newsfilter
← Latest News
Earnings Call Transcripts·

TD Cowen 2026 Financials & Fintech Conference - PAGAYA TECHNOLOGIES LTD

All right. Here we go. Good afternoon, everyone. Thanks for joining us. We're very pleased to have the management of Pagaya with us this afternoon. Gal Kubriner is the co-founder and CEO of Pagaia. The company is about 10 years old, which has been public since 2022, 2022, I think. So anyway, what we'd like to do is first start and talk just a little bit about the company's business model and its evolution. You talked to us about the original thoughts as to what you thought of when you founded Pagaya and how that's evolved over the last several years. So hi, everyone. Thank you for having me here today. Most appreciate all the hard work and the coverage behind the scenes, a lot goes into it. So maybe let me start with what Pagaya does and then I will go to how we started and where we are going in a little bit. We'll try to keep it brief. The long story short of it is that in the US, banks are very well organized and capable of serving customers on the mortgage front, checking savings, and the very well-known products. But in certain areas, such as personal loan, auto loans, for a major population bigger than you expect, there is actually a lack of ability of the banks to serve these customers, especially on the credit side. One would think when I say that, that it means the underserved, the one who doesn't earn a lot of money, wrong. There is really good population earning $120,000 on the personal loan, earning $85,000 on the auto loan, that if they will go to JPMorgan Bank of America tomorrow and will ask a loan, personal loan they will get a no. And the reason for the no is a combination of two things that happened in our prehistory already of the financial services, but is as true to today as you can imagine. Number one is 08 that made totally the regulators to push for the banks to be a safe haven, to be deposit-based customer organizations, rather than the original purpose of banks, which was to lend money. The second piece is that these things tend to take a lot of investment to build them. All of us remember the episode of Marcus and Goldman. So even if you want to go into consumer credit, you want to invest, you want to provide, you wanna do, technology is moving so quickly, the amount of investment you need to do in the infrastructure is so massive, that as a bank, it's really not an easy thing to do, and you need invest over years to get to actually a working program and ability. So we took that gap, and we said that if we will be able to provide that capabilities, the technology, the capital market expertise, a lot of productization specifically to that, we can make the banks simply better. So you will be in JP Morgan, you will put your money there, but when you ask for a loan, you're actually gonna get a loan. The last bank that we announced, and sorry that I cannot say TD, I will say TD one day, but the last bank we announced just a few weeks ago is Citizen, because Citizen is looking to solve for their customers the ability to take personal loan from their mobile app, from their branch. And that is the offering that Pagaya brings and we are working with U.S. Bank and we do for them the personal loan. We are working citizens, as they say, ally on the auto loans and we'll talk later about the difference in offering between personal loan and auto loan. The only way I will close it is that the beauty about that product is none of the customers know that it is actually a Pagay loan. So they have experienced that as U.S. bank loan, as a citizen loan, so they are happy. They're happy with the brand, they're happy with the bank, what they do, they stay. And banks that are now getting hit hard by the fintech lenders, SoFi, Lending Club, many others that are great in what they do and pulling through, providing credit, doing different things, they are pulling away deposits for these banks, the traditional banks in the U. S. needs to find solutions for that. And Pagaya is that technology provider and partner to be able to help you provide that credit to your customers that they need the most. So, Gal, the largest product line that you've got is personal loan, followed by auto. Talk to us a little bit about how each of those is developing. And also, what are the product lines behind those, you know, the other things that you are either developing or working on? So the way we started the company was actually in personal loan, as you mentioned. We actually started working with the so-called fintechs. Back in the days, we were a decline partner. So you had Best Egg and Prosper and many others that did the first line of being able to provide personal loan through the Internet. it was a big technology back then, and they were very experts in marketing, they were very good experts in different parts of servicing, but when we came, we enabled them to say yes to more customers and to be able to underwrite a little bit more the near prime, the subprime, areas that you need much more heavy underwriting AI capabilities, and that's where we started from. So the first so-called business line, and the biggest now until today, is personal where, think about it as three main ways, people that are coming to you and the ability to actually provide them credit, near prime customers, but they are very good earners. Our personal loan book, $120,000. Usually they have 17 years of credit history and working history. So really good borrowers that just couldn't find the right fit for them and when they are entering to the banks, when they're entering to the fintechs, we are providing that, so that's product number one in the personal loan. The second place is kind of like meet your customers where they go, so a lot of the customers these days are looking for personal loans online. They go to Create Karma, they go to Experian, they go so many places, and the ability to offer them an offer online and to say, hey, you can take that from