Stephens Annual Investment Conference | Nash2026 - ANDERSONS INC
Hello everyone and thanks for joining us today. I'm Puran Sharma and I cover food, agribusiness, and sea stores as an equity research analyst at Stevens. And it's my pleasure to welcome you all to today's fireside chat with the Andersons. For those of you that are less familiar with the company, the Andersions is a Maumee, Ohio-based agribisness and renewable fuels company operating through two segments, agribusiness and renewables. Its businesses span grain origination, storage and merchandising, fertilizer and specialty ingredients, ethanol production, and renewable feedstock merchandising. The company has broadened its North American footprint through strategic investments and is expanding its low-carbon ethanol platform, most recently through its announced acquisition of Harveststone Low-Carbon Partners. Joining us today are Bill Kruger, President and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Valentine, Executive Vice President and chief financial officer. Thank you both for being here. To kick things off, I'll turn it over to Bill to provide a brief overview in the State of the Union on the Andersons, and then we'll dive into Q&A. Over to you, Bill. Thank you. Good afternoon. I appreciate the time to talk. One of the key things that we're excited to discuss today is the recent transaction of Harvestone Low Carbon Partners. But in addition to that, the ability for the company to generate increased EPS, increased EBITDA over the past trailing 12 months is something that we are very proud of. The entire team of employees that we have are the reason why we feel like our business as a one Andy approach is really creating a mindset that's going to allow us to continue to perform the next several years. Thank you, Bill. Maybe just on that point, you mentioned the Hearthstone strategic transaction. maybe we could dig into the rationale. You highlighted North Dakota as a geography where the Andersons historically had limited exposure, and you also emphasized the value of the plant's on-site carbon capture capabilities. Beyond the immediate 45Z economics, what most attracted you to that footprint? Is it the bigger opportunity access to surplus corn and Canadian low-carbon markets or the ability to expand your merchandising network into a region where you didn't have much presence before? That's a good question. The HLCP transaction really brings several items together. And first, in any transaction, there has to be a cultural fit between the two organizations. And that is one thing that the senior management and employees of Harveststone really mesh well with the Andersons. We're looking forward to post-closing being able to interact. The two management teams bring a different skill set, which I'll dive into more later through the fireside chat. But in addition to a culture and a mindset of the employees is the addition of low-carbon CI. We really believe that that is going to be a competitive advantage as we move forward. Being in the CCS market day one after close is something that we're really looking forward to. A lot of ethanol companies are working through the process of getting permitted, finding opportunities outside of pipelines to be able to sequester carbon, and we feel like that's going to be a real advantage. And then if you take the scale of 730 million gallons of production day one post-close, add to that our de-bottlenecking project in Climbers, Indiana, which will be online, Getting the Andersons to north of 750 million gallons of production is something that we've shared with the shareholders. I believe that we have been very disciplined in our capital. And then looking forward with future projects combined across seven plants is something that really excites us about the overall larger footprint. And, Pran, maybe just to add to that a little bit, I think there's some parallels that can be drawn between this transaction and the Lansing deal that we did back in 2019 from the standpoint of the complementary skill sets of the two teams and the complementary nature of the businesses, both geographically, but also, again, the capabilities that are brought. So Bill referenced sort of the carbon sequestration capabilities. That's a skill set and something that they're doing already today that we don't have in-house. So that's something that certainly they bring. But then when you think about two of the three plants are running the same technology as our plants run today and and there's also the fact that today they're uh paying somebody to originate the corn into their plants and also market the the finished products and those are things that we have those capabilities in-house today so and i think then there's also the geographic footprint of more access to the the western corn belt so there's there's some really nice complementary things between the two companies and and we're really excited Thank you, Brian and Bill. Maybe just sticking with Hearthstone, one thing I wanted to clarify regarding the $225 million to $250 million annual EBITDA outlook, given that Dakota Spirit is expected to begin sequestration in early 2027 and Iroquois in late 2028, how should we be thinking about the cadence of earnings over the next few years? Does that outlook already contemplate a meaningful ramp in sequestration benefits, or is there opportunity for earnings to step up higher as all three facilities become fully sequestered? Yeah, I could start on that one. And before we dive into the answer in more detail, it's probably worth mentioning we're talking about some forward-looking statements. And so certainly those numbers can change, and we're between signing and closing and all that kind of stuff. But a couple things that we wanted to talk through on the transaction, I guess first, let me start with the purchase price a little bit. This is really probably the first transaction of this nature that brings together base ethanol, low CI ethanol, combined