Milken Institute1h 0m
Immigration Strategy for the Borderless Economy
Ron Brownstein, Antonio Villaraigosa, Laureen Powell Jobs, Michael Bennett, Carlos Gutierrez, Rupert Murdoch, Vivek Wadhwa
Conference Presentation, Panel, Fireside Chat
Context and Demographics
- The discussion addresses the first serious comprehensive immigration reform debate since 2007, driven by profound demographic shifts.
- The 2010 Census indicated that 37% of the U.S. population is non-white, rising to 47% of the under-18 population.
- The Census Bureau projects the under-18 population will become majority non-white as early as 2018.
- The debate centers on integrating the "brown" (diverse youth) and "gray" (aging white baby boom) generations.
Economic Arguments for Reform
- 11 million undocumented immigrants currently exist in a "shadow economy," unable to legally work in their trained fields or pay full taxes.
- Secretary Carlos Gutierrez cited a microcosm of 100,000+ businesses facing labor shortages; one restaurant owner stated he would operate eight locations instead of three with available workers.
- The U.S. labor force is not growing fast enough to sustain economic expansion without increased immigration.
- Research indicates 40% of the top 500 U.S. companies were founded by immigrants.
- 52% of Silicon Valley startups between 1995 and 2005 were founded by immigrants; this dropped to 43% as U.S. restrictions prevented them from staying.
- A Kauffman Foundation analysis estimated that a "startup visa" alone could add 1% to 1.5% to GDP within 10 years with no cost.
- Legalizing undocumented immigrants would boost tax revenue, stimulate housing markets, and integrate consumers into the formal economy.
- The McKinsey Group estimated the DREAM Act alone would immediately benefit the economy by $300 billion.
- In Los Angeles, 42% of the population is foreign-born, 57% of households have an immigrant head, and 44% of local businesses were started by immigrants.
- Mexico's birth rate has declined from seven children per woman in 1970 to 2.1 today, while its economy grows at 4% and produces more engineers per capita than the U.S.
Proposed Legislation and Provisions
- The Senate "Gang of Eight" plan offers a 10-year pathway to a green card followed by a 3-year period for citizenship, totaling 13 years for most applicants.
- Dreamers receive a faster track: a 5-year pathway to a green card and immediate citizenship eligibility thereafter.
- Agricultural workers also receive a 5-year pathway to citizenship.
- The legislation links the full pathway to specific, objective benchmarks for border security rather than indefinite delays.
- The bill shifts legal immigration from a 75% family reunification / 25% skills split toward a roughly 50/50 balance.
- H-1B visa caps would rise from 65,000 to 120,000, though critics argue this remains insufficient for high-skill demand.
- The bill provides 112,000 agricultural worker visas annually and 20,000 low-skilled construction visas, which Secretary Gutierrez noted are still below actual market needs (e.g., Miami alone needs 20,000 construction workers yearly).
Political Dynamics and Challenges
- Pathway to citizenship is described as a "non-starter" for reform advocates if absent; however, conservatives fear it creates a permanent subclass of non-citizens.
- Polling cited by Rupert Murdoch shows 70% of the public supports a pathway to citizenship, with 51% favoring a timeline under five years.
- The Senate bill enjoys bipartisan support, though the House faces hurdles due to the "Hastert Rule" and the risk of primary challenges from the right.
- Republicans are increasingly concerned about the 2016 election cycle and potential losses among Hispanic and Asian American voters if reform stalls.
- Mitt Romney's "self-deportation" rhetoric and "go home" comments in the 2012 primary are cited as significant factors in the Republican Party losing the Hispanic vote.
- Former President Obama, as a Senator, once supported amendments that threatened to derail a 2007 bill, complicating the history of the issue.
- For the first time, the AFL-CIO and the Chamber of Commerce have agreed to support a bill that includes farm worker provisions.
Education and Integration
- There is a consensus that immigration reform and domestic education reform are "twin issues" that must be addressed simultaneously.
- In Los Angeles, 42% of the population has dropped out of high school, contributing to an 11.8% unemployment rate.
- California projects a deficit of 2.3 million college graduates and specialized degree holders by 2025 due to the achievement gap.
- Only 5% of U.S. college graduates are in technology fields, compared to 30% in China.
- 300 undocumented students at "College Track" currently require full scholarships and cannot work in their majors upon graduation.
- Laureen Powell Jobs noted that if Dreamers were legalized, 2 million others currently in "purgatory" would become productive contributors to society.
Alternative Scenarios and "Plan B"
- Vivek Wadhwa proposed a "Plan B" focusing on immediate, tactical legislation (DREAM Act, startup visas) if comprehensive reform fails, citing a rising anti-immigrant political tide.
- Rupert Murdoch argued that a system with legal status but no pathway to citizenship (as seen in parts of Europe) could create social divisions and is insufficient for the U.S.
- Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa stated that creating a second-class legal class without a citizenship path creates "social ingredients for social division and unrest."
- Senator Michael Bennett warned that without a pathway to citizenship, there will be no bill, and Washington will kick the problem down for 10 to 20 years.
- Secretary Gutierrez suggested that even with 100% border security, failure to adjust worker visas will drive jobs overseas to Mexico and Canada.
- Rupert Murdoch noted that 70% of the population favors a pathway to citizenship, suggesting the Republican base may be more tolerant than leadership assumes, though primary fears remain.
Forward-Looking Statements
- Rupert Murdoch believes the Senate bill will pass, though he feels it is "not nearly good enough" and hopes for adjustments over time.
- Vivek Wadhwa predicts the U.S. is in the midst of a 30-40 year economic reinvention that could be boosted by granting legal status to the 11 million undocumented.
- The panel anticipates that if the House does not pass the bill, the Republican Party risks further demographic alienation and political irrelevance in future national elections.
- Senator Bennett expressed confidence that the Senate can achieve a vote in the neighborhood of 70, making it politically difficult for the House to reject the compromise.