Milken Institute1h 1m
Solutions to Climate Change: A 10-Year Game Plan
Andrew Revkin, Noah Diffenbaugh, Bob Inglis, Qi Ye, Diane Regas, Pete Trelenberg, Andy Revkin, Carolyn Jungermann, Paul Telles, Amy Christensen
Conference Presentation, Panel, Fireside Chat
Scientific Trends and Observations (1988–2018):
- 1988 marked a pivotal year for climate discourse: Jim Hansen testified before Congress, Yellowstone wildfires occurred, and CO2 levels were 350 ppm for the last time in recent history.
- Peter Glick's 1988 projections regarding California water resources were accurate: warming has shifted water systems from snowpack-dominated to liquid-dominated, causing earlier melt and winter flooding.
- Warming in California has doubled the probability of drought years by increasing the frequency of warm temperatures coinciding with low precipitation.
- Analysis of record-setting heat events shows global warming influences more than 80% of surface areas with reliable data for hottest events.
- Extreme wet and dry events are influenced by global warming in approximately 50% of monitored surface areas.
- The U.S. has experienced over 80 climate and weather disasters in the last decade costing at least $1 billion each, totaling hundreds of billions in damages.
Global Energy Challenges and Demographics:
- Three primary global challenges for the next decade: doubling total energy supply, increasing energy access for billions, and decarbonizing the energy system to meet the Paris Agreement.
- The global population will add three billion more middle-class consumers by 2040 (increasing from 2 billion to 5 billion), primarily in China, India, and the developing world.
- Natural gas offers a transitional solution with 60% lower CO2 emissions compared to coal for electricity generation.
- Global energy efficiency has improved by ~1% annually since 1970; doubling or tripling this rate is required to meet future demands.
- Switching from primitive biomass cooking to clean fuels like LPG could address major global health issues while reducing emissions.
Policy Proposals and Political Strategy:
- Bob Inglis (republicen.org) advocates for a revenue-neutral, border-adjustable carbon tax to "internalize negative externalities" and appeal to conservative values.
- The border-adjustable tax is designed to incentivize global markets to adopt similar carbon pricing, using U.S. market access as leverage without UN dependency.
- Inglis identifies a potential collision between populism and conservatism, suggesting conservatives must overcome an "inferiority complex" regarding climate policy by leading with market-based solutions.
- Ye Qi (Brookings, Beijing) notes China is already leading via the world's largest carbon market (covering 5 billion tons of CO2 by end of 2017), though a carbon tax remains a potential alternative.
- China and the U.S. have ongoing R&D cooperation on clean coal, building efficiency, and the water-energy nexus since 2009, contributing to China's emissions peak in 2015.
- Dianne Regas (Environmental Defense Fund) emphasizes that while cap-and-trade is preferred, policies must reward innovation; California's program has successfully driven down emissions at low cost.
Corporate and Industry Perspectives:
- ExxonMobil (Peter Trellenberg) argues that carbon capture and storage (CCS) is a cost-effective necessity at ~$100/ton, citing Norway's $80–$90/ton tax as a driver for its use.
- The oil and gas industry views CCS as essential for decarbonizing petrochemicals and aviation, which cannot be easily electrified due to energy density requirements.
- Biofuels research, specifically algae-based fuels, is highlighted as a scalable solution that avoids the food-water nexus by utilizing brackish or gray water.
- Peter Trellenberg notes that while industry focuses on middle-class markets, local entrepreneurship is best suited to develop distribution networks for energy access in the "bottom billion."
R&D, Investment, and Geopolitics:
- There is a bipartisan disinvestment in basic science R&D, historically targeted by "Golden Fleece" awards despite the long-term strategic necessity.
- China is investing over $100 billion annually in clean energy (36% of the world total), driving rapid deployment of EVs and solar, creating competitive pressure on U.S. industry.
- The Trump administration's 2016 campaign statement supported maintaining basic science funding even in tight budgets, though current administrative actions (e.g., NSF/EPA budget cuts) contradict this.
- Security concerns regarding climate change were highlighted by Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, though the administration currently downplays the social cost of carbon.
- Green public procurement is identified as an untapped resource in both the U.S. and China to accelerate innovation in battery and solar technologies.
Risk, Vulnerability, and Adaptation:
- Climate risk is defined by the intersection of physical hazard, exposure, and vulnerability; population growth and poverty are currently the main drivers of vulnerability.
- Adaptation (reducing vulnerability) is distinct from mitigation (emissions reduction) and can be addressed immediately, whereas emissions reductions take decades to show climatic effects.
- Sub-Saharan Africa faces "known unknowables" regarding wet/dry impacts, making vulnerability reduction via poverty alleviation a priority independent of emissions science certainty.
- The "Global Warming Paradox" describes the reality that increasing energy consumption (often via fossil fuels) is the most direct way for poor populations to reduce climate vulnerability.
Convergence and Consensus:
- The panel reached a >90% overlap on solutions: electrification, energy efficiency, market-based pricing (carbon tax/cap-and-trade), and technological innovation.
- Consensus exists that no single entity (government, NGO, or corporation) can solve the issue alone; a multi-stakeholder approach is required.
- There is agreement that the current climate crisis is not a solvable "pollution event" but an emergent, long-term issue integrated into public health, economics, and national security.