newsfilter
← Interviews
Milken Institute1h 0m

Expanding Access to Higher Education

Brandon Busteed, Christopher Eisgruber, Karen Symms Gallagher, Thomas LeBlanc, Jeff Maggioncalda, George Weiss

Panel, Conference Presentation

College Completion Disparities and Data Trends

  • Over the past 50 years, the college completion rate for children born into the top socioeconomic quartile in the US doubled from 40% to 80%.
  • In the same period, completion rates for the bottom socioeconomic quartile increased only marginally from 6% to 9%.
  • The national six-year average graduation rate for US higher education institutions sits at approximately 60%.
  • Public perception of college readiness is extremely low, with only 3% of US adults believing high school graduates are very prepared for college success.
  • US high school graduation rates are at an all-time high of 83.2%, though panelists dispute the accuracy of federal data reporting.

Institutional Strategies for Low-Income Completion

  • Princeton University now enrolls 28% of its entering class as first-generation or low-income students, achieving a 93% completion rate for this group compared to 96% for the highest-income quintile.
  • Georgia State University utilizes big data analytics to identify at-risk students, increasing completion rates by 22 percentage points to the mid-50s while maintaining equity between underrepresented minorities and white students.
  • USC's Neighborhood Academic Initiative has partnered with LA public schools since the 1990s, resulting in over 1,000 high school graduates and nearly 500 college entrants from the program.
  • USC's five charter high schools (operated via the 501(c)(3) Ednovate) report a 100% high school graduation rate and a 100% college acceptance rate for their first graduating class.
  • George Washington University became test-optional two years ago, which increased the number of underrepresented minority applicants by 33% in the first year.
  • Say Yes to Education partners with cities to place mental health clinics and social workers in schools, aiming to raise expectations and support inner-city students before college.

Financial Models, Pricing, and Affordability

  • Princeton employs aggressive price discrimination, with 60% of its student body on financial aid; the average scholarship exceeds the tuition price, and 83% of graduates leave with zero debt.
  • USC operates on a tuition-driven model, providing over $600 million annually in institutional scholarships and grants to students.
  • Higher education is characterized by an average 50% discount rate between published tuition and actual net price paid by students.
  • George Washington University President Tom LeBlanc justifies price discrimination as a moral imperative for a public good, noting students voted to subsidize scholarship students via full-pay peers.
  • Coursera has launched "Coursera for Business," with 1,000 companies hiring the platform to provide employee access to courses and degrees, addressing the opportunity cost of working while studying.
  • The Google IT Support certification is offered via Coursera with a scholarship fund covering up to 12,000 seats, and the University of London plans to grant credit for this certification toward a Bachelor's degree.
  • The University of Illinois offers a fully online Master's in Computer Science for $25,000, which is comparable to the on-campus degree cost but designed for working professionals.

Panelist Perspectives on Metrics and Future Directions

  • Chris Eisgruber (Princeton) argues that while an ideal graduation rate should be pushed higher, 100% is unattainable and undesirable as it eliminates the ability for institutions to take risks on diverse students.
  • Karen Gallagher (USC) contends that universities should aim for a 100% graduation rate for admitted students to shift the institutional mindset from blaming student failure to identifying systemic barriers.
  • George Weiss (Say Yes to Education) asserts that raising expectations and standards in underserved communities is more critical than focusing solely on financial aid, citing a reversal of college matriculation rates in Guilford County, NC from 12% to 88% after program intervention.
  • Jeff Magin (Coursera) suggests that flexible, work-integrated credentials (such as "Master Track Certificates") allow learners to earn degrees while maintaining income, effectively decoupling affordability from immediate access.
  • The panel unanimously agreed that the current six-year federal graduation metric obscures the reality that the vast majority of students complete degrees closer to four years, particularly at selective institutions.
  • Tom LeBlanc noted that "early action" programs help yield but "early decision" binding programs are discriminatory against low-income families who cannot afford to commit without knowing their financial aid package.
  • Coursera's MBA program at the University of Illinois features an average student age of 37 (working professionals) compared to 27 for on-campus peers, highlighting a shift toward lifelong learning models.
  • Princeton is expanding its undergraduate body size to accommodate transfer students from community colleges, military veterans, and more low-income students without reducing spots for traditional applicants.
  • Panelists expressed skepticism regarding Income Share Agreements (ISAs), noting they currently benefit high-earning STEM majors but are unlikely to be a widespread solution for the broader student population.