newsfilter
← Interviews
Milken Institute1h 0m

Creating Smarter Cities

Peter Scheer, Meredith Whitney, Mayor Smith, Mayor Richard Daley, Rick Caruso, Dan Bitterman, John Graff, Esther Dyson

Panel, Conference Presentation

Context and Global Urbanization Trends

  • JPMorgan Chase and the Brookings Institution have launched a five-year, multimillion-dollar Global Cities Initiative to provide data and expertise to municipalities.
  • Urban population is projected to rise from 50% globally today to 70% by 2050, creating cities of unprecedented scale.
  • In the U.S., 100 metropolitan areas generate three-quarters of the nation's GDP; globally, 600 metropolitan areas account for 60% of GDP.
  • Challenges for urban governance include infrastructure, education, energy, and clean water, requiring new business models beyond traditional approaches.

Fiscal Realities and Economic Competitiveness

  • 49 states are legally required to balance their budgets, forcing cuts to discretionary spending on education, infrastructure, and public safety during revenue shortfalls.
  • A "negative feedback loop" occurs when cities raise taxes and cut services, causing businesses to relocate and further eroding the tax base.
  • States like Illinois and California have experienced significant business exodus due to high taxes, while Arizona has benefited from relocation.
  • Cities face "city arbitrage," where municipalities compete directly for businesses by offering tax advantages, accelerating the need for fiscal competitiveness.
  • Traditional 20th-century financing and taxing systems are misaligned with a modern, mobile, internet-driven economy.

Private Sector Innovation and Public-Private Partnerships

  • Bryant Park Corporation operates on a model charging market rates for space and events, contrasting with New York City's standard of $100 for events like a picnic, which Dan Bitterman notes is inefficient.
  • Rick Caruso's "The Grove" development strategy focuses on creating localized "town centers" where residents can live, work, and play, reducing traffic and increasing local sales tax revenue.
  • The Americana at Brand in Glendale, California, is a private-public partnership generating roughly $1,200 per square foot in sales (triple the national average), making the developer the second-largest taxpayer in the city.
  • Mesa, Arizona, implemented a strategic partnership with a local hospital to utilize "transitional response vehicles" (TRVs) for non-emergency medical calls, reducing the deployment of expensive fire trucks for minor injuries.
  • Rick Caruso argues that cities should function as facilitators rather than barriers, noting that 10-20% public investment in projects like Millennium Park ensures taxpayer involvement without full privatization.
  • Dan Bitterman notes that political resistance to the term "privatization" is geographically concentrated, largely absent west of Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and east of the High Sierras.

Education, Infrastructure, and Labor

  • Meredith Whitney identifies a direct correlation between unemployment, poverty, and the quality of the education system, labeling education the primary competitive factor for cities.
  • Whitney advocates for the privatization of public assets (e.g., toll roads, airports) to generate capital for infrastructure and social services, citing the Chicago Skyway lease ($2 billion) as a model for funding hard and social infrastructure.
  • Mayor Daley emphasizes that cities must compete globally against international hubs like Shanghai and Mexico City rather than domestically against other U.S. cities.
  • Municipalities are urged to consolidate pension funds to professionalize management and fund infrastructure, a move requiring significant political courage.
  • Union resistance to privatization is a significant hurdle, particularly in the Northeast and California, though some officials note that private contracts can sometimes maintain union representation with better outcomes.
  • Mayor Daley highlights the "Big Dig" in Boston as a worst-case example of infrastructure mismanagement and Mitch Daniels' privatization of Indiana toll roads as a best practice.
  • Technology adoption, specifically surveillance cameras, is cited as a proven method for reducing crime and improving efficiency in cities like London and Chicago.

Specific Challenges and Forward-Looking Statements

  • Rick Caruso warns that relying on asset sales to cover operating deficits (P&L) will eventually bankrupt a city, suggesting that structural pension problems must be solved first.
  • Meredith Whitney suggests that municipal bankruptcy, while not a great solution for individuals, may be necessary to force political courage and reshape unsustainable pension systems, citing the example of Central Falls, Rhode Island.
  • Dan Bitterman predicts that the next wave of municipal bankruptcies will primarily occur in "blue states" due to the stronger political taboo against privatization.
  • Mayor Smith notes that cities are uniquely constrained compared to federal or state governments because they cannot run deficits, requiring immediate and creative fiscal solutions.
  • The panelists agreed that cities must move beyond "either/or" thinking regarding public vs. private control, adopting hybrid models that leverage private capital for public goods.
  • Future growth depends on creating "learning environments" that extend beyond the traditional school day, utilizing community spaces and private sectors to support education.