Bloomberg Television8 min
New Street's Ferragu Sees Strong Case to Buy Nvidia Shares Ahead of Earnings
Interview, Fireside Chat
Analyst Rating and Valuation
- Pierre Faragu of New Street Research maintains a Buy rating on NVIDIA with a price target of $4.50.
- The recent stock sell-off is characterized as an overreaction that has left the stock trading 70% below the analyst's price target.
China Revenue and Export Analysis
- Direct and indirect revenue from China is estimated at approximately 10%.
- Direct revenue is derived from company reports.
- Indirect estimates account for chips physically entering China via border volumes and suspected smuggling incidents.
- Singapore transit data indicates that 99% of chips shipped to Singapore do not touch local ground but are transshipped to other global destinations.
- Estimates of advanced Chinese AI labs using NVIDIA chips remotely suggest a higher exposure range of 20-25%, though this usage remains authorized.
- High-ranking U.S. administration officials incorrectly assumed that the vast majority of revenue funneled through Singapore was destined for China.
- Direct and indirect revenue from China is estimated at approximately 10%.
Strategic Response to Jensen Huang's Resignation
- The resignation is described as a material blow to the company, creating coordination challenges for the 60+ direct reports who relied on Jensen Huang as a central coordinator.
- Despite the leadership change, the analyst argues the CEO does not represent two-thirds of the company's value.
- Market downgrades immediately following the resignation are attributed to compliance department pressure rather than a fundamental reassessment of the business.
- The analyst asserts that the market is currently overpricing key man risk and the potential revenue loss from China restrictions.
Market Dynamics and Competitive Strategy
- NVIDIA's primary defense against competitors is maintaining a market position that prevents alternatives (e.g., from Google, Amazon, OpenAI) from gaining sufficient scale to develop their own chips.
- The company benefits from open-weight models, which fragment the market and prevent any single user from accumulating enough power to build a competing ecosystem.
- Jensen Huang's strategy of financing small players is identified as a deliberate "divide and conquer" tactic designed to maintain pricing power and fragment demand.
- NVIDIA currently holds an 80% market share, yet faces a tangible threat that selling to a concentrated group of five-to-ten customers could result in losing over 50% of the market to alternative ecosystems.
- The analyst disputes the notion that NVIDIA sells to high-risk Chinese entities due to laziness or desperation, framing it instead as a calculated move to fragment demand and preserve dominance.
Supply Chain and Demand Outlook
- The resignation introduces uncertainty regarding a trillion-plus dollar supply chain and how existing coordination mechanisms will function without Jensen Huang.
- Current global chip demand is characterized as insufficient to meet supply, contradicting narratives of a potential immediate "air pocket" in demand.
- The analyst predicts a potential "slight" impact on near-term earnings, though the long-term structural impact of the leadership transition remains a variable.