with the 45Z and the 45Q tax credits. And so when we think about the $915 million purchase price, really that number includes just a little under $60 million of working capital. So when you back that off, you kind of come down to roughly $4 per gallon. And we've said that that is roughly 50-50 split between the value of the 45Z and 45Q cash flow streams. And then really that would leave $2 a gallon for base ethanol plus the low CI premium. So, you know, with regard to the $225 to $250 million each of the first three years, what I would say is Blue Flint is already up and running and sequestering and capturing carbon and going down hole. Dakota Spirit, we expect to come online with sequestration in the early part of 2027. So that really should be in from the early years. And then the Rensselaer, Indiana plant would be more in 2029. So I would Say if you're thinking about that model, maybe it's of the 225 to 250. Maybe it's starting out at the lower end of that range in the first year or two, and then ramping up to the higher end of the range and hopefully even with some upside beyond. Okay. Thank you for that detail there. Maybe just sticking on carbon sequestration economics, on the last earnings call you cautioned investors against simply adding the incremental 45Z benefits from sequesteration without accounting for the associated operating costs, including compression, transportation, and what you refer to as downhole cost, can you help us quantify those expenses on a cents per gallon basis? And how should we think about these costs as relatively consistent across facilities, or could they vary meaningfully depending on the plant and its sequestration infrastructure? Yeah, so at a high level, I guess let's start with bringing it back to the EBITDA range. I would say we believe it's reasonable to think that about half of the $225 to $250 million EBITDA range annually can be attributed to 45Z net of operating costs and other discounts. So we can't really get into a price per gallon or a cost per gallon breakdown at this point because we're between signing and closing. But what we can say is there's a couple different sequestration scenarios. The first is where you're doing direct inject and going down hole on site. And that would be an example, the example of that would be at Blue Flint. The second scenario would be where you are transporting it. So maybe you are trucking it. So you are capturing it on site, but then you are trucking in. And that is the scenario that Dakota Spirit would have when they are up and running. So obviously there would be some incremental costs of doing that. Eventually the Indiana plant would look more like Blue Flint where there's a direct downhole on site and i guess a third scenario in the in the marketplace would be if you're going to a pipeline because then you're gonna have you'll have transport costs to get it there and then you'll also have either some sort of credit or cost sharing uh with the pipeline operator so there's that's sort of the the three or four different scenarios that you could think of across that spectrum one thing i'd like to add is as brian said we are um between signing and closing so uh we're restricted from talking about uh certain items uh our hope is that at our um q4 earnings call in february that we'll be able to give more color uh if the uh if we're closed thank you for the clarification and the color um Maybe just sticking on the two North Dakota plants, they sell into different markets than your legacy ethanol facilities. And so as you integrate these businesses, where do you see the greatest incremental value from your existing corn origination? Ethanol marketing and co-product merchandising capabilities? Or just kind of where doyou see the most opportunity? It's really going to be a combination, but we believe the net result of being in the low CI production of ethanol day one is really where the most value is going to come from. And our belief is that low CI ethanol is really going to be the differentiation of value creation in ethanol in the future. And we could talk quite a bit about the different markets, but we believe the commoditized aspect of ethanol will be different than being able to produce an oxygen level that has an ultra-low CI, which we describe as below 20 CI. So that's the first and foremost opportunity. You can't get that without the cost of sequestration. sequestration. But then if you just step back and look at the Andersons who've been in the ethanol industry since the beginning, and in July or August of 2025, we doubled our size by taking 100% ownership of our legacy plants. Then with this transaction, we're able to add another 215 million gallons, like I mentioned earlier. But across all our entire merchandising platform, we're increasing our ethanol production, co-product trading by 40% with one transaction that is above any of our internal hurdle rates, which we feel like is a really good deployment the capital. And thank you for that, Bill. Since we're just on sequestration, what are you looking for in terms of milestone? Blue Flint is already sequestering carbon. Dakota Spirit expected early 2027. Iroquois targeting late 28. What are the most important execution milestones investors should watch out for over the next 12 to 18 months. Is there any downside to the $225 to $250 million in annual EBITDA outlook if one of these were not to be on schedule? It's a good question. The DSA project, as we've been on site a number of times now, really is something that we feel is going to come online very shortly after post-close. So we feel that that is really set and we don't see that sliding substantially to affect the model. If you want to look at the Rensselaer plant, then it really just becomes a mathematical equation between the value of 45Z and the value of 45Q, because as time decays, if 45Z is not extended, it's just simply a mathematical equation. So to us, it is very measurable and one that we will be able to report to