newsfilter
← Latest News
Earnings Call Transcripts·

TD COWEN 2026 FINANCIALS & FINTECH CONFERENCE - SLM Corporation

I'm very pleased to have the management of Sallie Mae here with us at our conference and represented by John Witter, the CEO. John joined Sallies in 2000, like a couple of minutes before COVID started, if memory serves. That's exactly right. And prior to that had been at Hilton Capital One and several other places in consumer and financial services type roles. You know, Sally May has been, you know, an interesting and somewhat controversial stock of late. You know maybe the place that we should start is give us an overview of the private student lending market, key participants, and, you know, obviously some been some big changes this year. So maybe talk about that a little bit. Yeah, sure. Happy to, Moshe. So to put it in context, and all the facts I'm going to reference here are in our recent 10K, but as a country, we spend about, call it a little bit less than $540 billion a year educating people in higher education. And if you look at that, a little but north of $100 billion of that is the lending industry, And the rest of that spend is really made up through family contributions and scholarships and grants and the like. But within the lending space, probably 88%, maybe close to 90% historically, has been made up by the federal programs. And the federal program programs have a number of different component parts. There are what are referred to as direct loans, and these can be subsidized or unsubsidized. historically capped. It's also made up of what's called the Parent Plus program, which allows parents in their name to borrow for their child's education. And then the Graduate Plus program which allows graduate students to borrow up to the full cost of attendance for theirs. The net impact of that, of the sort of generosity of those programs historically, has been you know, private lenders have played an important, but I think more niche role. So in that context, of that $100 billion of sort of total lending each year, you know private student lenders only provide about $14 billion of that 100 billion. What happened, you know in July of 2025 through HR1 or the one big beautiful bill, is those federal programs were effectively reformed and really the predominant feature of them is that they were capped. So the grad loan or the grad plus program was eliminated, the parent plus program Was capped, the caps for the direct programs were were changed to better support students. But the net impact of that is that for the first time, opened up more of the undergrad opportunity for private lenders, and it also opened up really for the first time the mainstay sort of graduate program. There were some specialty products that we and others competed in, but really kind of the main portion of the graduate lending opportunity opened up. You know, that will be effectively phased in over a multi-year period of time. So the way it works is if you had loans under the old regime, you were grandfathered in for the remainder of your course of study. But if you were a new borrower to a course of studying, then you were subject to sort of the new caps and the new regulations. I think that what that means for us is we saw an opportunity over the course of that phase-in period to increase our annual originations is by somewhere in the order of magnitude of kind of up to 70%. And obviously view that as an attractive opportunity going forward. The list of competitors that we play against is a little bit of a kind of a niche group. We see the likes of Citizens and PNC. We also see some private players like College Ave. certainly with the advent of the federal reforms you know there's more interest from other players so for example SoFi who has always been a great competitor in the in the consolidation space I think is looking more at what we've referred to as the in-school channel sort of as a part of their their overall focus coming forward right and obviously that started as of July 1st which you know, coincides with third quarter, which is a quarter that you reported, you know, a few weeks back, you had the, you mentioned, you know, previously kind of niche levels of grad loan originations, but they more than doubled. Can you talk through how both your grad and undergrad, which I guess would include the parent business, kind of performed relative to your expectations? And are there, you You know, are there kind of learning challenges for the universities? Talk through that and how that, you know, how you think you're tracking against that 70%. Yeah, happy to. You know I think in aggregate we feel really good about where we are. We affirmed our guidance for originations growth for the year at 12 to 14% originations growth. And I think if we look operationally at what we delivered this year, the introduction of, you know, a number of new products, new marketing programs, new underwriting programs, feel really good that we delivered everything that we had originally thought, you know, much that we would set out to deliver. I think it's important sort of stepping back, though. if you think about where we were in the late fall, early winter of 2025, as we were setting guidance for this year, you know, this was really a difficult market opportunity for us to estimate. We had to come up with our beliefs about what the federal rules would say. We had to do a bunch of work to figure out what the credit worthiness of all these previously federal borrowers was going to look like because the federal loans were not underwritten. You know, we had to decide what was going to be the kind of cost of capital and hurdle expectations, and therefore, you know, sort of pricing discipline of various competitors. You know we had think about how families would respond. You know there's this interesting but important distinction where, you know, these caps are both lifetime caps, but they're also annual caps. Depending on which you choose to focus on, you get to very different answers, not at sort of the end state opportunity, but how that