newsfilter
← Latest News
Earnings Call Transcripts·

STEPHENS ANNUAL INVESTMENT CONFERENCE | NASH2026 - CANNAE HOLDINGS INC

Here in Nashville, I'm Oscar Nieves, research analyst here at Stevens. We're excited to have Kenai Holdings, ticker CNME, with us this afternoon. Kenai is a principal investment firm focused on a concentrated portfolio of controlling and minority interests with a growing emphasis on sports and entertainment. Its largest investment is Black Knight Football Club, which is a multi-club platform that includes AFC Bournemouth, FC Lorient, and Moray Rens. And joining me is CEO Ryan Castle. Thank you for being here. And we'll start with the strategy, spend some time on Black Knight football, and then spend also some time with the non-core assets and your capital allocation strategy. So let's start, Ryan, with the big picture. For those less familiar with Kanai, how would you describe the strategy today and how has it evolved over the past year? Yeah, thank you, Oscar, and thank you for having us here. um i i think i mean look i think you did a good job describing it but we are an opportunistic uh investor we're we're historically been a holding company that owned um probably eight to ten core uh investments um we have been transitioning our portfolio um to focus on sports and entertainment where we believe um there is significant macro tailwinds that support the investment thesis coupled with, we believe that we have a unique experience and history operating and generating value in those assets and an ability to source them. So we've been monetizing our non-core assets and repositioning the portfolio, which we are very excited about. Yeah. The shift to sports, it's an interesting one. What makes sports and entertainment assets attractive? And how do you think about concentration versus diversification in the portfolio? We think sports present a very strong macroeconomic backdrop. We think that you can look through history and people have enjoyed and experiencing sports. And so we think there's a strong brand identity and significant ability to monetize the assets. And we like the macro picture, we also think that it's really important to be able to operate effectively in sports assets. And we have a proven playbook that we've used in multiple assets to generate value. In terms of concentration first diversification, we will, again, people think about concentration differently, but we will probably, you know, in an ideal world, we'll have five to 10 kind of core assets. And so we have two sports assets today, but we'd look to have five to 10 assets in our portfolio. Yeah. And within that, how over time do you anticipate having more meaningful positions or owning minority investments? How do you think about that? Is there one vision or can you incorporate both into your portfolio and your strategy? Yeah, we think we can incorporate both. where we focus thus far is on positions where we're in control or we have an ability to work with the team to drive the management of the team. I do think there are plenty of assets and given our capital base where a minority investment could be interesting. But we are, so we're looking at all. But in the short term and where we are today, we've been much more focused on control type investments where we can really drive outcomes. This year, you've returned a significant amount of capital to shareholders, primarily through buybacks. How do you decide between making a new investment and buying back your own stock, given your view that it's trading at a discount to its net asset value? Yeah. So quarterly, I work with our board and we look at both of the assets that we own and what we think are our core assets or where we can monetize. And then once we have the capital and when we're comparing it to a new investment, we try to look over the long-term horizon and whether that could make more sense or buying back stock. I mean, as you've seen, we've bought back significant amounts of stocks. We've been very committed to the buyback given the discount to NAV, and I continue to see that going forward. but we will look on an investment-by-investment basis to determine what we think makes the most economic sense. Maybe switching gears a little bit, and let's talk more in depth about the investments that you hold and own today. Black Knight Football is the biggest investment in Canine's portfolio. How do you think about Black Knight, which is, as I mentioned at the beginning, a multi-club platform? What does that mean? And what is the long-term vision for the teams within that platform? Yeah, so Black Knight Football today, we own three clubs. We own AFC Bournemouth in the Premier League. We own FC Lorient in League One in France. And we own Morence FC in Portugal. And we look at the platform probably a simplistic way to view it is kind of like a minor league baseball team. and that there's different pathways that you can use depending on the commercial realities of each of the leagues. We're super excited about each team. At Bournemouth, when we bought the team, it was in 19th place and on the verge of relegation. Last year, it finished in 6th place in the Premier League. It's best-ever finish in its over 100-year history as well as qualified for the Europa League, the first time it had ever been in a European competition. So we've had significant performance on the sporting side. We've built a new performance center. We're upgraded the stadium and we've seen significant progress on the commercial side of the business. So we are really excited about the changes and what we've done at Black Knight. I think going forward what we'd like to see is we'd continue to see the success and the continued rise of AFC Bournemouth. We'd also like to see the continued success of FC Lorient and Morense as they move in their leagues. And then the ability of our players to move between clubs and to generate the pathway, showing that we're able to utilize talent across each of the teams, which we believe over time will create value that we see through multiple on an ultimate exit. For someone that's newer to sports investing, what are the different revenue drivers for a sports team? Because, you know, I can think of selling merchandise, match