Edge cases of sentience & how to act ethically despite massive uncertainty | Jonathan Birch
Jonathan Birch, Luisa Rodriguez
Philosopher Jonathan Birch presents a precautionary framework in *The Edge of Sentience* that mandates proportionate moral action based on the realistic possibility of suffering in beings ranging from human fetuses and invertebrates to neural organoids and advanced AI. Drawing on evidence of diagnostic errors in disorders of consciousness and the suffering of species like octopuses and bees, Birch argues for abandoning rigid classifications in favor of a duty to avoid gratuitous harm even amidst scientific uncertainty. This approach has already influenced UK legislation to include crustaceans and cephalopods in welfare protections while recommending a shift toward citizen-led deliberation and proactive regulation for emerging technologies like brain emulation.