opportunity plays out over time. And sort of, the list goes on. And so, it's not an exaggeration to say that, you know, across each of our different product areas, our confidence bands were pretty broad around what we expected. And, so, where we are right now is really, I think, unpacking this peak season and making sense of all of it. And we are still waiting for the market share data which will tell us actually outside in how big was the market this year in total we actually still don't know that and we'll also you know get information and be able to really assess it how successful were we in each sort of piece in part I fully expect that we will be happy with our overall aggregate performance again we spent a lot of time coming up with those numbers and I'm also sure there will be incredible learnings for us about how to do even better going forward. You can't build five or six new product areas. You can launch this kind of expansion and not have places where you overperform and not have some places where we underperform. So we're just in the early stages of digging into all of that. I'm sure that will lead to great insights about how we can compete even more forcefully going forward, but I think given just where we are in the process, probably too early to speculate. Right. appear, I mean, you mentioned a few competitors, but it doesn't appear there's been a significant inflow, you know, of new competitors because of that grant opportunity. You know, I think the people we thought were going to show up, showed up. There's, of course, always when you have a market opportunity like this, new entrants and, you knows, folks who are looking to build businesses. And it's not hyperbole. We sort of welcome and invite all of You know, we think actually one of the best things is to have a really broad, well functioning student finance marketplace, you know, that makes all of us stronger. Got it. One of the other elements of the strategy for Sally May over the last several years has been in addition to using various, you know, on balance sheet funding you know deposits and ABS but also loan sales and over the last couple of years, you've done two forward flow agreements. Maybe kind of two separate questions, I guess. First off, talk to us a little bit about those strategic partnerships with those two forward-flow partners, and then we'll talk a little bit about the whole loan sale market separately. Yeah. First of all, maybe it's important to take a little bit of a step back, because I think kind of how we came to this strategy speaks volumes to what we hope to get from it and why we think it's important. When I joined the company back during the COVID days, Moshe, as you mentioned, we had predominantly at that point leveraged our bank as our primary funding mechanism. We had done a few loan sales over time, but I think we thought of ourselves predominantly as a bank-funded player. And it was during that very same time that we started the implementation of CECL. And that really forced us to sit back and say, how do we feel about our bank, really? And the answer was, we loved it, but it had some limitations. And I think primary was, it is just a capital-intensive way of funding loans when you combine regulatory capital with life-of-loan loss reserves. So we loved the persistent, consistent, you know, a sort of earning stream, we love the ability to control sort of the totality of the funding sort of strategy, but it had limitations. And that really led us right back around my joining the company to a more programmatic program around selling loans. And we did that for a couple of really important reasons, which was one, It provided a capital light and full risk transference way of originating or funding our originations, but we also, as you know well, saw the real disconnect between our loan sale premiums and the value of our equity. We saw a real opportunity there to think about fundamentally different strategies in capital return. That strategy really powered us over the course of the next couple of years, and proud to say that over that time we bought back rough justice, almost 60%, maybe it's now slightly more than 60% of the shares outstanding as of that 2020 starting point. While we love the loan sales and we love that strategy, it had a drawback too, and that drawback was volatility. And I think we saw the sort of extreme of that volatility earlier this month when we made the decision to postpone a loan sale, because pricing didn't come in where we wanted. But that volatility, honestly, existed even before that. If I think back over my time, again, with the company, we had sold loans at a premium as high as, again approximately 14%. And we had sold loans at a premium as low as sort of high threes rounding to four. And I think we heard loud and clear from many of our investors that while they love the capital return, that the volatility of earnings was a little bit of a white knuckle experience, and we agreed. And so probably three years ago or so, we started looking with great interest at what was happening in the private credit markets. And what we saw was a real increase in the depth of those markets and the sophistication of those players. And the sort of vision of a Goldilocks solution sort of came to mind, where could we create something that had the same kind of persistent, consistent, easy to understand cash flows of a balance sheet with the same risk transference and capital light nature of loan sales. And could we implement that as a third leg of the stool? Again, not to the exclusion of the others, but as a complement to that. And so we were really excited as we went out and started our strategy work and began to have conversations. We had, we found a really great like minded group of private credit, private equity players who sort of saw the world in the same way that we did. And so, we were thrilled, I learned just this morning, one year ago tomorrow, so happy birthday to have signed our first deal with KKR. And then we announced on our earnings call that we signed our second deal with Sixth Street. And