All-In Podcast3h 0m
E11: Election Night Special featuring Phil Hellmuth, Bill Gurley, Brad Gerstner & more!
Phil Hellmuth, Bill Gurley, Brad Gerstner, Chamath, Michael Newman, Jon Cohen, Pete Buttigieg, Joe Biden, Jason Calacanis, David Friedberg, David Sacks
Fireside Chat, Interview, Other
Election Night Dynamics and Market Reversal
- Betting Market Flip: Betting odds shifted violently within hours, moving from Biden being a 5-to-2 favorite three months prior to Donald Trump becoming a 3-to-1 favorite late in the night.
- Trump moved from -1.25 (favorite) to +600 (underdog) briefly before flipping to minus 600 (heavy favorite) on Bovada.
- Phil Hellmuth notes betting markets have been in Biden's favor for three straight months before the sudden reversal.
- Market Reaction: Financial markets rallied significantly on expectations of a Trump victory or a divided government, pricing in stability and lower tax risk.
- NASDAQ futures rose 350 basis points; S&P 500 futures fell initially then reversed to rise.
- The US Dollar strengthened ("rippes"), Treasury yields fell, and the Euro/Dollar pair dropped sharply, indicating pro-Trump sentiment.
- Investors reacted positively to the potential for corporate tax cuts to remain in place, avoiding a "blue wave" mandate for tax reform.
- Media vs. Data Discrepancy: Major news networks (CNN, NBC) initially projected Biden leads that contradicted real-time betting markets and early reporting data.
- The host notes networks are "useless" for real-time analysis, with CNN still showing Biden ahead even as markets priced in a Trump win.
- Fox News called Florida for Trump early, while the New York Times initially showed Trump at 95% to lose Florida before correcting.
State-by-State Analysis and Critical Path to Victory
- Florida: Projected as a secure win for Trump; a "home free" state that was removed from the path to victory for Biden.
- Biden lost the state by roughly 300,000 to 400,000 votes, driven by retiree turnout and tax concerns.
- Early vote counting (dumped in a pile) favored Democrats, but election-day voting shifted the lead heavily to Trump.
- Ohio: Trump won decisively after an early "blue mirage" of Democratic gains due to mail-in ballots; Biden's early lead evaporated as election-day counts came in.
- Final tallies showed Trump with ~2.4 million votes to Biden's 2.2 million.
- North Carolina: Extremely close race with Trump leading by a narrow margin (approx. 1,000 to 10,000 votes depending on the source/time) with ~63% to 95% of precincts reporting.
- A margin of less than 1% would trigger an automatic recount.
- Trump holds the state in most real-time data, though some early reports showed Biden ahead by 9,000 votes.
- Pennsylvania: The most critical swing state, with Trump leading by ~370,000 votes with only 12% of mail-in ballots counted.
- 2.2 million mail-in ballots remain outstanding; Philadelphia alone has 1,706 precincts with 95% not yet reporting.
- If historical Democratic margins in Philadelphia and suburbs hold, Biden could recover the 500,000+ vote deficit.
- Michigan and Wisconsin are similarly delayed due to rules requiring mail-in ballot tabulation to begin only after polls close.
- Michigan & Wisconsin: Trump leading in early counts (55-44 in Michigan, 51-47 in Wisconsin) due to the count of election-day votes in rural/suburban areas; major urban centers (Detroit, Milwaukee) have not yet reported.
- Reports indicate Detroit and Milwaukee will not release tallies until the following morning, leaving these states "up in the air."
- Arizona: Initially called for Biden by Fox News and others, but the margin is tight with significant mail-in ballots still to be counted.
- 76% of votes reported; Trump performs better on election-day votes, creating uncertainty until all in-person votes are tallied.
- Georgia: A statistical dead heat with Trump leading slightly, but 400,000+ votes outstanding in Atlanta and suburbs.