day, sponsorships. What's the way to think about that so that we can get a better understanding of? Yeah, you hit most of them. I think the other big one is the media rights. So we think about there's media rights, there's sponsorship. membership so that's around the stadium on the the kits there's match day and there's those are kind of the big ones that I would say and so for the premier league one of the reasons that we like the league is that we think it's the the biggest football league in the world and has one one of arguably the best media contracts in the World right so the the lowest team in the premier league will do probably over 115 million pounds of revenue and then it goes up depending on placement so that's that's a huge driver in the league but then you also need to drive more of what we call the club controlled revenues which is match day sponsorship hospitality etc yeah and on the economics of the league if you can give people an overview of how those work for the premier league is uh whereas in other sports your uh your position on the standings is kind of irrelevant when it comes to revenue generation. That's not the case for the Premier League. Yeah. So the Premier League, there's a there's that they call like an equal share where everyone gets, which is roughly the call it one hundred ten hundred fifteen million. Each place that you get higher is about three million additional pounds. And then and then on top of that, there are different qualifications. So if you're in the top, it moves each year. But last year it was in the top seven um the top five or top eight excuse me the top five went to champions league which is additional revenue both from a from a media perspective as well as uh um the the incremental home games that you get um and then there's the europa league which we're in and then there's conference league so so those are the the other parts of the the media um contracts that you can get depending on your placement yeah you've talked uh in prior occasions about how Black Knight is trying to implement a playbook as it grows its various clubs. What are the main levers that go into that? Revenue growth, player development facilities, and how does that tie into investments in stadiums and facilities which Black Knight has been making over time? Yeah, one of the big things that, and I think Bill Foley learned this through the Golden Knights, is really trying to put a culture of excellence and putting the players in a position to succeed. And that's giving them the best facilities, the best coaching, the best performance, the most professionalism, the best food. And so one of the first things that we did when we acquired AFC Bournemouth was to start a new performance center to really give the players the best-in-class environment and show the ambition that we have for the club. So sporting is one. I think the other piece of it is on the business side and the commercial side and really trying to maximize every kind of revenue opportunity that you that you can. And so we put in we put into we brought over a guy that we'd worked with previously and put him at the head of business and he brought some others. And then the last one, look, these are community assets and making sure that, one, you're integrating with the community and, two, you are giving fans a great experience. And so part of that comes into the stadium renovation that we have done at Bournemouth. We have improved it. We have approved the hospitality. We have increased the size. And we've done it in a way that's kind of hand-in-hand with the local council, such that we are providing the community and the fans the best experience that they can. How should investors think about the earnings power of a sports club, especially in the case of Bournemouth, given all the player trading that you have been executing over the last few years? And how does that look going forward? Yeah. So I think just from a revenue expense perspective, the revenue is what we talked about earlier. And then the expenses are really the player salaries and other staff costs and other expenses to operate the business. So relatively a simple P&L. I think that what's different about the Premier League versus U.S. sports, which people are more familiar with, which I go back to in some of these analogies, is you have the ability to great contracts and sell the players for um for real dollars so you're both acquiring players and selling them so we have there's a component of what we refer to as trading income um those are um a bit more um lumpy like a couple seasons ago we sold i think over 300 million dollars of players in the last window we didn't we didn' t i think we sold basically none um so but if a team like ours is doing a good job, you will see player trading and you will see some profits on players. We'd like to keep our players for longer because obviously if you sell players, it's one of your better players that you're selling if you're making a profit on them. But you would expect to see player trading continue going forward. A few months ago, you announced the Exeter Ruby investment, which kind of moves you away from having three clubs that all you know it's football soccer what attracted you to that club and to branching out into a new sport entirely yeah so so Exeter is in rugby and it's based in in Exeter which is about 80 miles away from Bournemouth it's a different economic model than what is the Premier League and the main difference is Premier League call it 75 percent of your revenue comes from distributions and 25 is club controlled um exeter is probably a flip um and so we looked at the team we think and the league we think there's some strong dynamics in the league we think rugby's an interesting there's there's real commercial opportunities both in international rugby and at the club level um and we looked it as an opportunity whereby um we could come in and really increase the club controlled revenues through some of the same things that we did at Bournemouth. We don't, they don't need a new stadium. They actually have a nice 15,000 person stadium, but by putting in new people from a commercial perspective, we've hired three people already. By putting in, improving the ambitions on the sporting side, improving