newsfilter
← Latest News
SEC Speeches and Statements·

Remarks at the Practicing Law Institute’s 58th Annual Institute on Securities Regulation

  • Commissioner Mark T. Uyeda delivered remarks on Nov. 2, 2026, marking the 20th anniversary of the SEC's 2006 Corporate Penalty Statement & his 20th year of employment at the Commission.
  • The Corporate Penalty Statement was issued unanimously in Jan. 2006 to provide an analytical framework for imposing civil penalties on corporate issuers, emphasizing that penalties should not harm shareholders who are principal victims of violations.
  • The framework's two principal considerations are whether the corporation received a direct benefit from the violation & the degree to which the penalty will compensate or further harm injured shareholders, alongside seven additional factors like deterrence, intent, & cooperation.
  • A 2007 pilot program intended to give the Statement practical force was discontinued in 2009, leading to a period where the Statement was seldom cited in public reasoning or used as an internal analytical tool.
  • Despite the Statement's diminished visibility, the Commission imposed record financial remedies in FY 2024, prompting Acting Chairman Uyeda to direct staff in Jan. 2025 to adhere to the Statement & include it in the Feb. 2026 Enforcement Manual updates.
  • Uyeda identifies seven modern developments requiring the framework's refinement: constant shareholder turnover obscuring who pays penalties, complications of Fair Funds in compensating victims, penalties for non-intent violations like controls failures, the unique corporate structures of SPACs, dual-class stock arrangements shifting costs to public shareholders, the interaction with the whistleblower program, & ambiguous definitions of corporate benefit in stock-based compensation fraud.
  • The Commissioner argues that the Commission must equally pursue individual wrongdoers using tools like cease-and-desist orders, bars from the industry, censure, & clawbacks under Sarbanes-Oxley to ensure accountability falls on responsible people rather than innocent shareholders.
  • The speech concludes that while the Corporate Penalty Statement's core principles remain valid, the SEC must apply them visibly & extend them thoughtfully to address new market realities & ensure individuals responsible for misconduct are held accountable.