What superforecasters and experts think about existential risks | Ezra Karger
The Forecasting Research Institute conducted a multi-stage tournament and adversarial collaboration involving over 200 experts, superforecasters, and skeptics to quantify existential risks, revealing that while both groups agree advanced AI will emerge by the mid-21st century, they diverge sharply on extinction probabilities with domain experts estimating a 3% risk compared to 0.38% for superforecasters. Follow-up studies on AI risk perception determined that long-term worldview differences and expectations regarding human well-being rather than short-term capabilities drive these disagreements, resulting in minimal belief convergence during eight weeks of structured debate. The findings suggest that public risk estimates are highly sensitive to reference class framing and highlight independent verification of AI's ability to evade deactivation as the critical crux needed for consensus on catastrophic outcomes.