical and emotional pricing factors; rig counts are down nearly 80% from peaks, but bankruptcy waves are expected to continue.
- Retail: The sector faces significant headwinds from technology shifts, though some strong operators exist; experts remain selective and have avoided significant exposure.
- LBOs: The Leveraged Buyout market is rebounding, with more deals announced and backlog moving off bank balance sheets, though LBOs are not strictly necessary for a functioning high-yield market.
- BDCs (Business Development Companies): Direct lending by BDCs is filling a vacuum left by bank reticence; the industry is viewed as ripe for consolidation with many small public BDCs existing.
- M&A: Corporations are utilizing low-cost debt to drive growth through acquisitions (M&A) rather than organic revenue growth, as revenue growth is near zero in many markets.
Liquidity & Market Mechanics
- Trading volumes are historically high, yet market participants report perceived illiquidity due to reduced bank balance sheets, regulatory constraints (Basel III, Dodd-Frank), and a consolidation of trading desks.
- The rise of passive investing (ETFs and mutual funds) is amplifying short-term volatility and price dislocations, creating opportunities for active managers but increasing negative feedback loops during sell-offs.
- ETFs create a "funnel" effect where high retail inflows meet a shrinking pool of active Wall Street traders, accelerating price movements.
- While structured credit and ETFs can execute at high volumes, long-term investors often face price sensitivity that restricts participation.
- One expert noted that if one ignores price, liquidity is sufficient; if one is price-sensitive, they must be selective and hold assets long-term.
Negative Interest Rates & Forward-Looking Risks
- Negative interest rates are viewed as a "distorted uncle" to the family, potentially creating asset bubbles and squeezing bank profit margins.
- There is concern that negative rates will exacerbate global inequality and force investors to ignore credit fundamentals in the hunt for yield.
- The "unwind" of negative/low rates is expected to be disruptive if it occurs during a period of weak economic growth; ideally, it will happen alongside improving corporate profits.
- Equity markets are seen as the "most levered asset class," with earnings being "manufactured" via cost-cutting and synergies rather than genuine growth.
- Financial engineering is currently driving growth in M&A, with companies borrowing at near-zero rates to acquire assets, creating fragility if rates rise in a zero-growth environment.
Investment Strategy & Opportunities
- Active management is preferred over passive strategies to navigate the volatility in semi-liquid, commodity-exposed asset classes.
- Distressed debt investors are busy but note that many balance sheets remain over-levered with negative cash flow.
- Diversification is cited as the primary defense against illiquidity and sector-specific downturns, allowing investors to avoid over-leveraged names.
- High-quality, defensive businesses are expected to remain supportive of high yields even if cyclical sectors face downturns.
- Investors are advised to be cautious, noting that while the current environment offers yield, it lacks the "real" revenue growth seen in previous expansions.