me is something that we are operating on behalf of the banks, on behalf the different constituencies in these marketing affiliate channels as they call them. Today we are live with US Bank in Credit Karma and now the customers of US Bank and other customers, we start to see on the personal loan side, actually US Bank offering loans and a lot of that or most of it is with the hard work of the US Bank folks and the technology and the models that Pagaya provide behind the scene. And then the third piece which is the pre-screen is actually many customers that you have in your bank and they never ask for a loan, but you never offer the loan. So there is a question if you can be proactive and show to the customers you like the most that you are loyal to them. And you want to offer them a pre-approved loan or ability for them to know that you're there for them as a bank. So the third product is what we call the pre-screen, which is the ability to be proactive about going after the good customers of the bank and offering them credit to make the relationship with the bank much more sticky. On the auto side, which is a business line that was born, I would say, started 22, but really took scale in 23. Sorry, when Eli got connected to us, Eli did a big bet on us from the very early days. Doug Timmerman, which was the president of Otto, which we have very good relationship with, understood that while they have a very strong GMAC historic capabilities, 20,000 dealerships, a lot of ability to provide different parts, they are lacking sometimes of the best offer to put to the customers, because there are other banks out there that tend to be a little bit more technology-oriented. And he looked for a solution to be as competitive as possible across the spectrum, as we call it. And then they went to the dealerships and they are like, hey, you remember Eli, we're very good in this and this and these segment, Actually now, Ally partnered up with a partner and we are actually very good in all the segments. So please send us more application. And if you will go and you will look on Ally financials, they are actually doing a very good job in growing the franchise in a very consistent way. And there is almost $100 million line item that is the servicing that Pagaya is paying on the book and the customers that we are originating with them. So very meaningful, non-capital intense business that is helping Ally to become better bank, higher ROE, compete better in the marketplace with the best technology in class, which is what we do. So a lot of the adaptation of how you should think about the offer, what is the loan amount, when you use digital verification for an income of people, how you make it seamless, a lot of things we brought together to Ally and to their dealerships, and it has been tremendous success. And then when you get past personal loan and auto, can you talk about some of the other verticals? I mean, you have a point-of-sale business, and you've talked at times about going into credit cards. Maybe talk about those a little bit. You put me on the spot here. So POS is definitely one of our third vertical, shorter loans, much more embedded into all-day purchases. Think about one of the partners is FlexPay. Sorry, and Sezel. So it's like if you want to take a trip to somewhere or if you wanna buy something. So shorter loans, smaller loans, we operate that piece on their behalf. We usually tend to do the longer loans that they don't do. So they do more the paying for, we do the long term piece. So a very good collaboration and partnership. And the credit card from our perspective, again, in the same vein of white label connectivity, there are major parts in the U.S. population that for them to get legit good credit card under the TD brand, under the Citizen, is not that easy. So they are going to other names that I will not mention, which are great, but much more expensive, much less institutional, and they are losing becoming a customer of this brand. So nothing that we have done yet, but the concept and the thing I'm trying to flag is that the same thing that works for us in personal loan and in auto loan, of course, with the relevant specification, will be a future growth potential for Pagaya as offering that for different populations that otherwise couldn't get a credit card from Bank of America today. And you had alluded to this a little bit, but maybe flesh it out. You started the process working with a number of fintech-type lenders and have moved more recently into the banks. What additional steps did you have to do in order to get the banks to agree to that? And is that going to allow additional banks to kind of sign on with Pagani? So I think it's actually all starting from the team. So my co-founder and president, he was the ex-CEO of Citi Mortgage for many years. He was the president of First Data. he brought with him Raj, which is our chief risk officer and was the chief risk officer of Eli. So it starts, to your question, from having the right fundamental people capabilities to first speak to the banks in their language, which is basically no schticks, no tricks, everything until the end, buttoned up. The second piece is to have the ability to have the regulatory discussion and the scrutiny to the highest level that possibly can. Fair lending, UDAP rules, SEC disclosures, everything needs to be in the highest level that exists because historically banks have been over-grilled versus many other institutional investors in the world. Rightfully so, they are having the highest standards of kind of like scrutiny. and that means that we need to have the same level of scrutiny because the models that we produce are being adopted by the banks and there are a lot of interconnectivity between the companies so I think from 22 we work like majorly massively I'm doing this a lot in Sanjeev in the team and many other people that I'm forgetting right now but Miriam our chief compliance officer the coming from being white melon and and the bottom line