newsfilter
← Interviews
Milken Institute58 min

The Known Unknowns of Election 2020

Sarah Sandler, Willow Bay, Jim Messina, Mark Penn, Karl Rove, Neera Tanden

Conference Presentation, Panel, Fireside Chat

Global Political Trends and Context

  • The rise of anti-establishment parties is a global phenomenon driven by economic anxiety, occurring in France (Macron), Mexico (AMLO), and Italy (Five Stars).
  • Unlike other nations, the U.S. two-party system prevents the rise of new third parties, though internal party fragmentation mirrors global trends.
  • Populist movements in Europe (e.g., National Front in France, League in Italy) are unified by opposition to immigration and a focus on national sovereignty.
  • Economic anger and cultural issues, including race and immigration, are the primary drivers behind the fragmentation of the political center in the U.S. and abroad.
  • Macron's victory in France is attributed to articulating a distinct vision of change that countered the "old" establishment, a strategy panelists suggest is necessary for Democrats.

Demographic Shifts and Voter Psychology

  • The electorate is approaching a "40-40-20" split (or 45-45-9-10 per one panelist), where 10-20% are true swing voters and 8-9% are persuadable moderates.
  • The U.S. population is aging; voters over 60 now outnumber the 18-29 demographic, making older voters critical to election outcomes.
  • Gen Z is 500% more politically active than their parents' generation, utilizing social media and peer networks to engage in politics.
  • Voter behavior is increasingly driven by state-level demographic shifts: states like Ohio are becoming older and less favorable to Democrats, while Nevada and Colorado are becoming younger and more diverse.
  • The average American voter processes political information for approximately 4 minutes per week, with economic well-being ("Who will make my kids' lives better?") being the dominant concern.

2020 Election Strategy and Dynamics

  • The 2020 election requires a dual strategy of voter persuasion and base turnout; relying on one or the other guarantees defeat.
  • Donald Trump's re-election challenge stems from a 2-to-1 disadvantage: nearly twice as many people do not support him as do, forcing him to run a persuasion campaign rather than a pure base mobilization.
  • Trump's core vulnerability is a massive gap between his performance approval (57%) and his personal likability (29%).
  • Suburban women, who Trump lost in 2016, are a key demographic; issues like healthcare and pre-existing conditions have driven these voters away from Trump.
  • Working-class voters, particularly those Trump bonded with in 2016, remain a volatile group; his current immigration rhetoric may fail to retain them compared to his previous economic populism.
  • The panel agrees that a candidate must "disqualify" the opponent to win, but also must present a disciplined vision for the future to secure the middle.
  • Trump's reliance on social media and "madman" tactics creates a unique challenge for opponents, who must balance condemning his character while avoiding being distracted from economic messaging.

The Democratic Primary Landscape

  • The Democratic primary is projected to be highly fluid, with no early consensus candidate, leading to a potentially contested convention.
  • Rule changes have altered the primary: the process is now more front-loaded, with 48% of delegates allocated in the first five weeks, and the use of superdelegates on the first ballot has been removed.
  • The reduction of caucus states from 11 to 3 is expected to shift the electorate toward more moderate voters in open primaries.
  • 61% of Democrats prioritize "electability" over ideological purity, viewing defeating Trump as the single most important issue.
  • The panel predicts a likely scenario where Joe Biden finishes first, Bernie Sanders second, and other candidates like Kamala Harris or Pete Buttigieg split the remaining delegates, with no single candidate securing a majority initially.
  • Unlike 2016, where establishment candidates failed to stop a populist phenomenon early, the Democratic Party may now face internal conflict between candidates focusing on electability versus those focusing on progressive activism.
  • There is a potential "voter penalty" for negativity in the Democratic primary, as voters are sensitive to attacks that could damage a nominee's ability to unify the country.
  • The "character" issue for Democrats centers on a candidate who can unite the country, reject bullying, and oppose the divisive rhetoric associated with the current administration.
  • Most Democratic candidates are not actively supporting impeachment, recognizing that the focus on investigations energizes Republicans but alienates independents who feel the matter is "over."
  • The panel concludes that the ultimate barrier to winning is not just policy disagreements but a pervasive decline in trust in all government institutions (Congress, Presidency, parties), with only the military and law enforcement retaining public respect.