newsfilter
← Interviews
80,000 Hours2h 22m

Is effective altruism just for consequentialists? | Andreas Mogensen (2022)

Andreas Mogensen, Rob Wiblin

Interview, Podcast

Andreas Mogensen, a Senior Research Fellow at Oxford's Global Priorities Institute, critiques the "Hinge of History Hypothesis" while arguing that effective altruism remains compatible with W.D. Ross's pluralistic deontology despite theoretical disagreements on aggregation and population ethics. He defends the validity of moral intuitions regarding large numbers against skepticism and rebuts evolutionary debunking arguments by distinguishing between proximate and ultimate explanations for belief formation. Mogensen's current work also explores shifting from moral error theory to non-naturalist realism, suggesting that effective altruism functions best as a virtue ethics framework focused on cultivating intellectual integrity rather than strict consequentialism.