is it needs to be 100% kosher. It needs to be 100% uptime. It never can be not explainable. There is a big question around AI, how much is effective versus how much is explainable? So to find the right middle ground to be able to explain to what you do and the variables and the outcomes, but in the same time to have an advanced technology and to do that, that's the fine line that Pagaya goes. And if you look on the way we speak about our earning calls, et cetera, we never put the one thing as this is the thing, AI gonna change the world. No, it's a lot about understanding who are your audience, what you use for which purpose, and being moderated and understand that these things takes years to actually penetrate into the banks, and that mindset and understanding is, from my perspective, the winning of the battle. You mentioned AI. You were certainly an early user of machine learning to develop the underlying credit models, one of the concerns we've heard from investors at times is, well, wouldn't AI allow everybody else to just compete with you and do the same thing? Can you talk about that a little bit? Yeah, so I think from a competitive mode, the two big line items just to take home, if it remembers nothing else, the data is proprietary and specific to what we do with where we are. You don't have it in OpenAI. you don't have it anywhere number two to the earlier point getting connection to major banks in the u.s. is a huge mode with all the buzz and all the investment and everything to be able to go into the core heart of the banking systems loan origination system model approval etc it's not it's something that took us a year and we were very focused on that so it's now that rational to think that someone will come just with a better technology and we'll wave it in two years and we will be there. I think the bigger question for that is remain to two parts. One is can we utilize AI, which is actually now excellent in code review and in code development, the rest it's okay, to help us integrate faster to the banks, explore how to integrate to the bank faster. That's an area that we are exploring. And the other piece is that while machine learning was the kind of like holy grail from unlocking underwriting to the next level and actually opened a lot of financial opportunities to people, especially in the US. How does the agents, which is more like LLM, so different type of models, could help in the engagement with the customers to continue to unlock more things? Let me give you the best example. A machine learning could say yay or nay based on most of the characteristics you got to it. But, and now to get a human agent, ask questions of a person, et cetera, very heavy. But let's assume that the machine learning could go back and say, actually you didn't get approved. But, we have only three concerns. We don't see your income here, can you show us there? We don see this, can tell us there. And by three simple questions, in a good engagement with the customers, Actually getting an easy answers that you can feed to the machine learning and here you are in a different world of the five minutes that I needed to be able to control over a so-called agent to ask three questions that unlocking so much financial potential is again opening the imagination of what could be done. And if done properly and again, compliant and slow and with regulation and with guardrails and a lot of with, I think there is a unique opportunity for the next 10 years of consumer credit in general to be something that all of us could just imagine, but it will take time. And it's okay that it takes time, because in banking and in regulated environments, it's better to do it properly rather than to do It wrong and then getting to a free zone of 10 years that no one could do anything. It kind of plays nicely into the next thing I want to talk about. One of the themes that you and your team spoke about on the third quarter call was that you're able to onboard partners more quickly. You've also said that there is a period that you do kind of have to have in order to test to ensure that. Can you talk a little bit about both of those phenomena and how that is going to play out in terms of Pagaya's growth? So just this quarter, as we announced, we onboarded Citizens, FNBO, two major important banks, one for personal loan, one for point of sale. And today, this morning, we announced on Splash, which is another actually major player in the fintech space that's working a lot with credit unions. And I shared with you about the U.S. Bank going into Credit Karma. So you can see that the activity and the velocity is increasing and a lot of it comes down to the productization that we've been through it's like a full narrative and aligning the company in the next i would say 18 to 24 months of being religious about these are the things that are working let's replicate them and do them properly let's avoid from by spoke ideas etc and things have proven to be systematic and therefore you can work out the APIs to be much more replicable and actually you don't need to build a bigger team so if you look on the OPEX of Pagaya almost stayed the same in the last year if not even a little bit declined it's not to say that every year it will decline but definitely to say the way you should think about Pagayas a very strong operational leverage and a lot of it is making things quicker better learning from mistakes and moving into the the productization of that word. And in that lane, iGentic or the ability through AI to test things quickly, see them in real life, react to them, is very meaningful. And as a technology leading company that is on the front of that technology capabilities, that gives us a lot of advantage versus others. Now on the other side, credit is credit. Doesn't matter which agent you have, the losses either come or they don't come. It's that simple. So to have the maturity of testing your model, waiting three months in, waiting six months, course correcting, as much as you