newsfilter
← Interviews
Milken Institute1h 2m

How Improved Health and Longer Lives Drive Global Prosperity

Thomas Frieden, Jonathan Gluck, Carole Roan Gresenz, Michael Harsh, Peter Margolis, Ceci Connolly

Fireside Chat, Panel, Conference Presentation

Panel Overview & Objective

  • The session, hosted by Cece Connolly (PwC Health Research Institute), examined the link between healthcare innovation and economic growth, aiming to debunk myths surrounding cost and quality.
  • The panel comprised experts from the CDC, Heritage Provider Network, Georgetown University/RAND, GE Health Care, and the University of Cincinnati.
  • The central thesis posited that moving from a "sick care" fee-for-service model to an accountable care model improves population health while reducing long-term costs.

Economic Impact & Innovation Examples

  • Immunization ROI: Dr. Thomas Frieden (CDC) cited a 10-to-1 return on investment for immunizations, generating $70 billion in societal savings annually from $14 billion in spending.
    • Immunizations prevent approximately 20 million disease cases and save 42,000 lives yearly.
    • The benefit-to-cost ratio is 3-to-1 for direct medical costs and 10-to-1 for total societal costs.
  • Accountable Care Models: Jonathan Gluck (Heritage Provider Network) highlighted a 30-year track record of using budget-based care (capitation/medical homes) to reduce costs.
    • This model relies on the premise that preventing illness is cheaper than treating it after onset.
    • The industry is shifting toward this model via the Affordable Care Act and CMS Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI).
  • Telehealth & Diabetes Management: Carol Roan (Georgetown/RAND) noted a CMMI pilot in Hawaii using remote foot imaging to prevent amputations in low-income diabetics.
    • The device takes daily foot photos to detect neuropathy early, preventing ulcers.
    • Medicare is currently funding this pilot, signaling potential broader adoption.
  • Imaging Efficiency Savings: Mike Harsh (GE Health Care) estimated that the shift from exploratory surgery to diagnostic imaging saved nearly $14 billion annually over the last 20 years.
    • Exploratory surgeries have declined by approximately 60% due to advanced imaging technologies like CT, MRI, and PET.
    • GE developed a handheld ultrasound device ($50k+ annual savings potential) described as a "21st-century stethoscope" for point-of-care cardiac diagnostics.
  • Systematic Care Standardization: Dr. Peter Margolis (UCincinnati) reported that the "Improved Care Now" network increased remission rates for pediatric IBD (Crohn's/Colitis) from 60% to 77% without new medications.
    • This network involves 52 centers, 15,000 patients, and 1,000 clinicians sharing standardized data.
    • Current practice gaps show only 25% probability of patients receiving indicated care due to provider/patient adherence failures.

Incentives, Data, and Big Data Strategy

  • Prize Challenges: Heritage Provider Network utilizes prize challenges to crowdsource solutions, leveraging the fact that "most smart people work for somebody else."
    • The "Bundles for Babies" prize aims to find payment models for Medicaid providers to prevent premature birth complications.
    • The "Heritage Health Prize" seeks algorithms to predict hospital admissions to prevent $40 billion in unnecessary hospital care annually.
  • Data Silos & Interoperability: Speakers noted that while the U.S. has enough healthcare data to fill 500,000 Library of Congress volumes, data is trapped in silos.
    • Geolocation of data varies drastically; e.g., Whitman Walker Health in DC uses integrated EMRs, while many private practices in the same district do not.
    • Interoperability is required to eliminate redundant care, though progress is currently "in its infancy" compared to sectors like finance.
  • Industrialization of Healthcare: GE Health Care advocates for "industrializing" healthcare to reduce clinical variation.
    • Eliminating just 1% of clinical diagnostic variation could yield $60–63 billion in annual savings.
    • The strategy requires moving from "data rich, information poor" to actionable insights for providers.
  • Information vs. Incentives: Dr. Frieden emphasized that public reporting of provider performance often motivates physicians more than patients, as doctors are sensitive to ranking.
    • Controlling high blood pressure is a high-impact intervention; 47% of Americans are currently controlled, whereas high-performing systems reach 75-85%.

Barriers, Future Outlook, & Myths

  • Timeframe for Savings: Dr. Roan noted a trade-off where short-term health IT implementation and preventive care increases utilization costs before long-term savings materialize.
  • Payment Reform: The consensus is that reimbursement must shift from "paying for volume" to "paying for value," a transition driven initially by public payers and trickling to private insurers.
  • Myth: Innovation Requires High Tech: Panelists debunked the idea that innovation must be high-tech, citing low-tech solutions like checklists and task-shifting to nurses as highly effective.
  • Political vs. Intellectual Barriers: Jonathan Gluck identified the primary hurdle as political (addressing end-of-life discussions, payment reform) rather than intellectual.
  • Economic Growth & Insurance: Carol Roan argued that universal insurance access fosters entrepreneurship by freeing individuals from "job lock."
  • Patient Engagement: Dr. Margolis highlighted that patients are an underutilized resource; involving them in collaborative networks (e.g., via IP lawyers or filmmakers) accelerates innovation.