Milken Institute1h 11m
Charting the Way Amid Asia's Game of Thrones
Parag Khanna, Curtis S. Chin, Nina Hachigian, Yasuhide Nakayama, Maria Ressa
Conference Presentation, Panel
Geopolitical Landscape and the "Game of Thrones" Analogy
- Core Metaphor: Curtis Chin characterizes Asia's geopolitical environment as a high-stakes, zero-sum struggle for control, likening it to Game of Thrones, with major powers vying for dominance over the "Iron Throne" (Middle Kingdom/China) and the South China Sea.
- China's Dual Role:
- China is identified as the single most significant force shaping the region, driven not only by state actors but by the agency of Chinese people (tourism, investment).
- Despite government control, the Chinese populace is transforming the region through economic engagement and consumer behavior.
- US Rebalance Strategy:
- The US maintains a dual focus on geopolitical security and economic integration, exemplified by the US-ASEAN Connect initiative launched in Laos.
- Key Metrics: US military presence is projected to shift 60% to the Pacific by 2020; the US opened a dedicated mission to ASEAN in 2011, becoming the first non-ASEAN nation to do so.
- Economic Initiatives: New financing for women-owned MSMEs, clean energy initiatives, and trade workshops for non-TPP ASEAN nations are central to the rebalance.
- Japan's Strategic Pivot:
- Japan is redirecting foreign investment from China to ASEAN (specifically Myanmar, Indonesia, and Thailand) due to rising risks in China.
- Risk Mitigation: Japan is assisting ASEAN nations in coast guard training and boat rentals to counter security threats in the South China Sea.
- Japan-US Alliance: Yoshida Nakayama emphasized the critical necessity of maintaining US military presence in Asia, stating Japan is willing to cover 100% of the costs for US forces if required to ensure their stay.
- Multilateral Engagement:
- Panelists argue against viewing the region through a purely zero-sum lens, noting that competition coexists with necessary cooperation on cross-border issues like climate change (Paris Accord), terrorism, and trafficking.
- ASEAN is described as a "neutralizing force" capable of mediating relationships between great powers, preventing any single nation from acting radically without regional consideration.
Security Threats and Military Dynamics
- North Korea:
- Yoshida Nakayama cites intelligence indicating North Korea has produced approximately 20 nuclear warheads, with the capability to target Japan within seven minutes of a launch.
- Japan anticipates further nuclear tests or military activities from Pyongyang within six months.
- South China Sea Tensions:
- Ongoing military exercises by China and Russia in the South China Sea are raising alarm bells, with Japan concerned about the potential for sudden escalation.
- Japan and China have established a maritime hotline regarding the Senkaku Islands to manage friction, though the risk of accidental conflict remains high.
- Rule of Law Disputes:
- A primary geopolitical fault line is the interpretation of international law; ASEAN nations uphold UNCLOS and the rule of law, while China's actions (e.g., artificial island building) challenge these norms.
- US Freedom of Navigation Operations are conducted to uphold these international rules, despite Chinese objections.
Technology, Information Warfare, and Domestic Politics
- The Information Tsunami:
- Maria Ressa notes that 6,000 square meters of information are generated every second, a velocity comparable to an atom bomb, creating an exponential rather than linear growth in data.
- This shift has dismantled traditional media gatekeeping, allowing "everyone to be a journalist" and empowering both positive engagement and malicious campaigns.
- Social Media as a Political Weapon:
- Rodrigo Duterte's 2016 election victory in the Philippines was driven by a massive, bot-driven social media campaign, with 16 million votes secured via digital mobilization.
- Disinformation Tactics: Campaigns utilize "FUD" (Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt) and "sock puppet" networks to manipulate public perception; for example, fake accounts reposted old news as breaking current events to justify a state of emergency following a bombing.
- Corporate & Political Blurring: Tactics originally developed by corporations (e.g., Smart telco in the Philippines) have been adopted by political groups to drown out opponents with bot-generated hashtags.
- Impact on Public Discourse:
- Algorithms now determine the quality of public discourse, creating volatile environments where fake news can trend higher than verified reporting, particularly in youth-heavy demographics (median age 22-23 in Philippines and Indonesia).
Specific Case Studies and Regional Volatility
- The Philippines (Duterte Administration):
- Approval vs. Criticism: Duterte entered office with a 91% approval rating, driven by a promise to end corruption and crime; however, the "war on drugs" has resulted in over 3,500 deaths in 11 weeks, including 2,000+ extrajudicial killings.
- Geopolitical Reorientation: Duterte has signaled a pivot toward China and Russia, requesting arms from them while criticizing the US and former US President Obama.
- US Response: Nina Shijian characterizes the US-Philippines alliance as a 70-year partnership that will endure despite the current transition, noting that ASEAN nations generally maintain "multi-alignment" with all major powers.
- Economic Impact: Stock market volatility occurred post-election, with investors fleeing initially, though domestic safety perceptions have risen for some sectors.
- Inequality as a Driver:
- Rising inequality is identified as a root cause of political volatility, fueling support for strongman leaders (Duterte, Trump, Xi) who promise to address the grievances of those "left behind" by globalization.
- Corruption and elite resistance to tax reforms pose significant challenges to implementing social safety nets.
Future Outlook and Strategic Recommendations
- ASEAN Integration:
- ASEAN is moving toward an Economic Community, which aims to increase economic independence from great powers.
- The "Young Leaders" initiative (ASEAN-US CONNECT) has reached nearly 100,000 members, fostering a shared regional identity among youth who previously lacked awareness of their neighbors.
- Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP):
- Panelists expressed confidence that the TPP will pass the US lame-duck session, emphasizing its geopolitical and economic importance for stability in the Pacific.
- Japan is expected to play a pivotal role in lobbying the US administration to finalize the agreement.
- US Commitment:
- The US has reaffirmed its status as a "Pacific power," stating it will remain in the region for the long term regardless of US election outcomes.
- Yoshida Nakayama noted willingness to pay for US military costs (including F-35s and salaries) to ensure US forces remain in Asia as a deterrent.
- Rising Powers:
- India's "Look East" policy and focus on ASEAN are reshaping the geopolitical calculus, with Myanmar increasingly viewed as a bridge between South and Southeast Asia.
- Singapore is cited as a model for balancing relationships with all major powers (US, China, India, Japan).