Milken Institute1h 0m
Are eSports Ready for the Big Time?
Anne Hand, Jack Etienne, Rick Fox, Peter Levin, Bruce Stein, Peter Vlastelica, Clinton Foy, Monkey Man
Panel, Fireside Chat
Panelists and Entities:
- Anne Hand: CEO of Super League Gaming (establishes feeder systems for amateur gamers).
- Jack Etienne: CEO/Founder of Cloud9 (operates for ~5 years).
- Rick Fox: NBA champion (3x), Founding Partner of Echo Fox and Vision Venture Partners.
- Peter Levin: President of Lionsgate Interactive Venture and Games; Owner of The Immortals.
- Bruce Stein: CEO/Co-founder of Axiomatic Sports; Owner of Team Liquid.
- Peter Vlastelica: President/CEO of Major League Gaming (MLG), a division of Activision.
Market Growth and Investment Horizons:
- Esports audiences are young, hungry, and growing, requiring a long-term investment horizon of 5+ years to realize returns.
- Jack Etienne advises investors to expect no immediate returns; the focus must be on building brands and fan bases for the future.
- Peter Levin describes the market as being in the "first inning of a baseball game" with massive upside for marketer-driven engagement.
- Peter Vlastelica notes that 22% of the one billion male millennials watch esports, highlighting the scale of the demographic.
Monetization and Business Model Shifts:
- Current esports lacks local revenue opportunities (ticket sales, local sponsorship, merchandise) compared to traditional sports like the MLS.
- Traditional sports leagues share global media rights and sponsorship revenue with owners; current esports structures often leave teams with only jersey sponsorships and prize pools.
- The Overwatch League introduces a franchise model with permanent, city-based, territorially exclusive rights to unlock local revenue streams and global media rights sharing.
- Peter Vlastelica argues against imposing traditional sports structures entirely, advocating for a blend that preserves the grassroots nature while adding necessary structure (e.g., preventing the "overgrown garden" chaos seen in boxing).
- Bruce Stein notes that esports is a "cultural shift" and digital-native experience, requiring unique engagement strategies beyond traditional licensing.
League Structures and Franchises:
- The Overwatch League (announced late 2016 for 2017 launch) aims to be the first global city-based league (e.g., Shanghai vs. Houston).
- This model replaces the "relegation" system used by Riot Games (LCS), guaranteeing franchise owners a spot in the league regardless of performance (barring misconduct).
- Peter Levin observes that while capital is available, the focus is now on forensic analysis of which business models and ownership structures will succeed.
- Rick Fox predicts other publishers will follow the Overwatch franchise path as the industry moves toward institutionalization.
Content, Broadcast, and Distribution:
- Peter Vlastelica states the goal is not dependent on TV; esports is a digital-first sport with advantages over traditional sports trapped behind paywalls (NFL fans averaging 43-49 years old vs. esports fans 16-30).
- Vision Venture Partners and Twin Galaxies partnered with the CW for an H1Z1 event that matched NHL ratings, demonstrating TV's potential as a marketing halo for digital-native audiences.
- Lionsgate (Lionsgate Interactive) is creating competitive formats with ESL and Pilgrim Entertainment, leveraging their unscripted reality production expertise.
- Bruce Stein highlights the "interactive" nature of the audience (90% are players) as a key differentiator for content engagement compared to passive sports viewers.
Sponsorship and Brand Integration:
- Effective sponsorship requires authenticity; fans detect "in-your-face" advertising and prefer subtle, content-driven integrations.
- Example: Axe sponsored Cloud9 and TSM to create a player-versus-player event (Bjergsen vs. Sneaky) that organically trended on Reddit without paid promotion.
- Jack Etienne leveraged his background at Crunchyroll (100% demographic overlap with esports) to drive early profitability for Cloud9.
- Bruce Stein argues against "label slap" traditional licensing, advocating for niche, interactive gaming applications that fit specific demographic lifestyles.
Talent Development and Player Careers:
- Player Education: Teams are acting as educators, teaching young pros life skills and professional conduct as careers transition from hobbies to full-time jobs.
- Recruitment: Analytics and data (leaderboards) are critical for identifying talent; Twin Galaxies helps adjudicate skills, while platforms like Twitch allow scouting of "rising stars."
- Career Longevity: The stereotype of players retiring by 25 is fading; with sustainable revenue, players (e.g., in Dota 2) are competing into their 30s and 40s, bringing stability and leadership.
- Super League Gaming: Provides a "little league/minor league" feeder system (AAU-style) for young gamers to develop skills, character, and emotional intelligence before joining pro leagues.
- College Esports: Over 20 universities in the US now offer League of Legends scholarships, validating the sector as a pathway for "intellectual athletes" with STEAM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, Math) expertise.
Community and Cultural Shifts:
- Rick Fox emphasizes the importance of storytelling to humanize players and provide blueprints for aspiring athletes.
- Peter Levin notes the "fraternal" nature of the early industry, where owners and teams share information freely to build the ecosystem.
- Jack Etienne highlights a unique fan-to-player connection: stars stream for 170+ hours/month, allowing direct interaction and sponsor recommendations that drive high conversion.
- Peter Vlastelica identifies a shift from "gamer stigma" to celebration of the demographic, with parents recognizing competitive traits in their children.
Future Outlook:
- Format Evolution: Industry leaders are experimenting with formats (mobile, console, PC) to find "soft landings" for broader, non-hardcore audiences without alienating the core.
- Consumer Products: Bruce Stein and Lionsgate are exploring R&D for new consumer products beyond endemic goods (mice, keyboards) to create authentic lifestyle integration.
- Stability: The industry is moving from a "wild west" to a structured ecosystem where owners secure long-term value through franchises, media rights, and local monetization.