what the players do and what they get and what THEY receive. It is a salary capital league, so it's different which from an economic perspective is good. But there's a very consistent playbook that we can do at Exeter. And I think just to put it in perspective, I think at Bournemouth when we started, there was about $14 million, $15 million of club-controlled revenues. Today that's somewhere between $35 million and $40 million. We don't need the same performance there at Exter, and there's different dynamics because that's in the Premier League and the success we've talked about. But there is real upside, we think, by putting in better commercial practices and giving the fans and the community a better experience. When you look at incremental investments, is there a geographic preference, sports that you're looking into, or is it more opportunistic based on the opportunities that present over time? Yeah, well, our sports investments today are primarily in Europe. I think that more was opportunistic than by we were focused on that. We thought the value in both cases was attractive, kind of the risk-reward. I think going forward as we look at new investments, we're definitely spending more time in the U.S. on investments. And so I don't – there's not a specific area that we're focused. I think we'll be opportunistic, but just given the environment, I'd see us spending more times in the US. Let's turn now to the non-core assets and to capital allocation. How are you thinking about the remaining non-core assets and the order and timing of monetizing them to the extent that you can share with us? Yep. So we have been very focused on monetizing non- core assets to generate capital to either invest in sports assets or return capital to shareholders. and i think we've done a good job i think we've sold a little less than 800 million over the last um kind of since the beginning of last year um so um we are continuing that process um frankly we've started on ones where we had more control in the outcome and so we could push whereas if you if we look now um there's some that we could easily monetize whereas there are others where we have different ownerships and different abilities to to control the outcome. But we in the board are incredibly focused on looking at our assets and monetizing the non-core assets in a disciplined way. And as appropriate, we will continue to update the market as that occurs. You've been talking about the process that the company started related to its restaurant group. And on the last earnings call, you mentioned some of the changes that were made. Can you walk us through, give us a high level overview of that and what remains, given that there's another transaction that's still in process? So the board remains very committed to trying to divest the restaurant assets. We started a process in february of last year um it is it has taken longer um than than we had hoped um i think the the one action item that has already occurred is as a result of the process we were able to close down oh charlie's um and um that i think i think what brett said on the call was it was roughly 16 million of run rate costs that were that were going into that business um So it was good for us to get out of that. Um, I think the, the second piece of that is 99 and the sale of 99. Um. The business, um, has, has struggled, um. Just from a, um., from a financial perspective from when we started the process. Um., and so that has made, has made selling it more difficult. Um,. But we are, we are still focused on the process, um,. It is a good business we think that there's a there's a good outcome for it and we'll update as appropriate how that that's on the private side turning out to the some of the publicly traded positions that used to hold how are you thinking about monetizing those versus holding them and any time frame or any other considerations that you are taking into account as you think about those of Of course. We have a couple public positions today. We like both the businesses. We think that they have good long-term prospects. That being said, they're obviously the easiest source of liquidity for us. And as we look to monetizing assets and how we generate liquidity for the portfolio transformation that we talked about, as well as for share buybacks, those are the most obvious ways that we can generate capital. And so as we need capital, we will clearly look to those as a way to generate capital and the timing on that we'll figure out as the capital is required. Along with the transition or the transformation of the portfolio that the company has been focused on over the last, you know, several quarters or, you know, two years, how do you think about the cost structure of the holding company, which is has been another point of focus for for the management team? And, and, and can you just give us an overview of what's been done and and what's still left to do there? Yeah, well, we've, in short, we're going to talk about we've done a lot. I mean, I think it really started with the internalization of the manager a couple years ago, that dramatically reduced the cost structure, as well as better aligned management with the primary compensation was in stock. And so I think the board took that step a couple of years ago now. I think that was the first step. I think secondly, the holding company itself and reducing costs became a real an ongoing focus um and and brett gave some numbers on the last call um but we've we've we've reduced it i think it's down i think 60 to 70 percent year over year now there's some one-time costs associated with some transitions in the previous year number um but we've remained focused we announced this quarter that we've taken we've gotten rid of a lease that that was about a little less than $3 million, so that'll take it down further. And we'll continue to try and find, there's kind of one-off items that we can get rid of. But look, we are very focused on what are the costs of the business as we think about the portfolio and the size of the portfolio going forward. I don't think that the costs will be as extreme as they were historically, but we'll try to continue to try to take costs out of the businesses. You've made some recent changes