Conference Presentation, Panel
Stopping Alzheimer's: Personal, Economic and Policy Imperatives
Milken InstituteNeil de Crescenzo, Robert Hormats, Sue Siegel, George Vradenburg, Anne Whitaker, Cecilia Arradaza, Bob Hormats, Peggy Wallace, Michael Miller
Disease Prevalence and Impact
- Alzheimer's affects one American every 68 seconds; 1 in 9 people aged 65+ and 1 in 3 people aged 85+ develop the disease.
- Two-thirds of Alzheimer's patients are women, placing a disproportionate burden on female caregivers.
- The disease imposes costs estimated at $215 billion annually in the US and over $600 billion globally, equivalent to the 18th largest national economy.
- If managed as a sovereign entity, dementia care would rank as the world's largest economy by annual revenue.
- Without intervention, the disease is projected to drive sovereign debt risks and exacerbate entitlement costs for Social Security and Medicare.
Current Research and Development Barriers
- Since 1998, 104 medicines have been pursued for Alzheimer's, but only three have received approval, resulting in a failure rate of approximately 97%.
- Research is hindered by the absence of validated biomarkers or surrogate markers, forcing clinical trials to rely on subjective symptom progression rather than objective biological changes.
- Unlike cancer (tumor markers) or cardiovascular disease (LDL), Alzheimer's is often detected too late to prevent progression or effectively treat symptoms.
- Current funding allocation is disproportionately low; NIH spends ~$450 million annually on Alzheimer's compared to ~$6 billion for cancer and ~$3 billion for heart disease.
- Industry investment is stifled by misaligned incentives: the 10-14 years required for basic science and FDA approval leaves insufficient patent life for profitable returns.
Technological and Data-Driven Solutions
- GE and Oracle emphasize that the primary data challenge is not volume but the "variety and velocity" of data from billions of connected devices (projected to reach 40 billion by 2020).
- Early diagnosis is critical, as pathological changes in the brain often begin 15 to 20 years before clinical symptoms appear.
- The BRAIN Initiative ($100 million seed funding) aims to map brain anatomy and function to accelerate discovery of basic mechanisms.
- PCORI has allocated $68 million over 18 months to create a National Patient-Centered Clinical Research Network for generating real-world data.
- Global collaboration is essential, with emerging markets like China and India investing in capacity building and data infrastructure for neurodegenerative diseases.
Systemic and Policy Critiques
- The current academic system prioritizes publication speed over patient speed, with a typical 1-year lag between lab discovery and peer-reviewed publication.
- There is no federal long-term care policy reimbursing doctors for care planning or cognitive counseling for Alzheimer's patients.
- Regulatory hurdles and long time-to-market discourage venture capital, leading to a "gaping hole" in early-stage financing for neurodiagnostics.
- Current reimbursement models fail to cover non-pharmacological interventions, leaving patients with only symptomatic drug options and no care planning support.
Global and Economic Implications
- 80% of non-infectious diseases now occur in developing countries, making the global aging workforce a critical economic concern for nations like China and India.
- Preventing Alzheimer's could allow the elderly to remain productive in the workforce longer, enhancing economic output rather than relying on caregiving networks.
- "Innovation nationalism" in some countries (e.g., China, India) creates barriers to global data sharing and trial participation, potentially slowing overall progress.
- The disease represents a fiscal threat comparable to the historical polio crisis, requiring a shift from viewing it as a health issue to a sovereign economic challenge.
Actionable Recommendations and "To-Dos"
- Increase Funding: Scientists estimate a minimum of $2 billion annually is required to accelerate progress, a significant increase from the current $450-530 million.
- Public Awareness Campaigns: Panelists advocate for a national exposure campaign (similar to seat belt or "Silent Heart Disease" campaigns) to reduce stigma and mobilize public outcry.
- Patient Engagement: Shift from advocacy to education, encouraging patients to participate in clinical trials and adopt risk-reducing lifestyle changes (diet, exercise).
- Leverage Specific Demographics: Mobilize women (who comprise 2/3 of victims and caregivers) via the "Women Against Alzheimer's" network to influence policy.
- Cross-Sector Collaboration: Expand the CEO Initiative on Alzheimer's Disease to include government, academia, and venture capital in a "safe harbor" to develop biomarkers and flexible trial designs.
- Financial Innovation: Create new financial instruments (e.g., outcome-based bonds or public-private guarantees) to incentivize long-term investment in early-stage neuro-research.
- Global Advocacy: Lobby Treasury and Finance ministers globally to include Alzheimer's in sovereign debt and economic growth strategies.