our investors if for some reason we see a change in the Rensselaer plant. And again, we really don't think that the Dakota Spirit sequestration project can materially affect the returns. Thank you, Bill. Maybe just on the de-bottlenecking, you've said that all three harvest stone plants offer relatively low-cost de-bottenecking opportunities and that the combined output could exceed 250 million gallons over the next 24 to 36 months. Is that opportunity fairly balanced across the three facilities or are one or two materially more attractive? What kind of returns are you underwriting and what is the payback period? And also, would higher volumes require incremental investment in CO2 handling or sequestration capacity? In terms of de-bottlenecking order, it would seem that it makes the most sense to target the lowest CI opportunities first. And that's what we will do. So that very clearly means North Dakota would be the area we'd focus on the most while we go through the sequestration process at Rensselaer, Indiana. The one thing that I do think is important for the investors to understand, we did not have anything in our modeling for de-bottlenecking or increased production in the numbers that Brian talked about earlier. As all capital projects are inside the Andersons, will go through our regimented process to where we assure that any capital spent in the future will be above our expected return metrics. So each of these projects will get evaluated like we do with all of our capital expenditures, but we do believe that the opportunities would first be around low CI, and then secondly, around other opportunities at Rensselaer. Got it. Thank you, Bill. Maybe just on earnings durability here, the $225 to $250 million in annual EBITDA is a substantial step up in earnings power. Without asking you to break out the exact tax credit contribution gain, And how should investors think about the durability of that earnings profile beyond the 45Z window? Is the combination of 45Q, low carbon fuel premiums, and operating efficiencies enough to protect a meaningful portion of those economics? Yes. So again, our modeling had the expiration or sunset of 45Z at the end of 2029, which is what the law states today. If you're able to utilize the 45Q, which is about tons of carbon sequestered, not about the CI score, that cash flow stream allows you to generate the low CI ethanol into the future, and then you're able to take the 45Z funds that we're going to achieve between 27, 28, and 29 and redeploy those into other opportunities across the entire enterprise, whether it's agribusiness or renewables. Thank you for that, Bill. Maybe we could shift over to your long-term target. One thing that sticks out is how quickly you've progressed toward your longer-term financial targets. You've previously outlined a goal of achieving $7 in run rate EPS exiting 2028, and you're already generating approximately $670 on a trailing 12-month basis, even before the Hearthstone acquisition. Given that progress, how should investors think about the $7 target today? And as you look at the improvement in earnings over the past year, how much do you believe reflects structural improvements to the business versus favorable market conditions? Yeah, thanks, Pran. What I would say is we feel really good about the progress that we've made toward that $7 EPS target. And as you said, we're just shy of $6.70. What I would say is then anything harvest stone will be incremental to that. You know, we have seen some improvement in market conditions. I mean, we had talked about previously sort of in the agribusiness side of the business where we said kind of 24, 25 felt like the trough. We saw some improvement and some volatility sort of over the summer. Now, some of that has retraced a little bit more recently. But I would say we've also seen just in, if you think about overall blend rates and ethanol demand globally, what we've seen, there's some good structural improvement there as well. Our plan, and Bill alluded to this earlier, assuming everything closes, our plan would be to come out with an updated longer-term target post-closing, hopefully at our at our fourth corner earnings teleconference got it thank you thank you brian and maybe just one more uh more more for you here um on the uh transaction it's it's being financed with debt but you expect leverage around two times at closing and most acquisition related debt to be repaid within five years how does that affect your appetite for additional internal growth projects and shareholder returns, does deleveraging become the clear priority or do you see room for high return investments across the existing portfolio? Yeah, I think from our perspective, we expect an ongoing balanced approach. As you said, we're planning to finance the business or the acquisition with debt. It'll be a combination mostly of bank debt, probably call it two-thirds long-term debt and a portion on our revolver. But with the really strong operating cash flows, I mean, if you think of from an EBITDA perspective, our trailing 12 months EBITTA was about $470 million. And you layer in this $225 to $250, you're essentially at $700 million of EBITMA. And then you have some of the very quick cash flow of the 45Z tax credits in the early years. And so that should enable us to de-lever a bit. But as you said, out of the gate, we expect that we're still going to be roughly two times. We should actually, in fact, be below two times long-term debt to EBITDA. So we expect to continue to invest in the business in organic growth projects and also return cash to shareholders, but obviously are going to, uh, be very focused on maintaining a strong balance sheet in the process. Thank you, Brian. Maybe moving over to agribusiness. Um, we've seen a pretty interesting divergence in crop conditions this year with drought and lower production in the western corn belt, but a much stronger harvest across your eastern footprint. You've also mentioned that delayed