to the board and the governance structure of the company. Can you give us an overview of what, you know, what those changes have been and how the company and the board, the management and the Board are thinking about the structure and the governance of the Company going forward? Yeah, this has definitely been a focus of the Board. The Board has been very focused on kind of getting to kind of best-in-class governance practices. I think a couple big ones to call out is we are starting kind of the declassification of the board such that everyone will be on annual terms, and that started this year. We've also – we've done work on some of the committees. We've added new members. We've had four new members to our board. We've put people – some of those members on the key committees. We've updated the related party transaction committee charter. So we've been trying to do things that both get new voices into the board as well as getting to best-in-class practice from a governance perspective. And the board remains very focused on that. Talking about valuation now a little bit, one of the key points to that kind of story is the discount between its NAV and where its share price trades. uh how do you think about that gap today and uh and how that you know what's the the disconnect with you know between how the share price uh trades and the underlying value of the portfolio and what are those things that you think would help close that gap yeah well we're obviously we are we are frustrated with the discount i think one way that we express that frustration is through buying back stock at a discount to NAV, which is, which, which as you know, we've been very consistent in. I think in terms of, I think of terms of closing the discount I think that one is that we need to continue to do what we say and execute on our strategy and prove out the value, the underlying value of our portfolio company assets. And I think we've done that. One of the ways that we've Been trying to do that is through incremental disclosure of the assets. If you look at our shareholder letters and what we disclose today versus what we disclosed before. We've been trying to continue to update the sum of the parts and just to really talk about the assets to give people a better sense of the underlying value in them. And so that's what we've been doing. I think that we're optimistic that as we continue to execute our plan and continue to do what we say continue to return capital to shareholders that that discount will close um we we don't think it like we think that there's always some holding company discount but we think it could be inside of where it is today yeah and we've talked uh about how the portfolio has uh transformed but with some of the more recent transactions that you've uh closed the the liability side of the balance sheet has also uh changed and i don't in my view i don' think that's something that people appreciate is there you know is that a question that you hear from investors or is that something that's mostly uh ignored uh as you i think the bursada transaction you uh eliminated at liability yeah and now you have a much cleaner balance sheet and i don't think that in my view people are paying too much attention to that yeah no so the with the borsada transaction we eliminated a liability that was the put right um we that um that we think was was was great for the company I think generally we have tried to keep a very clean balance sheet in terms of we've we do most of our deals to with equity and we try to manage a very very clean balance she and but the bachata transaction in particular we were excited about that because it eliminated the put right right what are you know related to that what are some misconceptions that investors tend to have uh about canine today yeah i i just think um i don't know if they're misconceptions but i think that people what we we are trying to do a better job of is is helping people to understand what is the underlying value of the individual assets in our portfolio um and and um and to me if we can do that and we can continue to follow be consistent with what we say and how we execute on our strategy of transitioning our portfolio, of returning capital to shareholders. I think that there will be a lot less questions going forward. So that's really, I mean, where I try and spend the most time is talking to people about our portfolio. What we're doing in our portfolio and what we're thinking from a strategic perspective going forward? Yeah, I think you've hit some milestones over the last 18 to 24 months. But what are some of the milestones that people should be watching uh and you know pay attention to over the next 12 to 24 months as you continue executing on that strategy yeah i mean i think i think look i think we've done it we've done a good job um over over the last i mean we've made a lot of change over the last 12 to 18 months um i think going forward you're going to see a similar theme to what you've seen, which is divesting non-core assets and either reinvesting that in new investments or in our share buyback program. I'd also like to see going forward other ways that we can demonstrate the value that we are creating in our portfolio. I've spent a lot of time talking about Bournemouth and Black Knight football, but other kind of ways that мы can show people the value that's being created there, as well as within other assets of our portfolio, because I think the key going forward will be how do we grow NAV? And so things that we can do to demonstrate that will be very important. And I have a last one just to close us out. What are you most focused on over the next year as the CEO? Look, I think it's a lot of the things that we've talked about, and the ultimate result of that being how do we increase the share price for our shareholders, right? And how do мы do things that over the longer term are increasing the value of Kenai, the value of our shares and and uh and creating creating value for the people that have invested in us um so great uh brian thank you for joining us and thanks to everyone for being part of the discussion and enjoy the rest of the conference thank you thank you i appreciate it

Company
CANNAE HOLDINGS INC
Keywords
CANNAE HOLDINGS INC