newsfilter
← Interviews
80,000 Hours2h 59m

Sarah Eustis-Guthrie on why she shut down her charity, & why more founders should follow her lead

Sarah Eustis-Guthrie, Luisa Rodriguez

Interview, Podcast

Founded by Sarah Eustace Guthrie and Ben Williamson, the Maternal Health Initiative shut down in January 2024 after an 18-month pilot in Ghana failed to reduce pregnancy rates due to unforeseen cultural norms regarding postpartum abstinence and breastfeeding. The organization concluded that continuing the program would misallocate funds from more effective causes, a decision driven by findings that increased contraceptive counseling yielded no marginal benefit when women were already protected by natural methods. This operational pivot highlights systemic challenges in philanthropy, where donor priorities and expert deference often overshadow on-the-ground evidence and local realities.