I think we believe that this will likely continue to evolve and grow going forward, both with the opportunity to sign additional deals, but also to potentially expand some of the deals we have. Right, and you mentioned as part of the answer to that question that you did postpone the sale that originally, a whole loan sale you'd originally planned for Q4. You know, when you think about the environment, you know, what is it going to take in early 2027 to get that, you know, to get that done? And, you know, how confident are you that, you know that we'll get there? Great question. I think we have, you know, a firm belief that loan sales will be part of our you know, sort of funding and overall business strategy next year. You know, I think what we saw in the early part of October this year was, you know sort of peak uncertainty you know really high rates that have already, you know step back to a certain degree and a lot of volatility. And you know when we looked at the indicative pricing that we were hearing from potential industry players. And we compared that to what we thought we could earn on those same assets in our bank. By the way, I think this is a testament to the multi-legged strategy and sort of the ability not just to be a price taker in these types of negotiations. We felt it was a difficult decision, but we felt like the right one was to hold off on that. I think as we look forward, I've already touched on a little bit of it, we would certainly think that there's a good possibility that rates normalize a bit i think we certainly believe that volatility will come down and some of the you know knock-on uh headwinds that we face as a part of that volatility will come i think down we also appreciate that there's probably work we can do um you know we are uh kicking off today uh you know a multi-city road show with abs investors to really make sure they understand and have full insight into the ability to model what is a really pretty unique asset class in the grand scheme of things. We know that there's additional things that we can think about with our partners around, you know, different structuring options. And so we are open to kind of looking at all of that. But, you know. Our core thinking at this point is loan sales will be a meaningful part of our plan next year. And I think we believe that industry, that the environment will allow that to happen. Right. And you've had, generally speaking, the on-balance sheet ABS deals that you've done have been at reasonably attractive spreads, right? In other words, so it doesn't feel like there's as much of a kind of Sally Mae risk concern in that. It seems more driven by the overall volatility that you cited as opposed to, you know. Yeah, I think, Moshe, there's certainly been some good prints that have happened even since we made our decision. I think we look at it, and as we talk to industry participants, we certainly see that rates were the lion's share of the driver of the pricing versus previous loan sales that we had done. But look, we have a unique asset class. By the way, there has been over the course of the last several years a number of changes that we've made to how we underwrite, to how manage our loss mitigation programs that have added change into the system. By the there have been exogenous factors and concerns that folks have raised. We were very much a part of the February, early March AI set of considerations. And I think the potential impact of AI on students is still a little bit kind of out there in the ether. So I think that education that we're talking about doing is really how do we put what we think is a very compelling fact set around each of those issues in a way that allows our critical abs you know partners and buyers to make really informed and accurate choices and we're confident if they do that and they understand the story they'll come to great conclusions right and you know i think one of the other elements has been you know a the in the last couple of quarters you've had some issues with respect to um starting with what you know a recovery channel that you said that you you know paused having an impact on net charge-offs and then you know in the second quarter and then in the third quarter um you kind of increased the impact you know that that would have talk to us a little bit about you know what has happened and you know the that 40 or so million dollars um do you think that will be you know something that sally may may will be able to collect in future years in 2027 and beyond. Yeah, great question. And some of you have heard this story before, but let me go back a little bit to the beginning here. In the very end of 2025, we started tracking in our portfolio some behaviors that were divergent from what we would have expected. And said simply, we saw a small group of customers who we thought had a very high sort of credit worthiness and ability to pay who were proceeding directly through to charge off. And I won't go into all the details, but that was associated with a number of other sort of operational and behavior things that we observed. And we just sort of said this doesn't look right and this isn't in keeping with sort of our understanding. As we dug into it, you know, what we found was, you a situation that we've now termed sort of misaligned debt resolution practices. And in its sort of simplest form, what we felt was going on was that there were customers who were being encouraged to default on their loans. There were lenders who were positioning themselves as debt settlement players, who would then come settle the loan with us out of our recovery channels at a steep discount, write a face value loan back to the customer at a lower interest rate in the longer term and effectively pocket the difference. And the back door of this was really kind of our legacy, charged off loan sale and recovery processes. And we had always, for our history, had, you know, the situation was the people who charged off had a low ability to pay, right? You know, they may have wanted to, but they had a lower ability to play. And so