Milken Institute1h 1m
The Case for Investing in Migrants and Refugees
Caroline Fairchild, Kerry Kennedy, Jeff Maggioncalda, Gideon Maltz, Saed Moujtahed, John Kluge
Panel, Conference Presentation
Current State of the Refugee Crisis
- Over 20 million people are currently forcibly displaced globally, with numbers escalating annually.
- Significant displacement flows have been recorded from Syria, Burma, South Sudan, and Venezuela in the last year.
- Approximately 50% of displaced persons face long-term displacement, often exceeding 20 years or one generation.
- Nearly 90% of the world's refugees reside in middle and lower-income countries, despite these nations hosting 60% of the population while holding less than 3% of global GDP.
- Syria represents the largest contemporary refugee crisis, though the US government was criticized for lacking preparation regarding financial aid and integration support.
- The Syrian-American community has absorbed a significant portion of the burden, providing essential services like driver's licenses and language training where government aid is insufficient.
Root Causes and Political Context
- Kerry Kennedy (RFK Human Rights) attributes refugee flows in the Middle East to US-led regime change efforts in Syria, Iraq, and Libya, which fueled conflict and destabilized regions.
- Kennedy links Central American refugee flows to US historical backing of military regimes in the 1980s, which fostered gang violence and drug trafficking cycles.
- Saeed Mujtahed (Syrian Institute for Progress) disputes the narrative that US interference caused the Syrian crisis, characterizing it instead as a homegrown, peaceful movement against a dictatorship that was abandoned by the Obama administration.
- Gideon Maltz (Tent Foundation) argues that while US interference has caused displacement, inaction in Syria was equally contributory, noting the government failed to act sufficiently.
- Mujtahed highlights that current US financial aid for Syrian refugees is inadequate, often covering less than the rent costs, forcing reliance on community support.
Private Sector and Educational Solutions
- Coursera (Jeff Maggioncalda) offers 40,000+ free enrollments for refugees via nonprofit partners, utilizing a platform with 31 million global users and 2,600 courses from 150 universities.
- Google partners with Coursera to provide a $49/month IT certification program that includes hiring partnerships with 150,000 open US positions and 450,000 in Latin America.
- The Tent Foundation mobilizes businesses to move beyond philanthropy, focusing on impact investing, tailored commercial services, and refugee hiring within supply chains.
- Starbucks has committed to hiring 10,000 refugees over five years, while WeWork aims to hire 1,500 refugees in the US and Europe.
- Chobani employs refugees for 30% of its workforce, citing high retention and productivity rates.
- Tent Foundation studies indicate refugees exhibit significantly lower turnover rates and higher loan repayment rates compared to non-refugees.
- The Syrian Institute focuses on overcoming language and cultural barriers, currently assisting 3,000 Kuwaiti students in connecting with refugees to facilitate fundraising and micro-loans via the World Bank.
- Mujtahed notes that 28% of Syrian refugees entering the US hold a Bachelor's degree or higher, challenging stereotypes regarding skill levels.
Systemic Challenges and Integration
- Credential recognition remains a primary barrier, as refugees often lack access to official transcripts or degrees due to destroyed institutions in their home countries.
- Administrative hurdles prevent refugees from establishing credit, securing loans, or signing leases, often requiring complex documentation processes managed by NGOs and community groups.
- Saeed Mujtahed reports that initial settlement often consumes six to twelve months solely on administrative paperwork, delaying economic entry.
- Refugees in the US pay significantly higher rents due to a lack of credit history, exacerbating financial strain despite receiving minimal government allowances ($700-$800/month).
- In the UK, integration outcomes are described as worse than in the US due to a welfare-driven model that prioritizes housing over immediate workforce integration.
- Technological solutions like blockchain and iris recognition are being deployed in camps like Zaatari in Jordan to manage identities and distribute aid without physical documentation.
Economic Impact and Future Outlook
- Research cited by the panel indicates that $1 invested in refugee support yields $2 back within a five-year period in the US economy.
- Historical analysis shows positive economic contributions from previous refugee waves, including Hungarian, Vietnamese, and Soviet refugees.
- Jeff Maggioncalda predicts a convergence of education and work, where digital credentials allow individuals to upskill remotely and access global job markets regardless of location.
- Gideon Maltz states that every major business has an operational opportunity to engage with refugees through supply chains, investment, or hiring.
- The panel advocates for increased capital investment in refugee-hosting countries (e.g., Jordan, Turkey, Ethiopia) rather than solely focusing on resettlement in the Global North.
- Mujtahed emphasizes the potential for refugees to introduce cultural industries, such as Damascus furniture making, to US markets.
- Panelists call for political action to support the US resettlement program, repeal travel bans, and restore funding to the UN refugee compact.