Milken Institute1h 5m
Global Capital Markets The Search for Value
Laura Deal Lacey, Michael Milken, Gordon Fyfe, Lawrence Golub, Omar Lodhi, Larry Post
Conference Presentation, Fireside Chat, Panel
Market Context and Pressure:
- Global pension funds and endowments face pressure to meet return targets despite "ratcheted down" assumptions; most large US and European funds still target 7%–7.5%.
- Norway's sovereign wealth fund is considering lowering its objective from 4% to 3%, while Japan holds ~$20 trillion in assets accepting a zero rate of return.
- The stage group opposes accepting zero returns, aiming to generate substantial rates through active management.
Gordon Thompson (BC Pension Fund - $130B AUM):
- Return Targets: Actuaries cite 6.25%–6.5% as a "home run," with the next decade deemed more difficult due to market valuations and low growth.
- Investment Strategy:
- Growth: Prioritizing India (demographics, reforms) and Africa (long-term horizon, 10–30 years), while remaining cautious on China except for specific consumer sectors.
- Distress: Actively investing in distressed Brazilian infrastructure assets made available by political turmoil.
- Fees: Aggressively challenging the "2 and 20" fee structure when returns are 8%–12%; reducing fees by increasing internal management to ~50% (rising) from lower Canadian peers.
- Liquidity Advantage: Maintains positive cash flow ($2B+ annually), avoiding fire sales during crises and allowing deployment of "illiquidity premium."
- Manager Selection: Prioritizes partner integrity, transparency, and alignment of interest (e.g., managers co-investing real cash) over asset selection alone.
Larry Robbins (Arena Capital) & Lawrence Golub (Golub Capital):
- Larry Robbins (Short-Duration High Yield):
- Targets a neglected ~$1 trillion market segment (5-year duration or less) within the $2.6 trillion high-yield universe.
- Returns/Volatility: Generates 5%–7% annual returns with 50–70% of the index's volatility, prioritizing capital preservation over duration risk.
- Risk Management: Argues rating agencies fail to adjust ratings for short-term bonds; prefers predictable short-term credit risk over 10-year interest rate risk.
- Lawrence Golub (Middle Market Lending):
- Market Size: Targets the $10 trillion US middle market (approx. 1/3 of US GDP) via non-bank lending, as bank lending has declined >80% due to regulation and compensation structures.
- Performance: Revenue/profit growth in this sector is double that of large caps/GDP; unleveraged net returns of 6%–8%, rising to 11%–13% with 2:1 leverage.
- Operating Model: Operates as an "operating business" with heavy back-office/IT infrastructure (125 loan ops staff) to manage risk, charging fees less than 1/3 of bank overheads.
- Credit Discipline: Avoids energy; compensates deal-makers based on long-term fund profits rather than quarterly mark-to-market to prevent risky behavior.
- Larry Robbins (Short-Duration High Yield):
Omar Choudhry (Emerged Markets/Private Equity):
- Investment Thesis: Focuses on "rough neighborhoods" (Sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America, MENA, Asia) expecting 2/3 of global growth over the next 20 years; targets 1.7 billion people entering the middle class.
- Risk Mitigation:
- Micro vs. Macro: Treats risks as manageable micro-issues (partners, alignment) rather than unmanageable macro risks.
- Local Presence: Requires "boots on the ground" to navigate local nuances and legal systems; assumes 6%–7% annual currency devaluation.
- Defensive Sectors: Focuses on essential consumption (healthcare, education, food) resilient to political instability.
- Case Study (Turkey): Invested >$1B over 15 years in defensive sectors (hospitals, dairy); exited a hospital business (IHH) valued at ~$15B; lost money on a luxury yacht venture due to hubris.
- Future Opportunity: Identifying Indonesia as a potential high-growth market similar to China's previous decade.
Cross-Cutting Themes:
- Distressed Opportunities: Crises (Brazil, financial crisis, Turkey coup) create access to premium assets at discounted prices for funds with dry powder.
- Alignment of Interest: Successful management requires partners to co-invest capital and align incentives with long-term fund performance, not just short-term fees.
- Governance Debate: Canadian pension funds maintain high independence from government, serving as a model for US funds seeking to reduce political interference.
- Credit Covenants: Emphasis on strong covenants and structural protections in debt deals to provide upside and downside protection, often ignored in high-spread markets.
Forward-Looking Statements:
- Golub Capital: Plans to grow AUM by 50%–80% over 3–4 years while maintaining credit discipline and limiting market share to <6%.
- BC Pension Fund: Anticipates significantly higher effort required to generate returns over the next decade compared to the previous decade.
- Arena Capital: Focuses on avoiding "strikes" (major losses) rather than chasing home runs to secure favorable long-term returns.
- Omar: Believes "stepping off the curb" (inaction) is a risk; continuing to invest in emerging markets is necessary despite volatility.