have more data, it is easier, it is more straightforward, but in order to do it properly without any hiccups, you need to take it slow. So as we think about ramping up, our partners know, we know that there is six months that we are fine tuning the understanding of our models versus the new flow. We see in everything there is specification, in everything, there is a tailor made. So a lot of the uniqueness, knowledge and capabilities is going into this calibration, if you will, as we ramp up. You mentioned credit, certainly can't have a discussion about this without discussing credit to some extent. In the third quarter, the credit losses underlying the portfolios, you know, that you've underwritten have been stable. And, you Know, if you look at them relative to the last couple of years, they're, they've notably improved. You probably have a window that's bigger, better than, you know, pretty much any individual lender. What are your current thoughts about, you the health of the consumer, and how does that play in? Is it kind of an approval rate? So what are the metrics that we should be looking at from Pagaya to get a sense overall about consumer health? The title for me is the consumer is stable. You don't see cracks. You don'T see people that are becoming very delinquent. And it's not to say that the consumers are not under stress. Like inflation to the four or five, it's not a great place to be. And we feel that things are not becoming cheaper as the day goes by. And I think there is even a bigger theme that the world is kind of like fighting on the resources. Will it go to computing of AI ideas? Or it will go to the drinking waters of different pieces? And in most of the eras that there is a kind of like gold rush to a thing, there is this creation of inflation that, by the way, over time, of course, correcting itself because the technology is becoming better. And then other people that the job could be done by technology is moving to other places. So all in all, I think it's a healthy cycle. And I will say that all of us remember the 21, 22, like for many of like one generation before me, it was 08. For us, it's the 21. 21, 2022. I don't think we are even like remotely close to that. There was a very specific, unique situation there about money becoming so cheap, no one using anything. And then in one day, everyone is using everything and inflation were 10%. Like very far away and supply chains and stuff. I think it's a much different environment. Having said that, I think that from a Fed perspective and the mandate of what they need to do in order to make sure it's not going out of hand, we are going to see and we are seeing going to higher rates environment and the ability to trim that down so it will not be an obstacle down the road. And that is expected to have effect on the consumers in general, starting usually from one-time purchases or other things. Loans are not really the first thing to get hit. It's much more about the less dollar of the ledger that you use and the other pieces. And from leverage perspective the consumer is not over levered and rather in in a good place. I think there is a lot of mismatch between what you read in the newspaper and how things are tend to believe and a lot of politics that goes into it, rather than the actual data and outcome, and the data and actual outcome is not the best it has been, but it's very stable and steady. Right. Some of that concern probably helps play into some of your partners wanting to work more with a provider like the guy. Number one, and number two, I will say maybe one more important thing. The unemployment that is so low, it's a blessing that all of us kind of like we forget how bad it is that it's not like that. We're almost like a little bit in the luxury world of discussing if it's inflation is bad or not, which it is bad. But the real big problem, and if you look on Europe for many years and Spain and Italy and these countries that you have unemployment youth of like 16 and 20 and 25%, that's taking the hope away, and that brings depression and things that are actually a catalysator for bad things to happen. So I think from an economy perspective and the environment of where we are, the most important thing, a little bit more inflation, a bit less inflation, is unemployment. And as long as this country continues to have employment in a good place and continues to generate kind of like employment in good numbers that knows to pay well, I think the US is in a good place. Any questions from the room? Okay, seeing none, I'll continue. One of the things that Pagaya does for its partners is actually also funds these loans. And, you know, the technology of that financing has improved significantly for you over the last several years. I think, you Know, we had some, you Know, I would say spikes in rates towards, you Know, towards the end of the third quarter. Volatility kind of got wider. And yet you did a personal loan deal the very end of September. You did an auto deal last month at tighter spreads. So talk to us a little bit about where that funding environment is and how Pagaya is kind of managing in the current environment. So I think from an investor perspective, and I'm sure you're familiar with that in other areas, everyone wants bigger, stabler, known, and simple. So as Pagaya is becoming the golden standout, as we have, to your point, a deal out every month, the performance is stable. We did already 100 different deals. So the discussion and the scrutiny and understanding is moving much more to that's the guys or the folks we do business with, even if there is one month like this or one month Like that, because we all live in a scale world. And to have a provider that you trust and you know that you support and the other way around is really taking the old days of ABS as we knew them of like high demand everyone is in, low demand everyone out, almost away from the equation. Most of the partners that we work with, let me tell you that, they have to deploy. Have