newsfilter
← Interviews
Milken Institute59 min

Emerging Markets Outlook

Douglas Rediker, Teresa C. Barger, Binay Chandgothia, Binod Chaudhary, Penny Foley, Francisco N. González

Conference Presentation, Panel

Political Risk and the "Emerging Markets Now" Paradigm

  • Political risk is no longer exclusive to emerging markets (EM); it has become a universal factor affecting global investment decisions.
  • Formerly distinct EM characteristics—including legal opacity, nepotism, and arbitrary law application—are increasingly prevalent in developed markets like the U.S., where political figures can now move global markets via social media.
  • Investors are advised to adopt a "political economy" mindset, acknowledging that qualitative political inputs are often determinative of financial outcomes.
  • The traditional distinction between developed and emerging markets has blurred, with the consensus that "we are all emerging markets now."

Market Evolution and Structural Shifts (Past 10–20 Years)

  • Diversification & Instruments: Post-2008 financial crisis, the development of ETFs and new investment instruments enabled instant liquidity access to EM and frontier markets, which were previously considered too risky.
  • Credit Quality Improvements: The JP Morgan EM Bond Index transformed from ~10% investment grade in the 1990s to over 50% today.
  • Geographic Expansion: The EM bond universe expanded from 38 countries in 2008 to 67 countries currently.
  • Valuation Gap: EM assets currently trade at roughly half the valuations of the U.S. and Japan, though Europe lags behind this metric.
  • Growth Divergence: EM growth relative to developed markets is widening, creating a strong pull factor for foreign direct investment (FDI) and equities.
  • Sovereign Debt Composition: Approximately 75% of sovereign debt is now denominated in local currency (up from nearly 100% hard currency in 1998-99), reducing balance sheet vulnerability to currency devaluation.
  • Corporate Debt: Corporate debt remains disproportionately dollar-based, as domestic investors in EM are primarily "rates buyers" rather than credit buyers, leaving a gap in local currency corporate bond markets.

Macro Outlook and Investment Themes

  • Cycle Positioning: EMs are currently viewed as being in the "early to early-mid cycle," contrasting with the "late cycle" U.S. economy, making them less vulnerable to capital withdrawal than in 2013.
  • Inflation & Rates: Inflation remains low due to negative output gaps in many economies, while real rates are high.
  • Demographics & Consumption: China and India now account for a GDP share 10% higher than the U.S. (in PPP terms); EMs are shifting from cyclicality (materials/energy) to consumption-oriented models.
  • Sector Composition: MSCI China offshore listings are 40% technology/domestic, compared to 25% in the U.S. and 11% in Europe.
  • Domestic Capital Flows: EM pension funds typically allocate only 10% to equities (vs. 60% in US models), leaving massive potential for institutionalized domestic savings to enter capital markets.
  • Currency Trends: A longer-term dollar weakening cycle is anticipated, punctuated by countertrends of 5-7%; currency volatility may become a primary driver for equity and local currency bond returns.

Investment Methodologies and Strategies

  • Fixed Income Approach:
    • Focus on "top-down" identification of political and economic turning points rather than static credit analysis.
    • Sovereign research teams target countries undergoing significant structural or policy changes to capture value ahead of the market.
    • Local currency bond returns are attractive but carry high risk in countries with weak institutional frameworks (e.g., Turkey), while USD-denominated bonds historically yield ~300 basis points over developed markets.
  • Equity & Activism (Cardica Management):
    • 85% of EM listed companies are controlled by families, founders, or the state; activism must be constructive rather than confrontational.
    • Successful interventions focus on "low-hanging fruit": improving English disclosure, removing non-core businesses, establishing succession plans, and enhancing analyst coverage.
    • Case Study: A Peruvian company doubled in value in 18 months after activists secured English reporting, segment reporting, and a clear succession plan.
    • Case Study: An attempt to convert a Brazilian offshore listing to an onshore listing failed due to the controlling shareholder's resistance, highlighting limits of influence in entrenched environments.
  • Operational Perspective:
    • Corporate operators view EMs as resilient; essential sectors (e.g., food) grow regardless of political instability.
    • Unpredictability and political volatility are currently perceived as higher in Western economies than in many EMs.
    • A "risk-reward mismatch" exists where distant, passive fund managers overestimate risk due to comfort zone biases, missing opportunities in emerging markets.

Regional Focus: Mexico and Trade

  • Electoral Context: A ~90% probability exists for Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador to win the Mexican election, though institutional reforms (requiring supermajorities) have strengthened the framework.
  • Trade Agreements: Mexico is advancing multiple trade deals, including the updated NAFTA (USMCA), agreements with Europe, and the CPTPP.
  • Supply Chain Resilience: Despite tariff threats, foreign direct investment (FDI) in Mexico is robust, particularly in automotive, aeronautical, and electric manufacturing.
  • CPTPP Impact: The agreement has redirected automotive and textile supply chains (e.g., from Australia/Vietnam) to Mexico, boosting raw material imports and manufacturing depth.
  • Currency Risk: The Mexican peso has been a top performer; however, the administration's rhetoric on trade imbalances creates volatility that can impact export competitiveness.

ESG and Governance

  • Social & Environmental Enforcement: In EMs, investors often must enforce local safety, labor, and environmental laws internally due to weak regulatory oversight.
  • Governance as Value Driver: Improving governance yields the highest re-rating potential, specifically through:
    • Capital Allocation: Reducing excess cash on balance sheets to increase Return on Equity (e.g., shifting from 35% to 55% ROE).
    • Internal Controls: Implementing robust KPIs and measurement systems to enable growth.
  • Greenwashing Warning: Past instances show companies re-rating purely on the use of "corporate governance" terminology without substantive operational changes (e.g., Russian companies in 1999).

Forward-Looking Statements and Asset Class Outlook

  • Yield Environment: EM fixed income offers relative value with yields in the 6%–6.5% range, contrasting with <2% yields in 45% of the global opportunity set.
  • Local Currency Bonds: The "risk-free asset" is currently non-existent; the concept of a risk-free asset in EM is a multi-year transition dependent on the evolution of the U.S. Treasury market's own risk profile.
  • China's Influence: China is aggressively expanding influence via the Belt and Road Initiative, offering low-cost debt and strategic partnerships that bypass traditional corporate considerations in South Asia, Africa, and Central Asia.
  • Fintech & Blended Finance: Project financing is evolving toward blended models (traditional bank + funds + fintech) to mitigate risk and accelerate execution.
  • Market Outlook: The EM cycle is expected to run for another 9–10 years; investors must exit comfort zones to capture returns in "unexplored" markets with first-mover advantages.
  • Risk Warning: While sovereign risk is mitigated, corporate leverage remains a concern, particularly in China, though policy focus on deleveraging is increasing.