Milken Institute1h 28m
The Global Economy: A Conversation With Timothy Geithner, Henry Paulson and Robert Rubin
Timothy Geithner, Henry Paulson, Robert Rubin, Sheryl Sandberg, Eric Garcetti, Bob Rubin, Hank Paulson, Tim Geithner
Conference Presentation, Panel, Statement
Conference Attendance & Demographics
- As of 10 a.m., 2,700 credentials were issued; total attendance reached approximately 3,500 participants representing 55 countries and 41 U.S. states.
- Non-U.S. attendance increased by over 20% compared to the previous year.
- The conference achieved its goal of approximately 30% female speakers and 30% female attendees.
- Approximately 700 panelists participated, with nearly 80% being new speakers for the year.
Los Angeles Context (Mayor Eric Garcetti)
- Los Angeles is described as having 39 countries with their largest population outside the home country, over 220 languages, and 115 countries of origin.
- The city is currently constructing five new rail lines as part of the largest public works program in the U.S.
- Innovation highlights include stem cell research for blindness/AIDS/heart disease, SpaceX public-private partnerships, and Uber-style logistics at the port.
- A new international terminal and eight additional terminals are under development; the port operates at a rate of one million dollars per day.
Milken Institute Operations
- The Institute operates eight centers producing data-driven research and policy initiatives.
- The 2014 "Best Cities for Successful Aging" report ranked 352 U.S. metros.
- Underwriter Guggenheim Partners and multiple Platinum, Gold, Silver, and Bronze sponsors provided financial support.
- The institute's core philosophy is based on founder Michael Milken's formula: Prosperity = Human Capital + Social Capital + Financial Capital.
U.S. Economic Outlook (Panel: Bob Rubin, Hank Paulson, Tim Geithner)
- Growth Trajectory: The consensus is a continuation of a "gradual, slow, and steady recovery" averaging roughly 2% growth since late 2009, though median real wages remain stagnant.
- Labor Market: The official unemployment rate is viewed as substantially underestimating the true unemployment rate; the goal is to bring more talent back into the labor force through sustained growth.
- Tail Risks: Significant unpriced risks include geopolitical instability, the "reaching for yield" in financial markets, and the potential for technology/AI to be labor-displacing despite productivity gains.
- Inequality: Income disparity is driven by the digital revolution and globalization, which are "routinizing" middle-income jobs; this is identified as a critical threat to democratic function.
- Political Dysfunction: All three panelists agreed that the primary barrier to solving economic challenges is the inability of the U.S. political system to engage in principled, pragmatic compromise.
- Entitlement Reform: There is broad agreement on the unsustainability of current entitlement systems, but a lack of political will to address them preemptively.
Global Economic Leadership & China
- U.S. Position: The panelists noted a "profound erosion" of support in both major parties for the global institutions the U.S. built post-WWII, weakening its ability to project economic power.
- China Relationship: The relationship is described as a mix of formidable competition and essential partnership; failure to cooperate on transnational issues (climate, pandemics, denuclearization) is deemed impossible to solve alone.
- Debt & Trade: China's ownership of U.S. debt is viewed as less of a threat than the U.S.'s own high debt levels; the panel strongly supports completing the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) and Bilateral Investment Treaty.
- China's Economic Shift: China's economic model is running out of gas, facing structural flaws, and slowing growth, requiring its own reforms to municipal debt and investment models.
Women in the Economy
- Impact: The IMF reports that equalizing female labor force participation would increase U.S. GDP by 5%, Japan by 9%, and Egypt by 34%.
- Barriers: The "leaky pipeline" is attributed to intense work expectations (10-12 hour days) clashing with social norms regarding childcare, rather than a lack of qualification at entry levels.
- Solutions:
- Bob Rubin advocates for early-career support and ensuring women have opportunities to remain in the workforce.
- Hank Paulson argues that CEOs must actively "put a finger on the scale" to counteract unconscious bias, suggesting that without proactive measures, quotas may become legally necessary.
- Tim Geithner highlighted the complexity of changing social norms and noted that while flexible hours exist, the demand for constant availability remains a major hurdle.
Climate Change
- Consensus: Viewed by the panelists as an existential threat and a desperate, long-term problem that requires immediate action to avoid catastrophic fiscal costs.
- Strategy: Bob Rubin and Hank Paulson advocate for a price on carbon and a policy framework encouraging non-carbon energy; they cite the "Risky Business" study which uses bipartisan risk analysis to highlight economic impacts.
- Political Approach: Framing the issue as an economic risk (avoiding disaster costs) is seen as more effective than debating the cause, which remains polarized.
Lightning Round Key Takeaways
- Unilateral Policy Change:
- Paulson: Fix the entitlement system to save the future.
- Geithner: Fiscal policy measures that make government work effectively.
- Rubin: Encourage more Americans to work for their country.
- Future Outlook:
- Fed Rate Hikes: Likely to occur "when they think it makes sense" or "early next year."
- Biggest Competitor: All three agreed the U.S.'s biggest competitor is "Ourselves" (due to domestic dysfunction).
- 2016 Campaign Issue: Income disparity and stagnant median real wages.
- Technology & Habits:
- Favorite Tech: Hank Paulson prefers a ballpoint pen; others listed the iPad and BlackBerry.
- Relaxation: Fishing is the primary relaxation method for all three panelists.
- Books:
- Paulson: Dealing with China.
- Rubin: The Last Living Eunuch in China and Political Education.
- Geithner: Innovators by Walter Isaacson.
- Unilateral Policy Change: