Milken Institute1h 7m
MI Summit 2013 - London: Global Capital Markets: The Forces Shaping the Future of Finance
Leon D. Black, Tom Finke, Mitchell Julis, Scott Minerd, David Zervos, Michael Milken, Mike Clouton
Panel, Conference Presentation
Central Bank Impact on Asset Pricing
- Central banks have made risk-free assets (cash, T-bills) "rich" and expensive to hold, incentivizing investors to move capital into riskier asset classes.
- This strategy, described as the "Bernanke put" or "Draghi put," aims to prevent deflationary spirals by forcing capital into productive risk-taking rather than hoarding.
- Investors are advised to avoid assets vulnerable to currency devaluation by the "printing press," such as cash deposits, while favoring real assets like buildings and equity capital.
- The current environment is described as the "greatest time in history to innovate" due to the high opportunity cost of holding cash.
Regional Market Dynamics: Japan
- Japan serves as a cautionary case where households hoard cash (approximately 54% of financial assets) due to 20 years of low growth and a fear of losing capital.
- Japanese real estate prices remain 65-70% below highs, and the stock market trades more than 60% below its peak, reinforcing risk aversion.
- The challenge for asset managers is convincing Japanese households that transferring capital to institutional managers (e.g., Apollo, Canyon) offers better long-term safety and returns than holding cash.
Insurance Industry Constraints and Opportunities
- The U.S. insurance market manages approximately $10 trillion in assets, with a surge in demand for long-dated fixed annuities driven by aging demographics.
- Insurers face "risk-based capital" rules that limit exposure to high-yield bonds (typically ~6%) and equities (2-4%), forcing a heavy reliance on investment-grade bonds.
- To achieve target long-term rates of return (typically advertised at 6.5% vs. <4% for high-grade debt), insurers are increasing allocations to structured credit, infrastructure, and securitized assets.
Structural Shifts: Banking vs. Shadow Banking
- Non-bank financial institutions (Apollo, Guggenheim, Canyon) are replacing traditional banks as primary lenders, now holding a minority share of bank loans but dominating the alternative financing system.
- The "shadow banking" system has been rejuvenated by central bank liquidity, allowing for the extension of debt maturities and refinancing of the "wall of maturities" that threatened the economy post-2008.
- In Europe, where banking systems are oversized relative to GDP, central banks (e.g., ECB under Draghi) are actively working to expand the market-based credit system to match the U.S. model.
CLO Market and Financial Innovation
- Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLOs) successfully institutionalized the leveraged loan market, utilizing covenant protections to withstand economic downturns.
- Contrastingly, the pre-2008 mortgage-backed security (MBS) market failed due to flawed structure and reliance on flawed regression analysis rather than credit culture.
- CLOs generate "endogenous liquidity" through cash flows from interest and amortization, unlike the market liquidity required for public securities.
Apollo Investment Strategy Evolution
- Apollo manages ~$120 billion in assets, split between private equity ($40B), illiquid credit ($68B), and real estate.
- The firm adopts a "distressed buyout" approach during downturns, focusing on deleveraging over-levered companies with strong fundamentals (e.g., LyondellBasell, where debt was reduced from $25B to $5B).
- Apollo has developed "strategic relationships" with large institutional investors (e.g., Texas Teachers), offering flexible, multi-product mandates with cross-collateralization to provide downside protection and aligned incentives.
- The firm focuses on "credit-oriented private equity," investing up and down the capital structure to identify the optimal risk-reward entry point.
Government Subsidies and Infrastructure
- The U.S. Build America Bonds program (2009) successfully expanded the taxable municipal market by offering a 35% interest subsidy, though it was limited by a short two-year lifespan.
- European initiatives are attempting to replicate this model through "project bonds" supported by the European Investment Bank to stimulate infrastructure spending.
- Investors noted that these subsidized securities historically offered a 2-4% yield premium over corporate debt with minimal principal risk.
Forward-Looking Risks and Political Economy
- David reported concern regarding the political will of central bankers to withdraw from quantitative easing, fearing a return to the inflationary errors of the 1970s.
- Quantitative Easing (QE) creates asymmetric wealth effects, benefiting those with existing capital to take risk while penalizing the savings of the elderly and lower-income populations.
- Scott warned that continued central bank intervention distorts market pricing and urges a return to market forces to avoid destabilizing economic distortions.
- There is a growing trend toward "integrated platforms" where asset managers offer diverse illiquid credit products (e.g., aircraft leasing, distressed loans, non-performing loans) to meet investor yield demands.
Event Logistics
- The panel concluded with an invitation for attendees to a reception on the 31st floor.
- The Milken Institute announced its upcoming 4th London Summit and the Global Conference in Los Angeles for the following April.