harvesting and slower farmer selling could shift some earnings opportunities from 4Q into early 2027. Could you walk us through how the business is positioned heading into next year, particularly around grain merchandising opportunities, storage economics, and farmer selling behavior yeah um so as we are uh finally nearing the end of uh corn harvest which has been uh stretched out across both the eastern and uh western corn belts uh approaching 90 percent harvested uh today in the eastern corn belt we finished well of a plan on soybean receipts which we don't talk a lot about as an organization. But the soybean crop, as I mentioned, on our earnings call was really benefited by some of the later rains. In addition, with the drawn out harvest in the east, we're going to be kind of at plan on corn receipts, could be potentially a little less as we finish up in Michigan. Our Nebraska assets, which we did not talk about, On the earnings call, we're going to finish above plan. So we feel really good coming out of harvest. The one item that we did see was with the drop in futures the last 30 days is that farmer selling has slowed. And we've seen an uptick in both corn and bean bases, both in the east and the west, but a little stronger in the east. And so I can't really answer the question as far as the shift goes between Q1 and Q2 today. But we do feel very confident that the sum total will be, there won't be material change. Yeah, thank you for that, Bill. Maybe just shifting to fertilizer and acreage, you've indicated that fall fertilizer applications started well and growers were maintaining application rates. After the volatility we've seen in corn prices, how are farmers approaching their 2027 acreage and input decisions? Do you expect stronger corn prices to support nutrient application and yields, or is it more important constraint still farmer profitability and cash flow? Yeah, it's a combination of the two. The one thing that I want to start with the producer and their marketing in kind of coming out of summer, early fall. the farmer in general did a really good job of rewarding the market for the futures rally that we had so if you look at um the the nice sales that they made uh if they made them early in the year and we think roughly uh half of our producer base has priced their corn crop that coupled with some of the government payments that they've received really has has gotten the farmer in a good cash flow position going through your end. Switching over to fertilizer and a little bit maybe more specific to your questions, we've seen really good fall applications. It's been good weather. Even though the corn crop was delayed, we've had warm conditions and fertilizer applications are kind of at or slightly above plan. So we feel really good to that. The cost of the inputs, slightly higher due to both geopolitical, but quite honestly, stronger global demand for fertilizer. So the U.S. farmer is seeing a little bit of uptick. It's too early to be talking about corn acres versus bean acres next year. the one thing that we are certain of is that both hard and soft wheat acres are going to be up about 10%. They're going to take some of those acres from someplace, right? And, you know, today our lean would be they probably take more from corn than beans, but that's still to be determined. Another benefit to fertilizer is with the strong increase in wheat acres and some of it going in a little later, assuming a normal weather pattern through the winter, we should see a strong demand for nitrogen for top dressing for the wheat come next spring, which will be something that we don't always get to see. And as I mentioned, you know, we'll need to continue to monitor the corn bean ratio to see the difference between planted acres. In total, though, early forecasts would be nominally lower corn acres and maybe flat soybean acres for 2027 planting season. Got it. Thank you, Bill. And I think we probably have time for one more here, and maybe just on the Port of Houston. Soybean meal export expansion is now operating. Started booking shipments into 2027. As the terminal ramps, are you still comfortable with the roughly 15 to 20 million of annual EBITDA opportunity that you've previously discussed? What is the biggest gating factor to reaching that run rate? Is it customer development, vessel utilization, originations, or market spreads? It's a combination of all those, but I am happy to announce that this week we finished loading our first soybean meal vessel. Things went very well, so we are now exiting the commissioning stage of the facility. so as a reminder the the new houston portfolio which used to be all grain is now a mix between soybean meal and grains so i want to take your question in two parts the largest gating factor for soybean meal is going to be crush you know we just saw uh that uh we had record uh crush last month. We believe that the crush margins through 2027 and likely beyond are going to remain strong, generating excess meal. So we believe crush margins and originations are the two gating factors for soybean meal. Soybean meal is going to typically run September through March, just as it competes with South America. So that aspect of the plan appears to be pretty good. Looking forward into 2027, you know, it's really a corn and sorghum play, or excuse me, wheat and sorkhum play. We feel good on wheat exports with the increase in hard wheat acres, that'll start around new crops. So let's call it June, July, China is going to really hinge more on, I'm sorry, sorghum is going hinge more China. So, you know, that's one market condition we can't really manage. However, our sorgham pricing in the US is making itself a lot more competitive into the EU. So as we look forward, today, we feel very comfortable with that range of EBITDA. Thank you. Thank You, Bill. Thank you, Brian. Appreciate you joining us here at Stevens and thank you all for joining us today.
- Company
- ANDERSONS INC
- Keywords
- ANDERSONS INC