Milken Institute58 min
Disrupting Food: Alternative Proteins Leading to a More Sustainable Future
Cristina Alesci, Ethan Brown, Jeremy Coller, Uma Valeti, David Levinson, David Rockefeller Jr., Lance Price, Jenny Santee, Jonathan Smiga, Ashley
Panel, Fireside Chat
Panel Composition and Company Mandates
- Ethan Brown (Beyond Meat): CEO and founder focused on building meat directly from plants; products are sold in 1,100 U.S. stores, including placement in the meat aisle at Whole Foods.
- Uma Valenti (Memphis Meats): CEO and co-founder of the world's leading "clean meat" company, producing animal meat from cells without raising animals; recently released chicken, duck, and beef grown from cells.
- Jeremy Collar (Collar Capital): Chief Investment Officer with $17 billion AUM; launched FAIR to bring animal factory farming to the ESG agenda; firm has invested in ~1,600 private companies.
The Problem: Traditional Animal Agriculture
- Health Risks: Consumption of animal protein is linked to heart disease, diabetes, and cancer; WHO and Harvard studies categorize processed meat similarly to cigarette smoking.
- Climate Impact: A study by World Bank scientists (Goodland and Anang) attributes 51% of global greenhouse gas emissions to livestock, including 14% from animal respiration (methane/CO2).
- Resource Efficiency: Animal protein is inefficient; it takes six kilograms of plant protein to produce one kilogram of animal protein; 80% of arable land is used for animal feed.
- Environmental Destruction: 91% of Amazonian deforestation is driven by livestock production and feed crop cultivation; livestock is the number one user of freshwater globally.
- Animal Welfare: Approximately 66 billion animals are slaughtered annually; factory farming relies on confinement and hormone treatments.
- Antibiotic Resistance: 80% of all antibiotics in the U.S. are used on animals (prophylactic and growth promotion), with colistin (a last-resort human antibiotic) becoming resistant due to agricultural use.
Technology and Production Challenges
- Beyond Meat Strategy: Uses material science (heating, cooling, pressure) to restructure plant proteins (amino acids, lipids) into muscle-like architecture; avoids GMOs to ensure consumer safety perception.
- Memphis Meats Strategy: Recultivates animal cells in clean, controlled environments to replicate the exact taste and texture of meat evolved through nature; production cycles last 3–4 weeks per harvest.
- Cost Trajectory (Memphis Meats):
- Started at >$1,000,000 per pound.
- Dropped to ~$18,000 per pound a few years ago.
- Currently at ~$6,000 per pound, decreasing by $1,000 monthly.
- Comparable to the iPhone cost curve, where initial production costs were $3.4 billion and dropped to affordable levels.
- Supply Chain Constraints: Most farmers grow commodity crops (corn, soy) for livestock; the industry needs to shift toward growing high-protein legumes (fava, lupin, mustard seed) directly for human consumption.
Consumer Adoption and Market Dynamics
- Taste Acceptance:
- Memphis Meats demonstrated "magical moments" where independent reporters (Wall Street Journal) tasted their duck and declared it "delicious" within 90 seconds.
- Beyond Meat achieved 10x higher sales velocity when placed in the standard meat aisle compared to the "penalty box" alternative section.
- Consumer Psychology: Most consumers want meat, not necessarily meat from animals; the barrier is often the process, not the product itself.
- Future Product Goals:
- Memphis Meats: Aims to create 3D textures resembling steaks and bone-in cuts; currently focusing on boneless products which represent $220B of the $250B U.S. meat market.
- Beyond Meat: Acknowledges current products are "good but not great"; aims to be indistinguishable from animal meat and eventually lower-cost.
- Taste Acceptance:
Investment Risks and Opportunities
- Stranded Asset Risk: Factory farms are predicted to become stranded assets like coal due to unsustainability, regulatory bans (e.g., Jerry Brown banning prophylactic antibiotics), and consumer pressure.
- Market Volatility:
- Yum! Brands (KFC, Pizza Hut): Underperformed public markets due to food safety epidemics and avian flu.
- Hallmark-Westland: Faced a $116 million recall cost for 65 million kilos of meat due to animal welfare issues exposed by an investigative report.
- BRF & JBS (Brazil): Lost $2 billion in market cap recently due to "rotten meat" scandals; blocked from U.S. IPOs.
- Shake Shack: Outperformed Yum! Brands by adapting to safer supply chains.
- Investment Criteria: Focus on founder passion, scalable cost curves, and a "pull" market demand rather than a "push" strategy.
Competitive Dynamics and Industry Reaction
- ** Tyson:** Took a 5% investment in Beyond Meat; shifting positioning to be a "protein company" rather than just a meat company.
- Collaborative View: Both companies view each other as allies in a non-zero-sum game; both anticipate a future where consumers choose between plant-based and clean-grown meat based on personal preference.
- Large Meat Producers: Major manufacturers (e.g., Barilla, unnamed spaghetti giant) are inquiring about the technology to avoid being in the slaughterhouse/feedlot business indefinitely.
- Restaurant Sector: Companies like Compass Group and Hellmann's are switching to plant-based alternatives to mitigate food safety risks (e.g., salmonella, avian flu).
Specific Technical Questions and Responses
- Antibiotic Use in Cell Culture: Memphis Meats does not rely on routine antibiotics in clean production environments; while small batches in testing facilities may use them for containment, scaling up to GMP standards will eliminate the need.
- Nutritional Profile: Beyond Meat's products have no cholesterol, half the saturated fat of beef, and no insulin-like growth factors; sodium levels are currently high due to seasoning but are being optimized.
- Digestive Gases: Beyond Meat uses pea protein, which avoids the flatulence issues associated with soy-based products.
- Seafood Applications: Memphis Meats is developing cell-cultured fish (tuna, mahi-mahi) to address overfishing and the inefficiency of feeding fish meal to land animals.
- GMO Concerns: Beyond Meat explicitly rejected GMO technology to maintain a non-controversial, simple ingredient list.
Forward-Looking Statements and Predictions
- Factory Farming End: Factory farms will become obsolete as regulations tighten and costs rise; the "meat lobby" resistance is being overcome by investor pressure via ESG funds ($2.25 trillion committed).
- Cost Parity: Both companies believe they can reach cost parity with animal protein; plant-based meat is projected to be cheaper due to the elimination of the animal "middleman."
- Dietary Shifts: The transition will involve eating less meat overall but of higher quality; the developing world will adopt these technologies to raise living standards without the resource burden of traditional farming.
- Market Expansion: Demand is latent and growing; every incremental improvement in product quality welcomes hundreds of thousands of new consumers.