Milken Institute1h 1m
U.S. Cities Leading the Way
Josh Terengel, Walter Robb, Kathy Wilde, Gavin Newsom, Tony Hsieh, Andy Cohn
Panel, Conference Presentation
Federal Constraints and the Rise of Local Innovation
- Shift in Governance Paradigm:
- U.S. cities are increasingly acting as "laboratories of innovation" due to federal gridlock and a lack of federal funding.
- Leadership has shifted from "command and control" (top-down) to "platform thinking" (bottom-up), focusing on cultivating conditions for entrepreneurship rather than dispensing resources.
- The industrial economy is described as "running out of steam," necessitating a move toward bottom-up, pragmatic, and proximity-based economic growth.
- Gavin Newsom noted a bipartisan shift where both Democratic and Republican mayors prioritize economic pragmatism over ideology at the local level.
- Federal Funding Gaps:
- U.S. cities are currently competing against global cities that benefit from full support from their national governments regarding immigration, infrastructure, and job creation.
- R&D Funding: The U.S. has lost approximately 20% of federal R&D funding in the last two years, impacting biotech and tech sectors in major cities.
- Immigration Policy: Restrictive federal immigration policies are cited as a primary bottleneck for New York City, where 8.4 million people are growing solely through international immigration rather than domestic migration.
- Transportation: While a $304 billion transportation reauthorization bill was proposed, it explicitly admits that federal funding cannot cover all infrastructure needs.
Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) and Economic Models
- New York City Case Study:
- Under Mayor Bloomberg (12 years), public-private partnerships helped New York achieve a $616 billion annual economic output, ranking it as the second-largest city economy in the world after Tokyo.
- These partnerships successfully diversified the economy, accelerating growth in tech, creative, and tourism sectors.
- The Foundation for New York City, originally founded by David Rockefeller, was reactivated to align business interests with city needs after the urban decline of the 1970s.
- Transit-Oriented Development:
- Denver's Union Station project is highlighted as a successful macro-scale PPP using transit-oriented design to revitalize mixed-use, walkable downtowns.
- Local infrastructure banks in Chicago and California are emerging as mechanisms to fund PPPs independently of federal largesse.
- Whole Foods in Detroit:
- Whole Foods invested $12 million in Detroit, creating 130 jobs and engaging 45 new local suppliers.
- The partnership required a year of community dialogue before the decision to invest, overcoming deep-seated community mistrust regarding corporate promises.
- Detroit store metrics show 7x the company average in food stamp usage, indicating success in serving the diverse local population without displacing long-term residents.
- The model included sharing physical space with non-profits (e.g., Liberty's Kitchen) and integrating non-profit/for-profit entities within the same building.
The Downtown Project (Las Vegas)
- Scale and Funding:
- Tony Hsieh and Zappos co-founders invested $350 million of personal funds into the "Downtown Project" to revitalize downtown Las Vegas.
- Budget Allocation:
- $50 million for small business neighborhood building.
- $50 million for tech startup companies.
- $50 million for arts, music, education, and healthcare.
- Remaining capital allocated to real estate.
- Operational Philosophy:
- Return on Community (ROC): The project prioritizes long-term "Return on Community" and "Return on Collisions" over short-term financial ROI.
- Collision Metrics: A specific target of 100,000 collisional hours per acre per year (approx. 2.3 hours per square foot) is tracked to measure serendipitous interaction between diverse industries.
- Five Core Principles: Investments are vetted based on collisions, co-learning, connectedness, diversity, and density.
- Success Stories:
- A local coffee shop owner who planned to leave Las Vegas was funded to open a breakfast/lunch spot; the business paid back the full investment in one year and is now projecting triple its initial growth.
- The "Container Park" in downtown Las Vegas, a small business incubator and family destination, attracted 500,000 visitors in six months, transforming a previously unsafe area into a community hub.
Challenges: Gentrification and Equity
- The Gentrification Paradox:
- Economic revitalization (e.g., Whole Foods in Detroit, tech booms in San Francisco) often leads to the displacement of long-time, low-income residents.
- San Francisco faces intense "gentrification" friction, including protests against tech company shuttles and high minimum wage debates.
- Policy Limitations: Existing measures like rent control, the highest state minimum wage, and paid sick leave are insufficient to counteract the "fire hose" of tech prosperity driving displacement.
- Affordable Housing Solutions:
- New York City: The city has nearly 500,000 residents in federally subsidized public housing; a goal to add 200,000 additional affordable housing units has been announced.
- Fiscal Constraints: Local budgets (e.g., NYC's $78 billion budget) are heavily burdened by pension and labor costs for municipal employees, leaving limited resources for affordable housing without federal support.
- Tech Sector Responsibility: Marc Benioff (Salesforce) halted a defensive PR campaign by the tech sector, urging companies to move beyond token philanthropy to substantive stewardship and integration with community needs.
Emerging Trends and Global Context
- Foreign Direct Investment:
- Global investors (China, Russia, Germany, Abu Dhabi) view U.S. cities as safe havens amidst currency volatility in their home countries.
- China: Investors like Greenland Group are undertaking massive projects (e.g., a 3 million sq. ft. development in downtown L.A.), though this is primarily "offshoring money" rather than replicating China's "new city" development model.
- Urban Agriculture:
- Cities like Detroit and Chicago have revised zoning to allow urban agriculture as a permitted use, creating a "generation two" of commercial food production.
- Detroit: Now hosts approximately 1,600 community gardens, with 100 operating as market gardens.
- Chicago: "Urban ag districts" are evolving into entrepreneurial hubs for value-added food products, with organizations like Growing Home training 350 adults for private sector placement.
Panelists' Favorite Cities ( exemplifying discussed values)
- Andy Cohn (Gensler): Austin, Texas – Cited for mixed-use development, walkability, strong university ties, and leadership.
- Tony Hsieh (Downtown Project): Downtown Las Vegas – Specifically the Container Park, representing the transformation from an unsafe area to a family-friendly incubator.
- Gavin Newsom: San Francisco – Valued for its natural assets and resilience, despite ongoing gentrification challenges.
- Walter Robb (Whole Foods): Brooklyn, New York – Praised for its inclusivity and successful rebranding while maintaining ethnic diversity.
- Kathy Wilde (NYC Foundation): Detroit – Chosen for its intense community dialogue, diversity, and the transformative power of public-private investment.