newsfilter
← Interviews
Bloomberg Television9 min

Is AI a Bubble? History Offers Some Clues

Justin Fox, David Gura, Christina Ruffini

Interview
  • The cyclically adjusted price earnings ratio is currently lower than the levels seen roughly a month prior, which had approached the highs of 1999 and 2000, while academic research suggests a 40% probability of a systemic collapse within three years and a 60% probability that it will not occur.
  • A secular bull market has persisted for 17 years, providing millennials time for financial recovery, though credit cycles historically recur every 15 years due to the rotation of authorities who did not experience previous downturns, and regulatory environments tend to become more lax over time as memories of past crises fade.
  • Transformational technologies like railroads and the internet have historically been followed by significant peaks and subsequent natural declines, a pattern the speaker applies to AI while dismissing extreme scenarios involving the elimination of money and work within five years as unlikely to materialize.
  • Access to AI technology will likely be uneven due to monetization constraints, with the technology remaining superior at supplementing certain human tasks rather than fully replacing them, and the speaker acknowledges uncertainty regarding the extent of progress at companies like Anthropic despite their large valuations.
  • Market sentiment drives long periods of growth and shorter periods of decline, yet the speaker states an inability to predict the timing of bubble endings or whether the market has entered a new phase, leading to a strategy of doing nothing with their portfolio despite approaching old age.
  • The speaker expresses significant trepidation regarding the next couple of decades, noting that while stocks may be worth considerably more in 25 years, the intervening 5 to 10 years may not be favorable, and the most extreme negative scenarios could be particularly detrimental to markets.
  • Cryptocurrency is characterized as an asset class based on air lacking fundamentals, aligning with the view of Eugene Fama who believed Bitcoin should go to zero, while the speaker admits uncertainty about the tangible value held by entities like OpenAI and Anthropic.
  • Academic finance has eventually accepted the term "bubble" despite historical resistance, though it remains widely agreed that predicting exactly when a market bubble will end is impossible, and investors who successfully identify a crisis often spend the subsequent period making incorrect predictions.