the whole system was really set up for that, and that was increasingly changing through this practice. Ultimately, you now, we decided to address that in a couple of ways. First and foremost, we suspended our loss recovery efforts. So, again, this is for charged-off loans. We suspended the sale of those loans to third parties, and we also suspended the collection of those loans through third parties until we could get sort of the right controls and the right conditions around that. And that was really what led to sort ofthe original impact on net charge-offs for this year. That was about $25 million of net charge-off impact. And it's important to say that wasn't incremental charge-offs. That was really just delaying the recovery of those charge- offs because we had suspended these efforts. As we got a little bit deeper into the year, what we found is, you know, there was a group of customers who we thought we could bring back into the boat, so to speak. And we had put in place some front-end strategies and approaches to go do that. We were successful at heading off a lot of customers going down this path. We weren't as successful in bringing some of those customers who were late in delinquency back in. And so unlike the first impact, the $25 million, we actually said we probably are going to have a gross charge-off impact here to the tune of about $20 million. Still relatively small in the grand scheme of a roughly $400 million net charge-off budget for the year, but important, I think, to have transparency into that. So maybe overall, and you alluded to the fact before that you've made some, over the last couple of years, some tightening of underwriting criteria. that's taken a while to flow through the portfolio, but it largely has. Talk about where we are kind of in that process right now. Yeah, and I think we have disclosed this a couple of different times. But yes, we made changes, I guess, going back now probably four years. And that had the impact of reducing our originations modestly. but we think, you know, driving a real leverage reduction in the expected losses. If you think about the deferment period in a student loan, you know, if we made a loan to someone as a freshman, you know, under this new set of, of credit principles. Like, it could take upwards of four years for that to flow through. And by the way, if they went on to grad school and had a, you know, kind of a deferment for that, it, it can be even longer. So I think we are steadily seeing a reduction in the percentage of loans coming into P&I each year underwritten under the old regime. I think for next year, we'll be down into the low single digits for that number, maybe about 4% if memory serves me right. But we consider that to be a tailwind that will continue to benefit us for the next few years. And again, given the nature of student lending and how the student comes out of undergrad, you've used the tool to modify loans. It was a big piece of that over the last couple of years. It's now somewhat more stable. Talk to us a little bit, I mean, you've given some data about the performance of borrowers as they exit that modification program. Can you give us a, you know, a little about that? Yeah, so the history here is going back again five plus years. Our primary loss mitigation program was a tool called forbearance. And forbearances almost unheard of in most consumer lending categories. It is commonplace in the federal program and therefore was adopted in the private program as that marketplace got stood up. At that time, we looked around and what we realized was most of the specific regulatory guidance out there favored more explicit loan modification programs than a more generalized forbearance program. We made the decision as a company to make sure that we were always trying to stay one step ahead and that it made sense for us to migrate from forbearances to a more structured approach. We did that. modification program that we have in place today I think is very rigorous I think it is very thoughtful it starts with an assessment of what is a customer's bona fide ability and willingness to pay so you can't just get a loan modification because you have one or you because you want one you have to actually show that you will have the means to pay back that loan that process is tightly managed through our sort of workflow processes and tools. It is highly audited by all number of different folks who really want to make sure that these mods are only going to the right people. And we think it's a really invaluable tool, especially for folks who are new to repayment. And if you think about it, I don't know how many of you here in the room have kids who who are recent college grads. But those first couple of years out of school are difficult. Young people haven't really refined their financial habits yet. Many of them may not have realized as much of their income potential in year one as they will in year two and year three. And so what we've always seen, even in the forbearance days, is a disproportionate share of financial distress comes in those first of years. So we really love these programs as a way of helping our students bridge that gap and get to good financial footing. We've been delighted with the outcomes. So roughly 80% or more of those folks are still current as they come out of their loan modification period and begin to step back into full P&I and a reversion back to contractual terms. We haven't disclosed the numbers, but we actually look at what happens after the first three months. Those numbers continue to be attractive to us and above our expectations. And so we feel great about those results. And as you would expect, we do the internal math to say, did we give up and what did we get for it? And we continue to believe that these are very attractive from sort of an MPV perspective in terms of, you know, again, helping folks find their financial footing. One of the things that you mentioned, you know, on the third quarter call was that, you know, even without the loan sale in Q4, you still expect to, you know, roughly finish