- DeKalb, Fulton, and Cobb counties (pro-Democrat) are at varying reporting stages (31%, 58%, 70%); if these trend 70-80% Biden, it could swing the state.
- Runoff election required for the Senate seat between Warnock and Loeffler if neither wins 50%.
Voting Trends, Pollster Failures, and Demographic Shifts
- Pollster Failure: Pollsters and media outlets significantly underestimated Trump's support, failing to capture the "shy Trump voter" or the shift in key demographics.
- SurveyMonkey data indicates a failure to adjust sufficiently for education levels and a misunderstanding of the post-graduate vs. college-grad divide.
- David Sacks and others note that Trump's "cult of personality" and fanatical base mobilized in ways polls missed.
- Lockdowns as a Primary Issue: The enforcement of COVID-19 lockdowns is identified as a major driver of Trump's performance in the Rust Belt.
- Voters in Michigan, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania cited economic hardship from lockdowns as a primary reason for supporting Trump.
- SurveyMonkey data shows a split where Trump supporters view the crisis as financial, while the general public views it as health-related.
- Demographic Diversification: Trump's coalition proved more diverse than the "white, working-class male" narrative suggested.
- Stronger-than-expected support among Black men, Hispanic men, and Cuban-Americans in Florida.
- The "woke left" and identity politics are described as alienating voters in the Midwest and rural areas.
- Cancel Culture and Censorship: Allegations of censorship by tech companies (Twitter, Facebook) regarding the New York Post story and other critical content fueled a vote against "coastal elites."
- Brad Gerstner and others argue voters are rejecting the "sanctimony" of urban elites who dismiss rural concerns.
Future Outlook and Potential Scenarios
- Scenario 1 (Landslide Biden): Ruled out; not happening.
- Scenario 2 (Trump Landslide): Possible but unlikely given the tightness in swing states.
- Scenario 3 (Soft Landing): Most likely scenario discussed; Biden wins the presidency, but Republicans retain the Senate.
- This outcome creates gridlock, preventing radical policy changes but stabilizing the economy.
- Markets are pricing in this outcome as a "risk-off" event that resolves uncertainty without a "blue wave."
- Scenario 4 (The "Shit Show"): A contested election with no clear winner for days or weeks.
- Trump has already tweeted of a "big win," raising the risk of legal battles if the final count favors Biden.
- Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin are likely to require recounting, potentially extending results until late November or early December.
- California Ballot Initiatives:
- Prop 22 (gig worker classification) appears set to pass, creating a "third way" between W-2 employment and independent contracting.
- Prop 15 (commercial property tax increase) is projected to fail.
- San Francisco city-level initiatives are described as "disasters," with all passing measures viewed negatively by business leaders.
Senate and Governor Races
- Senate Outlook: Leans Republican with key wins in Iowa, Maine, and North Carolina.
- Michigan and Montana are in danger for Democrats.
- A Republican Senate would force compromise on legislation, preventing a "radical left" agenda.
- Governor Races: Lindsey Graham won in South Carolina; Susan Collins held her seat in Maine.
- Hickenlooper: Won re-election in Colorado.
Quotes and Key Observations
- On Pollsters: "The pollsters were miles off on this... they didn't understand the Latin, or I guess Latinx... Cubans, Puerto Ricans, Mexicans, these are different countries."
- On Lockdowns: "Lockdowns is the biggest reason why [Trump wins the Rust Belt]... it hurts people... it's the only reason why Michigan and Wisconsin would ever be in play."
- On the Economy: "If Trump wins or Republicans hold the Senate... the market is voting on the fact that corporate taxes are not going to go up."
- On the "Soft Landing": "Scenario three is starting to look very possible: a Biden president and a Republican Senate... you can sleep soundly with that."
- On Biden's Character: "If Biden wins... the radical left gets a big rebuke... we have basically divided government in Washington... the temperature would go down."
- On Censorship: "Twitter doubled down on censorship after the hearing... Jack Dorsey will become the poster child for this new censorship."