newsfilter
← Latest News
SEC Speeches and Statements·

Remarks to the American Bar Association Federal Regulation of Securities Winter Meeting

  • Commissioner Mark T. Uyeda stated that the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act Section 1502, intended to reduce violence in the DRC through conflict minerals disclosure, has failed to achieve its humanitarian goals.
  • The rule mandated companies to report on the use of tin, tantalum, tungsten, & gold from the DRC region, theoretically to starve armed groups of revenue.
  • Following industry advice in 2011, major buyers withdrew from eastern Congo, causing a 90 percent drop in exports & creating a de facto embargo that devastated local livelihoods.
  • A 2023 study found the law reduced employment at mines & may have pushed miners toward armed groups, while a 2024 GAO report linked the rule to a spread of violence.
  • Transparency goals were not met; the GAO found 62 percent of companies with due diligence could not determine if minerals originated in the DRC due to smuggling & complex supply chains.
  • Conditions improved at mines only after industrialization brought private security, whereas US withdrawal allowed Chinese firms to gain commanding positions in the sector.
  • Legal challenges began in 2015 when the D.C. Circuit ruled parts of the SEC rule violated the First Amendment, leading to a remand in 2017 with no subsequent major SEC action.
  • Uyeda argues that securities disclosure laws were not designed for foreign conflict resolution & that peace & security depend on diplomacy, development, & economic policy.
  • The Commissioner suggested options ranging from legislative repeal to utilizing the statute's national security waiver to shift away from the current disclosure approach.
  • Uyeda emphasized that American engagement in critical mineral supply chains is vital for national security & that withdrawing via disclosure rules risks neither good disclosure nor positive outcomes in Africa.