Is it more effective help strangers or people you know? | Russ Roberts (2020)
Economist Russ Roberts and 80,000 Hours representatives debated the efficacy of effective altruism, with Roberts challenging the reliance on empirical data for career planning while the organization defended its focus on long-term impact and career capital under uncertainty. The discussion further explored fundamental philosophical divides regarding utilitarianism, where Roberts argued against the aggregation of welfare and the feasibility of global moral calculus in favor of local action and the preservation of individual autonomy. Both parties acknowledged the limitations of scientific prediction and the risks of overconfidence in social science, ultimately converging on the necessity of humility when addressing complex global challenges and the value of diverse, decentralized approaches to human flourishing.