Milken Institute58 min
Fast Pitch: Concept, Presentation and Critique
Daniel Gorfine, Delian Asperhov, Bonin Bao, Lynn Tilton, Steve Case, Caroline Pugh, Riley Ennis, Katalin Voss, Spencer Hewitt, Ryan Cavanaugh
Conference Presentation, Fireside Chat, Panel, Statement
Event Overview
- The Milken Institute hosted the inaugural "Fast Pitch" competition in partnership with Kairos Society, a global network connecting entrepreneurs across 50+ countries.
- The event focused on entrepreneurs addressing critical global challenges in health, sustainability, and job creation.
- Audience voting determined the winner via text message to number 22333.
- Presentations were evaluated against four criteria: growth potential, financial strategy, on-stage presentation, and social impact.
- Judges included Bonin Bao (Mondelez International), Steve Case (Revolution), Ryan Cavanaugh (Relativity Media), and Lynn Tilton (Patriarch Partners).
Judges' Core Evaluation Criteria
- Bonin Bao: Emphasized the necessity of a clear underlying business model, scalability, and verified consumer need over mere "great ideas."
- Steve Case: Prioritized the quality of the team ("people") and a concrete execution plan, citing Thomas Edison's quote that "vision without execution is hallucination."
- Ryan Cavanaugh: Stressed the need for "people who take a chance" on critical problems rather than competing in saturated markets with existing solutions.
- Lynn Tilton: Looked for products combining elegant design with disruptive technology ("wow factor") and a viable path to building a business.
- Collective Feedback: All judges noted a significant lack of detailed financial models and specific revenue projections across most pitches.
- Strategic Consensus: Judges agreed that future success for these startups relies heavily on strategic partnerships for distribution and scaling rather than going it alone.
Venture Presentations and Feedback
Nightingale (Delian Asperhov)
- Problem: Addresses the inefficiency of manual data collection in autism therapy, which costs families ~$60,000/year and creates therapist administrative burdens.
- Solution: A mobile app allowing therapists to record behavioral data via phones, automatically generating reimbursement forms and adjusting therapy plans based on data.
- Business Model: SaaS fee of $40 per student per month; currently serving 80 students across seven Bay Area programs.
- Financials: Raised a seed round at a $5 million pre-money convertible note; projects $6 million annual revenue within two years by capturing 1% of the market.
- Judge Feedback: Lynn Tilton questioned the income timeline and scalability plan, while Ryan Cavanaugh suggested leveraging the captured data for broader insights and partnering with major healthcare entities like J&J.
VirtualU (Caroline Pugh)
- Problem: Lack of standard, cost-effective tools for tracking comprehensive biometric data (lean mass, fat %, etc.) in fitness settings.
- Solution: A proprietary 3D body scanner that captures 24 million data points in 10 seconds, providing a 3D model and biometric report to users and gyms.
- Business Model: Hardware leasing model with no upfront cost to gyms; revenue share based on user engagement.
- Financials: Raised $625,000 seed round; relies on deferred payment manufacturing terms; charges users ~$6/month.
- Challenge: Judges identified the hardware model as capital-intensive and prone to obsolescence (3-year cycle) with low margins per user.
- Strategic Pivot: Lynn Tilton advised shifting the focus from fitness gyms to the fashion industry, using the 3D avatars to reduce clothing return rates and selling on transaction volume.
Immuticon (Riley Ennis)
- Problem: High recurrence rates in cancer treatment due to drug resistance and cancer stem cells.
- Solution: Targeted therapies aimed specifically at cancer stem cells, currently in preclinical development with the National Cancer Institute.
- Financials: Seeking seed capital to build a "data package" (mouse/non-human primate data) to de-risk the project for a potential pharmaceutical acquisition.
- Judge Feedback: Lynn Tilton expressed skepticism regarding the efficacy of rodent models for human cancer and the historical failure of stem-cell targeting therapies; estimated a need for $100M-$500M over 15 years, far exceeding current fundraising goals.
- Advice: Ryan Cavanaugh suggested focusing on the $100M+ requirement for biotech viability, while Steve Case commended the partnership approach with institutions like Stanford.
Sention (Katalin Voss)
- Problem: Behavioral therapy for autism often relies on abstract flashcards that fail to translate to real-world social cues.
- Solution: A Google Glass app using outward-facing cameras and eye-tracking to provide real-time facial expression recognition and social cues (e.g., "pause," "ask a question") to the user.
- Business Model: No commercial business model yet; intends to eventually sell the device and data analytics to behavioral therapists.
- Related Venture: An educational arm, Ascension, already monetizes similar underlying technology for schools.
- Judge Feedback: Ryan Cavanaugh highlighted the "brilliance" of the real-time interactive cue system; suggested a strategic partnership with Nightingale to leverage their existing therapist network and revenue model.
Skip (Spencer Hewitt)
- Problem: Long checkout lines and high operational costs for retailers due to traditional checkout processes.
- Solution: RFID-based "fast track" system that automatically tracks items via passive RFID tags and computer vision to charge users upon exit, eliminating lines.
- Value Proposition: Claims 25-50% profit increase for retailers via reduced staffing, shrinkage, and improved inventory analytics.
- Business Model: Charges retailers $1 for every $10 saved, plus fees for sales data and analytics.
- Implementation: Requires item-level RFID tagging (already present at retailers like JCPenney, Burberry, and American Apparel).
- Judge Feedback: Ryan Cavanaugh noted the "super competitive" landscape (including Google) and potential consumer privacy concerns regarding data tracking; suggested focusing on vertically integrated retailers (who control their own tagging) to bypass supplier complexity.
Competition Results
- Winner: Katalin Voss, founder of Sention.
- Reasoning: The judges and audience recognized the unique application of technology to a niche, high-impact problem (autism social cues) and the potential for a viable, partner-driven business model.
- Future Outlook: Daniel Gorfine and Steve Case noted that the event highlighted the critical role of startups in driving the economy and the increasing necessity for cross-sector partnerships to achieve scale.