to. They have two ways. Either they get money from pension funds or they get Money from insurance capital. every month in the general account there is a new thing they need to deploy when that mindset is in place then having good long relationships with big providers like ourself that in the good very best days will not squeeze them but in the bad days we'll be able to call and to say hey we need some help is changing completely the fundamental way we think and they think about funding We all live it from the equity that is very much sentiment on, sentiment off, because there are many people who decide if they put money in equities or not. In fixed income, it's working like that. They need to have billions of dollars to be invested every month, even if they want and even if они не хотят. That is actually creating a tremendous amount of stability in the ABS capital market, but for players who are repeatable, who are scaled, and who knows to manage that relationship properly over time and not trying to burn it out. And I think your two points, but more than that, after Liberation Day, Iran War, you name it, Pagaya was there, did the deal, got the money, fund the loans. We need that consistency to serve the banks that we need to stand behind the commitments that we provide. And that has been tested in the last two to three years, including COVID. And it worked well, while we have a different approach of raising the capital first, having it in hand, and then deploying it. The one thing that it is changing is price. There are a lot of players in the market. The price for us is cheap. But when there is little players inthe market, the price forus is high. And we understand it, too. And the way we have to deal with it, and that goes to management and Sanjeev and financials and the finance people, etc., is to manage it over the cycle properly and to know when to push the rates down to the consumer because cost of capital is higher and you need to maintain your margin, which is things that we did as we saw the rates went up, etc. And vice versa, when you have more room to get it down, to be able to approve more, you do the other way around. So I think the dynamic part of the U.S. wholesale market is very important. It's stable more than people think. Pricing is changing. And what we see is maybe the last point is another phenomenon that people are looking for a little bit specific deployment channels. So they will come to us and say, hey, that's what I have for the year. How do you help me deploy? And we are giving them schedule and we are doing bilateral deals. So we are moving from just a one-and-done type of a thing to different shape and forms of committed capital, bilateral ABSs, and things like that. So just to put a slightly finer point on that, your margin was down about 90 basis points from the high fours down to the low fours. And you've pretty much said you think you can keep it in there in that 4% to 5% range. but you and alluded to this in the last answer you took some pricing changes on the loans just talk about how long that's going to take to flow through and and what you know what we should see in terms of your margins from here yeah so as we spoke about it and we said and as i mentioned that stability is everything so the way to think about it is you are moving you know 50 100 basis points we actually did 100 basis points you see how the market reacts usually other lenders move So we gave guidance to the market that somewhere in the middle of next year we're going to be in the middle of the range but more importantly we have a strong understanding and believe that the margin range and even the upper side could be achieved if we continue to propel the good performance, the cheaper cost of capital and a lot of things that we are building as we are scaling. I think it's actually a very good testimony that like this type of business model knows to work in a higher interest rate environment, lower interest rate environment, even if margin is 50 basis points more or 50 basis points less. I will remind all of us in 21, I swear to all of you, the question I get the most, how will Pagaya perform at a 5% interest rate? I think every week in 21. And here we are, and Pagay is performing well in 5%, and it will perform well at 3% and at 7%. There is a lot of adjustment and knowledge and capability that goes into that, but at the end of the day, we are here to be the lending partner for many of the banks and things that we are building for years to come, 10, 20, we never have a partner that left us, and we are very proud of what we're doing in helping US consumers with the amazing work of the team. Got it. Maybe just to kind of end off, what would you say is the thing, If you could get investors to understand one additional thing about Pagaya that you feel people are getting wrong, what would that be? I think the fact that this is an infrastructure play that every consumer credit bank or lender in the U.S. will need to have it to be competitive and that this ist part of a phenomena that is happening that is bigger than us, that is the same as the private credit that is happenning in the corporate world. and that 30, 40% of consumer credit is going to be funded outside of balance sheets and that Pagaya is, as for now, the category definer for that and to appreciate what it takes to have relationships and business with companies like TD, Citizen, U.S. Bank, and others in the magnitude of the enterprise level it is, which is dozens of millions of dollars a year, 10 plus year of relationship, I think that talks a lot to the value of the enterprise value of the company that unfortunately now I think it's still being missed. But we are on a journey and we will fix that perception with the help of Moshe and others. And we really appreciate you listening to us today. And if you have anything else, feel free to reach out. All right. All right. Thank you, Gal. Thank You, everyone.

Company
PAGAYA TECHNOLOGIES LTD
Keywords
PAGAYA TECHNOLOGIES LTD