newsfilter
← Latest News
U.S. Department of Justice·

Federal Court Dismisses Challenge to National Security Exemption for Energy Development in Gulf of America

The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia dismissed a lawsuit earlier this week challenging the first national security exemption ever issued pursuant to the Endangered Species Act. The exemption terminated litigation threatening oil and gas in the Gulf of America — a critical source of domestic production. The court held that it lacked jurisdiction because Congress directed all challenges to the Committee’s exemption decisions to the federal courts of appeals, not the district courts.  

“Energy security is national security, and Endangered Species Committee’s exemption is ensuring continued domestic production of 15% of the nation’s oil,” said Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Adam Gustafson of the Justice Department's Energy and Natural Resources Division (ENRD). “The district court agreed with us that legal challenges to such an exemption can only be heard in the courts of appeals. ENRD will continue to advance President Donald J. Trump's commitment to unleash American energy.”  

In 1978, Congress established the Endangered Species Committee, comprised of six senior federal officials chaired by the Secretary of the Interior, and authorized it to exempt federal agency actions from the ESA's requirements. The statute directs the Committee to grant an exemption whenever the Secretary of War finds that an exemption is necessary for reasons of national security. On March 31, the Committee voted unanimously to grant an exemption for Gulf of America oil and gas activities, acting on the Secretary of War's finding that the exemption was necessary for reasons of national security. It was the first exemption the Committee has granted on national security grounds. 

Several environmental groups then sued in district courts. According to the motion to dismiss, Congress assigned judicial review of the Committee's exemption decisions to the appellate courts. The district court agreed in this case, concluding that Congress created only one type of exemption and “funneled challenges to those exemptions to the courts of appeals.” It dismissed the entire case for lack of jurisdiction, including the plaintiff’s related claims challenging the Secretary of War’s national security finding and its claims under the National Environmental Policy Act. 

The ruling follows decisions earlier this year by federal courts in the District of Columbia, Maryland, and Louisiana that gave effect to the Committee's exemption. The exemption for Gulf of America oil and gas activities remains in place. 

Attorneys with ENRD's Wildlife and Marine Resources Section handled this matter.

Keywords
Environment