newsfilter
← Interviews
Milken Institute1h 31m

Small Business Community: What Happened to Mom and Pop?

Nigel Duara, Lenore Estrada, Isabella Casillas Guzman, Eugene Cornelius, Jr., Carolina Martinez, Mark J. Robertson, Sr., David Lesher

Conference Presentation, Panel, Fireside Chat, Webinar

Event Overview & Strategic Context

  • Event Purpose: A CalMatters and Milken Institute co-hosted discussion addressing the outlook for California's 4 million small businesses, focusing on post-pandemic recovery, equity gaps, and future economic resilience.
  • Key Demographic Impact: Federal Reserve data indicates approximately 9 million small businesses did not expect to survive 2021 without government assistance; the pandemic disproportionately impacted low-income communities, communities of color, and women-owned businesses.
  • Federal Leadership Shift: Isabella Casillas Guzman was sworn in as SBA Director, bringing prior experience as California's State Small Business Advocate to oversee the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP), Restaurant Revitalization Fund, and $15 billion in disaster grants.
  • SBA Portfolio Scale: The SBA's portfolio expanded from a typical $40 billion annually to over $1 trillion since the pandemic began, utilizing loans, grants, and debt relief to support 30 million small businesses.

Disparities in Relief Access & Data Points

  • Exclusion Rates: Analysis of SBA data reveals that only 4% of PPP loans went to African American-owned businesses and less than 8% to Latino communities under the 7(a) working capital program.
  • Long-term Risk: 41% of Black-owned businesses are projected not to return due to the crisis, with less than 10% of 504 loans (used for facilities) going to Latino communities.
  • Banking Relationship Barrier: Access to relief was heavily skewed toward businesses with pre-existing banking relationships; those without "preferred lender" status or sophisticated bookkeeping faced immediate exclusion from the first round of funding.
  • Grant Distribution Results: In the Restaurant Revitalization Fund, $18 billion of the $28.6 billion total was directed to underserved, women, veteran, and socially/economically disadvantaged businesses.
  • Shuttered Venues Impact: The revamped Shuttered Venues Operator Grant program awarded $5.2 billion to over 6,800 cultural and performing arts entities.
  • EIDL Performance: The SBA has delivered over 3.8 million Economic Injury Disaster Loans (EIDL) totaling over $218 billion, with an additional $3 billion in targeted grants for low-income communities.

Business Owner Case Studies & Operational Challenges

  • Revenue Collapse Scenario: Lenore Estrada, owner of Three Babes Bake Shop, faced an 80% revenue drop when major corporate clients (e.g., Google, Lyft) shut down, forcing the layoff of 24 of 30 employees.
  • Community Adaptation: Estrada pivoted to co-found "SF New Deal," a nonprofit that distributed over 50,000 meals to food-insecure populations by coordinating with 200 local restaurants, demonstrating a model of community-led resource distribution.
  • Digital Divide Barriers: Service providers noted that many underserved business owners lacked digital literacy, requiring "drive-by" scanning services in parking lots to help them apply for recovery programs.
  • Personal Liability Risks: Small business owners reported facing personal bankruptcy risks due to personal guarantees required for leases and loans, a vulnerability not present for venture-backed startups.
  • Administrative Bottlenecks: California's Employment Development Department (EDD) experienced severe backlogs, causing unemployment benefit delays of up to six weeks, forcing owners to lend interest-free money to staff.

Industry Solutions & The "Five C's" Ecosystem

  • CDFI Intervention: Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) emerged as critical intermediaries, funding ~400 PPP loans totaling $8 million with an average of $20,000, targeting 70% loans to entrepreneurs of color.
  • Technical Assistance Role: Small Business Development Centers (SBDCs) provided essential coaching on financial literacy, helping owners reorganize paperwork and apply for grants they would otherwise miss.
  • Five C's Framework: CAMEO proposed a support framework consisting of Coaching (technical assistance), Capital (diverse funding sources), Connections (network building), Climate (local government support), and Culture (community engagement).
  • Marketing Gap: Industry leaders identified a "best kept secret" regarding SBA services, noting that non-profits historically under-invested in marketing, leading to confusion among business owners about where to seek help.

Future Outlook & Forward-Looking Statements

  • Infrastructure Opportunities: The SBA is repositioning to help small businesses access a $500 billion federal marketplace via the Bipartisan Infrastructure Framework and "Build Back Better" agenda, with a goal of increasing Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) contract goals by $50–$100 billion over five years.
  • Program Evolution: The SBA is shifting toward a customer-centric, technology-forward approach, aiming to streamline the EIDL application process within weeks to expedite relief for high-impact communities.
  • Community Navigator Pilot: A $100 million hub-and-spoke program was launched to fund trusted local organizations to connect underserved businesses with resources, though panelists reported significant implementation friction in finding "hub" administrators.
  • Resilience Strategies: Experts advise businesses to diversify revenue streams, move financial records online for disaster readiness, and secure business disruption insurance to mitigate future shocks.
  • Non-Debt Financing: For solopreneurs avoiding debt, recommendations include leveraging zero-interest loan products (e.g., California Rebuilding Fund), crowdfunding, and county-level grant programs.
  • Equity Mandate: The SBA is explicitly directing staff to prioritize equity, ensuring that 96% of PPP loans in 2021 went to small businesses with 20 or fewer employees and focusing on rural and Low-to-Moderate Income (LMI) communities.