the, you know, the buyback authorization. So maybe just talk to us a little bit, you The stock has been weak lately for, how do you think about capital allocation today? And obviously, there's a little bit of variability because we've got that pending issue with respect to the loan sale. But talk to us about that, your thoughts on the capital allocation. Yeah, and look, maybe I'll sort of draw it into two pieces, one more programmatic and one maybe more a littlebit opportunistic. You know, on the programmatic side, I think we really try to be pretty straightforward here in how we think about it. You know we want to, you know, sort of appropriately, you know, grow the bank balance sheet. And I think we've said, you know, that's probably for the next few years and the low single digits may be growing to the mid single digits, you know, a number of years out. But you know a little bit of growth in the bank balance sheet. We want to obviously continue to pay our dividend and be great stewards of that set of expectations. And I think after that, we want to buy back stock. And I think we've shown over the course of the last five or six years, it's hard for me to imagine that there's been anyone out there that's been more committed to the capital return story than we've been. I would also say, and I'm certainly not predicting anything, but I think we're also willing to be opportunistic about that when conditions arise. Earlier this year, when the AI turmoil started, we accelerated loan sales, put in place an ASR and a subsequent set of 10B51 plans, and we'll buy back almost 10% of the shares outstanding beginning of the company as per the beginning of this year. And so, yes, you're right to name it. Sort of the health of the loan sale market is a huge enabler of that. But certainly if conditions warrant, we want to be sort of programmatic about it. But we also want to opportunistic should that opportunity ever arise. Any questions from the room before, okay, seeing none, I will continue. The election kind of caused a big change in the legislature. Thoughts as to impact to Sallie Mae from that shift? Yeah, we've worked hard over the last five or six years to become, I think, a really trusted name and voice on Capitol Hill for all issues related to higher education finance. And we have and enjoy quite productive relationships with both sides of the aisle. I think have many examples of our thoughts being sought out. I think obviously the biggest thing that's going to be different going forward is we're just going to have a larger class of new congressional members than we've had in quite some time. And I think that means for us, job number one is how do we educate that group on sort of why the changes that have been made to date were the right changes to be made, why they're having the desired impact because we think they are having the desired impact, but also what is the remaining work for us to go do, you know, as a country to make the higher education finance system work even better. You know, so if I dig into that a little bit, you know, I've said this before publicly, it is absolutely the case that the notion of thoughtful caps on the federal program was an idea that had, you broad bipartisan support even before the HR1, one big beautiful bill. Now, no Democrat will admit today that they support HR1. But I think lots of Democrats will say, yes, thoughtful caps make a lot of sense. Secondly, if you look at what's happening as a result of that, good things are happening. Schools are better managing expenses. They are questioning the provision of programs, majors, that may not have been adding the value that they thought or that we might think as a society should be added. Families are unquestionably having better and deeper conversations about where to go and what to study and how to pay for it and what the implications are. And I think all of that is a direct result of these thoughtful caps that were put in place. So we will obviously focus heavily on those messages with the new incoming members. But look, the work's not done. There's not yet much enough transparency around the true return that people get on their investment in higher education. Higher education is still too expensive. And I think there's opportunities for us to continue to make improvements that will benefit the whole system. And we'll focus on those efforts as well. Got it. In the last minute or so that we have left, maybe if you could just reflect a little on what you've learned and lessons you've taken from what's happened to the company and the industry over the last year, year and a half. Yeah, thank you for that. First of all, I would I would say, I am, and this may sound funny to say, given recent stock price performance. I am actually delighted with what we delivered in the third quarter, and I'm delighted with how we're positioned going forward. I think the plus opportunity is proving out to be a really attractive one for us. I think if you look at the steps that we've made around credit, They are all sort of forming into a way that should drive tailwinds in our credit performance going forward. I am really pleased with how we're managing the investment dollars and the expenses around the plus reform and kind of just our general operations. And I think the Sixth Street partnership, the KKR partnership, really do show the power of the funding strategy that we're putting in place. especially in light of the recent loan sale market disruption. With that said, we need to continue that work. We need to build out our alternative funding measures. We need continue to deliver on credit. And we need show that the plus opportunity is real and substantial and gonna drive the kind of meaningful improvements to originations that we've talked about. So I'm not sure there's anything that I've learned on the strategy side, but obviously continued execution and answering the questions that investors have rightfully asked us is going to be job number one. Perfect. With that, we are out of time, so please join me in thanking John and Sallie Mae, thank you.